A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eli Mansour

Sefer Hachinuch

Misva #430: Birkat Ha’mazon

Lectured by Rabbi Eli Mansour

Published
April 5, 2023
Duration
12:04

Lecture Text

The Torah in Parashat Ekeb (Debarim 8:8) commands, “Ve’achalta Ve’sabata U’berachta Et Hashem Elokecha” – “You shall eat, you shall be satiated, and you shall bless Hashem your G-d.” This verse establishes the well-known Misva of Birkat Ha’mazon – to recite a special blessing after eating a satiating quantity of bread made from one of the five principal grains (wheat, barley, spelt, rye and oats), to thank G-d for the blessing of food.

In discussing this Misva, the Sefer Ha’hinuch elaborates on the meaning of the phrase “Baruch At Hashem” (literally, “You are blessed”), teaching us the fundamental concept underlying the recitation of Berachot. He explains that when we say, “Baruch Ata Hashem,” we are acknowledging that G-d is the source of all blessing. Hashem has given the human being dominion over the natural world, and He wants us to be worthy of enjoying the benefits that the world has to offer. When we recite “Baruch” and acknowledge that Hashem is the source of blessing, from whom all blessings originate, and that only He controls the world and bestows blessing upon people, we become worthy of His blessings. Reciting a Beracha is, in a sense, the key to accessing G-d’s blessings, as it is through the recognition of Hashem as the source of all blessings that we earn them.

The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that in the Amida prayer, after requesting what we need – such as wisdom, forgiveness, and health – we recite a concluding Beracha to express gratitude. Otherwise, we would resemble a servant who received a gift from his master and then left without expressing appreciation, which would, of course, be disrespectful.

The Sefer Ha’hinuch also discusses in this context the word “Yitbarach” (“He shall be blessed”), which we recite in Kaddish. He understands this word as a prayer asking that Hashem inspire all His creatures to recognize that He is the source of all blessing and goodness. We hope and pray that just as we acknowledge Hashem’s exclusive control over the universe, that He is “Baruch” – the source of blessing – the rest of mankind should similarly arrive at this belief and awareness.

The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains on this basis the teaching of the Sages that Hashem “desires” the prayers of the righteous. The righteous bring blessing to the world through their recognition of Hashem as the source of all blessings, and therefore, Hashem, who desires that mankind should be deserving of blessing, cherishes the prayers of the righteous.

This should be our intention whenever we recite a Beracha – that we acknowledge Hashem as the source of all blessings in the world, through which we earn access to His infinite blessings.

The Sefer Ha’hinuch concludes this part of his discussion by noting that there are deeper, Kabbalistic understandings of the word “Baruch,” but in this work, which he composed for his son, he limited himself to the straightforward, easily understood concepts behind the recitation of Berachot.

Birkat Ha’mazon is unique, in that it is the only, or one of the only, Berachot which are required Mi’de’Orayta – on the level of Torah obligation. The rest of the Berachot – including the Berachot recited before eating, and the Beracha Aharona blessings recited after consuming products other than bread – were instituted by the Sages.

The Gemara explains that the Rabbis established the requirement of Beracha Rishona – reciting a Beracha before eating or drinking – because it is improper to derive enjoyment from this world before acknowledging Hashem as the provider of this enjoyment. Moreover, the Gemara comments, if the Torah requires reciting a Beracha after experiencing the enjoyment of eating, then Kal Va’homer (all the more so) one should recite a blessing when he experiences hunger and prepares to eat. It emerges, then, that each time we recite a Beracha before eating, we follow a Halacha established via a Kal Va’homer line of reasoning. The Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909) taught that when we observe a law established through a Kal Va’homer, we arouse Hashem’s kindness and compassion. Every morning, we recite the Berayta of Rabbi Yishmael which lists the thirteen rules through which Halachot are extracted from the text of the Torah, the first of which is Kal Va’homer. The Ben Ish Hai writes that these thirteen rules correspond to G-d’s thirteen attributes of mercy. Specifically, the rule of Kal Va’homer corresponds to the attribute of “Kel,” which signifies the pinnacle of divine kindness, as indicated by the verse, “Hesed Kel Kol Ha’yom” (“The kindness of G-d is all day” – Tehillim 52:3). Thus, whenever we observe a law deduced through a Kal Va’homer, we bring upon ourselves G-d’s abundant kindness. It follows, then, that each time we recite a Beracha before eating, we activate G-d’s kindness, since the requirement to recite a Beracha before eating is established on the basis of a Kal Va’homer.

According to the Sefer Ha’hinuch and a number of other Rishonim, there is also another Beracha which is required on the level of Biblical obligation – Birkat Ha’Torah, the blessing we recite each morning over Torah study. The Sefer Ha’hinuch raises the question of why the Beracha over Torah learning is recited before we begin learning, but the Beracha over food (which is required by the Torah) is recited only after we eat. If the Torah commanded reciting blessings over food and over Torah, why did it draw this distinction, requiring one Beracha before enjoying the blessing and the other Beracha after experiencing the blessing?

The Sefer Ha’hinuch answers that there is a basic difference between physical enjoyment and spiritual enjoyment. Physical enjoyment is not appreciated until it is experienced, and so the Torah requires reciting a Beracha after eating and receiving enjoyment from food. The intellectual and spiritual benefits of learning Torah, however, can be recognized and appreciated even before the experience, and so the Beracha over Torah study is recited before we begin learning.

The Sefer Ha’hinuch concludes his lengthy discussion of the Misva of Birkat Ha’mazon with what has become one of the most famous passages in the entire work. He writes (listen to audio recording for precise citation): “Such have I received from my rabbis, may the Almighty protect them – that whoever is careful with regard to Birkat Ha’mazon, his sustenance is made available to him with dignity throughout his life.” Ensuring to fulfill this Misva properly brings a person financial blessing. The Mishna Berura adds that those who are especially meticulous in their Halachic observance make a point of reciting Birkat Ha’mazon from a Siddur. A number of Rabbis taught that Birkat Ha’mazon should be recited sitting, as alluded to in the phrase, “Ve’sabata U’berachta,” which could be read as, “Ve’sheb Et U’berachta” – “And sit at the time when you bless.” Furthermore, the Arizal (Rav Yishak Luria, Safed, 1534-1572) writes that the Sadikim would wear their overcoat and hat for the recitation of Birkat Ha’mazon.

This Misva applies in all times and places, and is binding upon both men and women, though the Gemara comments that it is uncertain whether women are required to recite Birkat Ha’mazon on the level of Torah obligation. One who neglected to recite Birkat Ha’mazon after eating a satiating quantity of bread has transgressed this