Compassion, the Search for Truth, and Life Beyond Imagination
- The eulogy connected Mr. Ellis with the verse, “O God, give Your judgments to the king, and Your righteousness to the king’s son.” He lived with the responsibility of a king and his son, showing compassion for the poor and needy and taking joy in helping them.
- The Torah portion describes Moses receiving the tablets, followed by the people’s fear that he would not return. The Midrash, as recounted in the eulogy, says that the people sinned through this episode and were punished through it: their hearts were grieved and broken. They were ultimately comforted by the words, “This is our God; we have hoped in Him, and He will save us.”
- The episode illustrates the difference between imagination and reality. When the Satan showed the people an image of Moses and led them to imagine that he would not return, they suffered for that mistaken belief. They found comfort when they saw the reality: “This is our God.”
- Mr. Ellis, despite his success in family, business, and public life, understood that there was a struggle between imagination and truth. He pursued truth by seeking ה׳: “Everyone who sought ה׳ went out to the Tent of Meeting, which was outside the camp.” When he encountered the truth, he made great sacrifices and surrounded himself with Torah scholars and rabbis, learning daily with private teachers and devoting himself to growth in Torah.
- He lived by the words, “I have set ה׳ before me always; I will not be ashamed before those who mock me.” Although some in the community did not understand his path and wondered whether he had left it, he knew what he was doing, and people continued to respect him.
- The eulogy connected his path to the haftarah’s account of Elijah asking, “How long will you waver between two opinions?” and mocking the people who called to their god. Mr. Ellis, by contrast, chose the path of true reality and continued to keep ה׳ before him.
- After Elijah said, “Come near to me,” he repaired the ruined altar of ה׳. Mr. Ellis likewise devoted himself to repairing and strengthening Torah: building yeshivot and supporting Torah scholars. His aspirations extended especially to his family. He wanted all his sons to become Torah scholars and produce heads of yeshivot; despite many struggles, he worked toward that goal and established a distinguished family.
- The eulogy described his family through the verse, “All your children will be students of ה׳, and great will be the peace of your children.” It also noted that he departed on Purim, having left many blessings and a legacy to carry forward, and that he consistently sought the highest level in Torah and fear of Heaven.
- He joined Agudath Israel because he saw Torah scholars, a Torah-oriented community, and a community that accepted Torah authority and listened to the great Torah leaders. He also became attached to the books of Aronson, understanding their work as being for the benefit of all Israel.
- The community, the eulogy said, owed Mr. Ellis a great deal, including gratitude for the privilege of helping him and his family. His example showed that a person could overcome an imagined reality and seek truth at any cost—going “outside the camp” to seek ה׳ while still remaining within the camp and achieving a Torah-centered goal.
- After quietly enduring suffering for close to ten years, he was described as having attained a great level in the World to Come. The eulogy spoke of the honor of ה׳—the honor of Torah—that he had prepared through upholding Torah and establishing a Torah family, and expressed hope that he would rest and rise to his lot in the Land of Israel at the end of days.
Suffering, Torah, and the World to Come
- The Gemara in Berachot teaches that Torah, the Land of Israel, and the World to Come are acquired through suffering. The eulogy raised the question of what it means to acquire the World to Come through suffering after a person has already merited Torah and the Land of Israel.
- Its explanation was that some suffering brings neither Torah nor prayer, but serves as a person’s final preparation for the World to Come.
- The eulogist recalled that his father lay for 130 days, sometimes conscious and sometimes unconscious. When Rav Shlomo visited, he said that perhaps, amid all the distress, there might be one profound thought that would deepen the sanctification of life retroactively. The yeshivah, too, had gone through years of such hardship.
- The eulogy compared this suffering to a final washing and immersion before entering the World to Come. It said that people who have completed their task may undergo this preparation, whereas the wicked will not benefit from such suffering.
