A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
. Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Torah Lecture

Funeral of the Sasson Family in Israel

Lectured by . Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Published
March 24, 2015
Duration
103:25
Lecture code
LAS-61

Opening Readings and the Occasion

  • The opening readings included Psalm 90, reflecting on human mortality: a person’s years are seventy, or eighty with strength, and pass amid toil and trouble. It asks God to teach people to number their days and to show compassion.
  • Psalm 91 speaks of refuge under the protection of the Most High, and Proverbs 31 praises the woman of valor for her strength, wisdom, kindness, and fear of the Lord.
  • The opening speaker said they would recite a poem for Yom Kippur in which a person expresses the desire to depart from this world. He described the children as righteous and innocent, destined for the Garden of Eden. The poem is attributed to Rabbi Moses ibn Ezra, though some say Rabbi Judah Halevi composed it.
  • He called the occasion extremely difficult but said it also contained much sanctification of God’s name. It was taking place on Shabbat Parashat Vayikra, when young children begin studying the parashah and its sacrifices, which purify and, as it were, protect Israel.
  • Referring to the upcoming account of Nadav and Avihu, who were consumed by fire, he recalled Moses’ words to Aaron: “Through those who are near Me I will be sanctified, and before all the people I will be glorified.” He cited Moses’ statement that he had thought the event would happen to him, but saw that Aaron was greater. He also invoked the verse about fire catching in thorns and consuming a stack of grain: when the thorns are present, it is the grain stack that is consumed.
  • Returning to Psalm 90, he said the children might have lived seventy, eighty, or even ninety years. Their lives could have been filled not with toil and trouble, but with Torah, mitzvot, and good deeds.
  • He urged the community to strengthen its faith, take stock of itself, and awaken to complete repentance. He emphasized the tragedy’s impact in a city with the world’s largest Jewish population, amid a community rich in Torah, mitzvot, good deeds, and kindness.

Gabriel Sasson’s Eulogy

  • Gabriel Sasson said that the words of the poem expressed his own feelings and the dreams he had for his grandchildren, perhaps seventy or eighty of them.
  • He interpreted the Song of Songs verse, “My beloved went down to his garden … and gather lilies,” as referring to the righteous. The Holy One, blessed be He, gathers a lily at the height of its beauty, before it withers, and takes the righteous person at the height of his righteousness.
  • He described the children as seven lilies. From their earliest months through their growing years, up to the age of seventeen, he had seen new peaks of development, with each child opening like a flower. He said he had not known children could be such a treasure.
  • He noted that eulogies are generally forbidden in Nisan except for Torah scholars, but said he believed a eulogy was permitted here because the children were a communal sacrifice.
  • Citing the Midrash on “Moses erected the Tabernacle,” he explained that the word “the” points to an additional Tabernacle: when the Tabernacle was erected below, one was also erected above. Rabbi Simon says that the heavenly Tabernacle is that of the angel called “Youth,” where the angel offers the souls of the righteous to atone for Israel during exile. Gabriel said that since there is no Tabernacle below today, the heavenly Tabernacle and the sacrifices of the righteous are needed.
  • He connected their deaths on the New Moon with the New Moon offering, which includes “two young bulls, one ram, and seven year-old lambs, unblemished.” In his interpretation, the two bulls represented him and his wife, the ram represented the story that was stopped, and the seven lambs represented the children. He named Eliyan, Malka, David, Yehoshua, Moshe, and Sarah as unblemished lambs.
  • He reflected on the moon’s renewal. Rashi asks why the account of Creation first says that God made “two great luminaries,” but then calls one the greater and the other the lesser. A Midrash explains that the moon complained that two rulers could not share one crown; God agreed that it should diminish itself, and it became small, renewing each month until full.
  • The moon has no light of its own; it reflects the sun’s light. Gabriel applied this image to people: although God wants each person to build a dream, path, and world, everything ultimately comes from God. Reflecting God’s light requires humility, because people cannot understand the larger plan or compare their own understanding and desires with what God will build.
  • Gabriel recalled his hopes for the children: he had begun learning a page of Gemara each day with his oldest son, who wanted to complete the Talmud before marriage. Each child had a way of serving God joyfully, and Torah and mitzvot were the greatest source of joy in the home. He had believed this was the holiest correction one could make, and said he would have answered the same way even now.
  • Yet God’s plan was different: the children were taken as a sacrifice at the height of their beauty. Gabriel said he could not endure the tragedy or strengthen his wife and daughter without humility and acceptance that there was a plan he could not understand.
  • He described his wife’s self-sacrifice, including how, while badly burned, she jumped from a second-floor window to reach the neighbors and ask for help saving the children. He said she had devoted herself to them from the day they married and continued to think only of their service of God.
  • He said people in Israel called the children angels, while in the United States they were examples in every class and brought ideas of holiness from Jerusalem.
  • He asked that the sacrifice not be in vain and that all Israel take a message from it and repent. Every child, he said, is a whole world, pure and holy, and children must be loved and given attention.
  • He recalled a story the Chafetz Chaim told about a woman whose children were killed in the Spanish expulsion. She said that she had previously divided her love between God and her children, but from then on it would all be God’s. Gabriel said he did not accept that formulation: love of children, spouses, and every person is itself an aspect of love of God and sanctification of God’s name. God is present in this sacrifice, though its meaning will only be seen in the future.
  • He developed the moon image further: the moon represents relationship and kingship, binding all parts together. Israel is compared to the moon because the people are one; each person’s joy and sorrow belong to everyone. Seeing oneself only as an individual in competition with others prevents one from understanding the situation, while humility and submission to God allow a person to see himself as part of all Israel.
  • From the individual perspective, he said, the children were lost; but they now live in the hearts of people and continue to influence them. He did not know what decrees their influence may have annulled, but said the opening of the Jewish people’s hearts was their portion and their continuing life.
  • He could not speak about each child individually. He prayed that the atonement associated with the New Moon would not be in vain: if hearts remain open and Israel is united, there will be no need for further decrees or tragedies. The Tabernacle is meant to bring the Divine Presence to earth; if people are united, that unity itself is the Divine Presence and no sacrifice is needed. Israel must remember that it is one and nullify itself for one another.

