A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

DH #165 - 12-26-25 - Shoveling Snow on Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
December 29, 2025
Duration
3:32
Lecture code
RDT-283

Shoveling Snow and Muktzeh

  • The question of shoveling snow to leave home for the Beit Knesset or to go to another person’s home for a Shabbat meal applies only where there is an eruv. Without an eruv, carrying a shovel, moving snow, or throwing snow in the public domain would be asur.
  • Rav Moshe Feinstein ruled in Volume 5 of Igrot Moshe that snow is muktzeh because it is nolad.
  • Most poskim, however, ruled that snow is not subject to the din of nolad. This is the ruling of Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchatah by Neuwirth, in accordance with Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, and of Hacham Ovadia Yosef in Yalkut Yosef.
  • The reasoning is that, just as ice that melts in a cup may be drunk and is not considered nolad, a natural change in form—such as snow becoming liquid—is not an isur of nolad. Accordingly, snow is not muktzeh according to this ruling.
  • A person may therefore shovel a path to clear snow and go to the Beit Knesset to perform a mitzvah. There is also no issue of melting snow: the person is only moving it out of the way, and any melting that happens on its own is indirect.
  • A person may walk in the snow.

Snow Play and Help from a Non-Jew

  • Most poskim ruled that making a snowman is asur: it may constitute something more permanent, like building, or compacting the snow may be an issue of melting it to create a form.
  • Since shoveling is permissible for a Jew, a person may have a non-Jew shovel the walkway and allow the non-Jew to continue. If the non-Jew independently chooses to use a mechanical snowplow, truck, or similar equipment, that is the non-Jew’s choice and is not a violation for the Jew.

Ice, Clothing, and the Scope of Shoveling

  • A person may spread salt on ice on the ground, even though it will melt the ice, because the melting takes some time and the ice is a hazard. This may be done to prevent someone from slipping, falling, or being harmed, and to enable the person to perform the mitzvah.
  • If snow gets on a person’s clothing, they may gently shake it off or remove it, but should not press hard and squeeze it out of the garment.
  • A person should avoid shoveling areas they do not need, to avoid unnecessary strenuous activity on Shabbat. Shoveling should be limited to what is needed to leave the house, go to the Beit Knesset, or avoid harm; shoveling out cars and other unnecessary areas should be avoided.
  • Shoveling snow is not choresh: the snow is above ground, so the person is not digging into the ground itself.

The Shovel

  • A regular shovel would typically be muktzeh as a kli shemelachto le'isur, a utensil whose normal use is for something forbidden, such as digging into the ground.
  • A snow shovel is designed to move snow rather than dig into the ground. In addition, a kli shemelachto le'isur may be used le'tzorech gufo for another need that is permissible. Since the shovel is being used for a permissible purpose rather than its normal forbidden function, its use in this case is not a violation of muktzeh.