Mr. Ellis’s Support for Rabbi Yosef and Torah Communities
- The verse “Your righteousness goes before You” was applied to the merit of Mr. Ellis. When the Gaon, Rabbi Yosef Raffoul, boldly left the established camp and established a camp of God, the move seemed strange to many. The eulogist recalled spending nearly an hour and a half explaining Rabbi Yosef’s purpose to people from the established community.
- The Mishnah asks, “Who is wise? One who sees what is coming.” The Sages compare Torah scholars to watchmen on towers, able to see what will happen thirty years ahead while others do not know what will happen in two weeks.
- Mr. Ellis, though a man of means, had the courage to devote himself wholeheartedly to Rabbi Yosef and become his right hand. His path remained clear even when leaving the established camp could discourage people who were seeking truth.
- One example of his practical approach came at a celebration for Yeshivat Kol Yaakov at a restaurant. The restaurant owner explained that he did business with many non-Jews and was invited to more popular restaurants, but wondered what to do about kashrut. Mr. Ellis had made an agreement with the restaurant’s owner, whom he loved. The owner took pride in inviting prominent guests, even the prime minister, and regarded Mr. Ellis’s presence as though he had invited him into his home and his wife had cooked for him. The story was offered as an example of fear of Heaven that did not mean withdrawing from life: Mr. Ellis followed the ways of the world with worldly wisdom.
- Rabbi David had told the eulogist that Mr. Ellis’s connection with Rabbi Yosef went back generations. Mr. Ellis’s father, Hamsalan, had consulted their grandfathers, Rabbi Avraham Ades and Rabbi Ezra Raffoul, who advised him to go to Colombia for outreach. He went with a rabbi from their community, did outreach there, and established a mikveh for public benefit. Earlier, they had arranged matters in Livorno according to the prayer books.
- This history was presented as an example of Torah seeking its own: Mr. Ellis’s father, having become close to the grandparents, later stood beside Rabbi Yosef. The eulogy attributed such merit in part to the merit of ancestors.
- The eulogy pointed to observant sons and children, grandchildren in yeshivot, and a great love of Torah in Brooklyn, New York. Fifty years earlier, the situation had been far less encouraging. The transformation was attributed to the merit of Rabbi Yosef’s ancestors and Mr. Ellis, whose understanding of Torah study and devotion to Torah bore fruit.
- Mr. Ellis was described as setting an example for the Sephardic Torah world, recalling the Torah, holiness, and Torah for its own sake that the eulogist had seen in his father and uncle and heard about from them. The eulogy prayed that the merit of Mr. Ellis would stand by his wife, descendants, family, Torah scholars, communities, and all the Jewish people.
A Seeker of ה׳ and a Pioneer in Brooklyn
- The verse, “Moses took the tent and pitched it outside the camp, far from the camp. And everyone who sought ה׳ went out to the Tent of Meeting,” was explained in its setting: after the giving of the Torah, the people had not yet learned Torah or the mitzvot, so a person had to be a seeker of ה׳ and go to Moses’s tent outside the camp.
- Mr. Ellis was called a seeker of ה׳, as the Gaon, Rabbi Ades, had described him. Thirty years earlier, the community had been one camp: good Jews who did not study Torah. Mr. Ellis was a pioneer with tremendous faith. When people saw one camp facing another, they recognized a camp of Torah, fear of Heaven, and genuine Torah scholars, devoted to growing in Torah and fear of Heaven.
- Mr. Ellis and Rabbi Yosef were described as being “in the shadow of wisdom, in the shadow of wealth.” Mr. Ellis’s name was displayed proudly in places throughout the Land of Israel, reflecting his role in establishing a world of Torah.
- Nearly twenty years earlier, on Shabbat, Mr. Ellis had asked the eulogist’s father to bless him that all his grandchildren would become heads of yeshivot. The father blessed him, and several of his grandchildren did become heads of yeshivot. The eulogy connected this to the merit earned by honoring Torah scholars and generously supporting Torah.