Rabbi Bakshi-Doron on Repentance and the Father’s Strength

  • Rabbi Bakshi-Doron said there were no words that could explain or justify the terrible decree, and rejected the claim that the tragedy could simply be explained as the result of the family’s sins.
  • He cited the Gemara’s teaching about thunder and lightning: extraordinary events are meant to straighten the crookedness of the heart and shake people awake. He applied this to the tragedy and quoted, “Let us search and examine our ways, and return to the Lord.”
  • He called the children a communal sacrifice because they were innocent and holy. Referring to “Aaron was silent,” he said the Sages teach that Aaron restrained his grief through silence, accepted the judgment, and thereby strengthened others. He urged the community to return in complete repentance and unite.

The Chief Rabbi of Israel on Collective Mourning

  • The Chief Rabbi of Israel described the seven coffins as a terrible loss to the world: each child had a distinct personality, and the family had been diligent in caring for and educating them.
  • He said the mother was in a medical condition and could not join the mourners or comfort them. He also reflected that, just before the Seder, Gabriel could no longer fulfill “You shall tell your son” with Lian, Yehoshua, David, Rivka, Moshe, Sarah, and Yaakov.
  • He prayed for the mother and daughter’s recovery, strength for the family, and an end to harsh decrees and suffering. He asked that the sense of fellowship felt by the Jewish people be experienced through friendship and joy rather than tragedy, and said that only God can comfort them and wipe away tears.

Rabbi Moshe Shapira on the Cry of the Tragedy

  • Rabbi Moshe Shapira said that the departure of the seven pure souls was a cry reaching from one end of the world to the other, beyond language and human comprehension. He invoked the Sages’ words: “Be silent; thus it arose in thought before Him.”
  • He connected the tragedy to “God is awesome from Your sanctuary,” saying that the cry calls people to recognize God’s awesomeness and fear Him.
  • Citing the Gemara in the chapter “HaKones,” he said no calamity comes upon the world except because of the wicked in it, and that the calamity first strikes the righteous. He related this to the verse about fire catching in thorns and consuming a stack of grain: the fire finds thorns, but the grain is consumed; the righteous are struck first.
  • He described the first of Nisan as a day crowned with ten crowns and beloved before God like the day heaven and earth were created. According to Tosafot, creation arose in thought in Tishrei, while the world was created in practice on the first of Nisan. He connected this to the purpose expressed in “God has made it so that people should fear Him.”
  • He cited the Gemara’s account of Rav Yosef weeping when this teaching was stated: “All this, and we are considered as nothing?” Rav Yosef compared people to chaff blown away by the wind.
  • Rabbi Shapira said the tragedy must be taken as a warning: if people fulfill its call to fear God, the calamity that first struck the righteous will be rectified and further suffering may be prevented. He prayed for strength for the family and recovery for the mother and sister.

Rabbi Arshter on the Land of Israel and Communal Mourning

  • Rabbi Arshter said that although eulogies are customarily not given in Nisan, they are given for great Torah scholars; in his view, these seven innocent children, already advanced in Torah and good deeds, could certainly be eulogized.
  • He emphasized that what happens to an individual touches all Israel, in tragedy as in celebration, and that the loss belonged to the whole Jewish people.
  • He connected the event to the eighth day and the first of Nisan, recalling the words about Nadav and Avihu: “Through those who are near Me I will be sanctified,” followed by “all the house of Israel shall bewail the burning that the Lord has kindled.”
  • He said it was painful that the children returned to the Land of Israel in this way, but prayed that “His land shall atone for His people.” He offered prayers for the family’s comfort, the mother and daughter’s recovery, and strength for Gabriel.