- The community and its Torah scholars had suffered a great loss. Mr. Ellis strengthened every avrech, urging them to learn and pursue what they loved, and established many study partnerships. He was called the generation’s Zevulun—and perhaps both its Zevulun and Yissachar.
Torah as the Precious Vessel
- Rabbi Tanchuma’s teaching was cited: “There is gold and an abundance of pearls, but a precious vessel is wise speech.” The gold refers to the contributions for the Mishkan; the pearls refer to the princes’ precious stones. Moses was distressed that he had brought nothing, but God told him that Moses’s speech was dearer than all the contributions, and that of all the people, God called only Moses: “And He called to Moses.”
- The eulogy emphasized that even spiritual gold and pearls brought by the princes were worth less than one utterance of Moses in the Torah. It used this teaching to describe the value of Mr. Ellis’s own Torah learning.
- For more than twenty-two years, whenever he was in the city, Mr. Ellis came daily at his appointed time to learn and pray. The eulogist recalled seeing him, five minutes after seven when prayers began, with a Gemara in one hand and his tefillin in the other.
- He also learned on holidays. In a regular class on the laws of each festival, they studied Rambam and Shulchan Aruch and worked to understand the Rambam. Mr. Ellis asked questions and learned about Pesach, Shavuot, Sukkot, and the other festivals. He also had other study partners and regular learning sessions.
- His Torah learning elevated him, while his charity made him a Zevulun who supported Torah. The eulogy applied “And He called to Moses” to him, saying that the Creator had called him through the Torah he had embraced.
- A Midrash teaches that a person has three names: the name given by one’s parents, the name by which people call one, and the name one earns. The teaching is illustrated by Bezalel son of Uri, of the tribe of Judah, and Oholiab son of Ahisamach, of the tribe of Dan, and by the words, “I have called you by name.” Mr. Ellis’s parents called him Eliyahu; people called him Mr. Ellis; through his own choices, he earned a name by elevating himself and his community.
- The eulogy said that the community would miss his presence, Torah, careful observance of mitzvot, beautiful etrog, finest matzot, and beautiful tefillin, all selected with the care of a Torah scholar.
Torah, Prayer, and Acts of Kindness
- The English eulogy invoked the teaching that the world stands on Torah, service, and acts of kindness. Mr. Safdeye began learning Torah when he was over fifty. After tasting Torah, he decided that he wanted it for his family.
- He changed course in midlife despite having wealth, family, health, and a leading position in the community. He began learning Chumash, Mishnah, Rambam, and Gemara, and had a study partner for twenty-two years. His nightly and weekend study partners in New York included heads of yeshivot. He sat with them without embarrassment, learning patiently until he understood, because he believed he had to set an example for his children and grandchildren.
- In service, he never missed a day of prayer alongside his Torah study. He chose to pray at Ateret Torah and joined the young men there. On Shabbat, he walked in rain and snow; he wanted his children and grandchildren to be there, and wanted to be there himself.
- In acts of kindness, he thought about how to help Torah scholars, poor students, widows, and families celebrating a bar mitzvah. He considered how to arrange his accounts and coordinate with the Israeli group so that help reached the places where he worked with those groups.
- The eulogist urged yeshivah students to consider what it means to persevere in learning when one has little strength. Mr. Ellis, after traveling to the Orient for two weeks and returning exhausted from a flight, would call from his car and ask for forty-five minutes before he was ready to learn. He was almost twice the eulogist’s age at the time.
- Before Pesach, Mr. Ellis asked the eulogist to find people who could not afford a Seder but wanted to attend. Although the venue was full, he insisted that they look for such people and did not want anyone to know he was helping. The eulogist brought fifteen people—fifteen families—and Mr. Ellis paid for Pesach. He allowed his own boss to become a partner in the effort rather than insisting on taking sole credit.
- The same account recalled that before entering a Manhattan restaurant, Mr. Ellis had called to ask whether its kashrut was acceptable. His concern for others and his attention to kashrut were presented together as parts of his way of life.