Rabbi Avraham Yosef Leizerson on the Schools and the Generation

  • Rabbi Avraham Yosef Leizerson spoke for the children’s classmates at the Chinuch Atzmai school in Sanhedria, describing their shock and grief. He quoted David’s words about remaining silent while pain burned within him, and Jeremiah’s lament over the destruction and the absence of a comforter.
  • He recalled a fire three years earlier, on the same day, at the Sha’ar family home in Rehovot: five children died, as did their father, who rushed to save them.
  • He said the ways of Heaven are hidden and that the Sages compare the death of young men of Israel to the burning of the House of God. He praised Gabriel’s words of faith and described the school community’s grief, including the principal’s tears and the children’s memories of the mother’s daily care.
  • He said the children were not taken because of their own sins, but as an atonement for the sins of the generation, and that the tragedy obligates everyone to respond. He returned to the teaching that thunder straightens the crookedness of the heart, describing this event as seven claps of thunder at once.
  • He told a story about a mother whose children were asleep upstairs during a fire. She called to people to throw stones at them so they would wake and save themselves. He said that, in this tragedy, Israel had not merited to wake and save the children; instead, God was “throwing stones” at the people to awaken them. The tragedy had shaken not only Jews but also the non-Jewish world.
  • He said the schoolchildren and teachers remained stunned, and recalled the family’s hope of returning and raising the children. He prayed that God would gather the tears shed for the children, the “unblemished lambs,” and save Israel from harsh decrees. He asked the children, as righteous souls, to intercede for their family, especially for the mother, daughter, and father, and expressed hope for the Messiah and the resurrection of those who dwell in the dust.

Rabbi Aryeh Rappoport on the Children’s Influence

  • Rabbi Aryeh Rappoport cited the Gemara’s rule that the High Priest may not wear golden garments when entering the Holy of Holies because “a prosecutor cannot become a defender”; the gold could recall the Golden Calf and become an accusation against Israel. Outside the Holy of Holies, he may wear them.
  • He connected this to the rule against sounding a shofar made from a cow’s horn on Rosh Hashanah. Although the shofar is not sounded inside the Holy of Holies, the Gemara explains that because it is sounded for remembrance, it is treated as if it were.
  • He said the shofar blast of the tragedy had not sounded only on that Shabbat night: the children had affected their community for twenty years. Their charm had changed their school and community. He recounted a teacher’s story about the oldest girl asking to sit in front so she could see the teacher better; the teacher kept her in the back because otherwise she would look only at that girl.
  • He related the Gemara’s account of a change in the cow’s blood that permitted it to be sprinkled inside the Holy of Holies, and said the children had likewise changed those around them. He praised the mother’s questions about modesty and how to preserve the children’s way of Torah while living in the United States.
  • Recalling a question by Rabbi Simcha Bunim of Peshischa about Adam receiving a reprieve, he said that even a little life can turn worlds upside down. The world before the tragedy was not the same as the world afterward; the way forward was to live by the children’s example.
  • He explained that the Paschal sacrifice has a separate commandment to eat, in addition to the commandment to slaughter, because eating is also part of a person’s service. Citing the Kotzker, he said God does not ask people to be angels but to be holy people. The children were holy while still behaving as children, and their example could help transform people’s lives.
  • He recalled Gabriel learning with his twelve-year-old son after a full day and praised the parents’ commitment to their children’s education.

Words from the Boys’ School and Classmates

  • A speaker representing the boys’ school addressed David, Yehoshua, and Moishy as members of the group, and quoted, “Your judgments are a great deep.” He explained the image as someone standing above a deep pit, unable to see what is happening below.
  • He remembered David saying with a smile, “We are not parting; we will come back,” and asked how that promise could be understood now.
  • He said Gabriel’s strength was no surprise to those who knew him: he had always insisted on the maximum and persevered through obstacles, especially in the children’s education.
  • He distinguished Gabriel’s silence from the community’s mourning: “Aaron was silent,” but “all the children of Israel shall bewail the burning that the Lord has kindled.” The tragedy was not only Gabriel’s personal sorrow; the community had to mourn and ensure that it did not go to waste.
  • He urged people to learn from both parents’ self-sacrifice by giving greater attention to the children’s modesty and education. He also relayed the children’s request that he say farewell on their behalf and ask their friends to seek mercy for them.

Closing Reflections and Burial Prayers

  • Rabbi Yaakov Ades led a prayer calling for acceptance of the yoke of Heaven, repentance, mercy for the souls of the children, healing and life for the mother and daughter, and salvation for Gabriel and the family.
  • Before the burial, the congregation recited Akavya ben Mahalalel’s teaching to consider one’s origin, destination, and before whom one must give an account. The accompanying verses affirmed that God’s work is just, while acknowledging that human beings cannot see the full measure of His judgments.
  • The family’s request for forgiveness addressed the children by name—Eliyan, Rivka, David, Yehoshua, Sarah, Moshe, and Yaakov—and asked their pardon and atonement on behalf of their family, community, friends, teachers, and classmates. The speaker also declared them forgiven and released.
Words in this lecture1
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras