A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
. Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Torah Lecture

Thirty-Day Memorial for the Azan Family / Hebrew / Rabbi Levy from Arachim

Lectured by . Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Published
January 18, 2018
Duration
08:05
Lecture code
LAS-89

The Meaning of Suffering and the Limits of Comfort

  • Chacham Aharon Levy recalled a question from a woman at an Arachim seminar in the United States, a little over ten years earlier. After his lecture on suffering, she challenged his right to speak about it if he himself had not suffered.
  • He agreed that someone who has not suffered cannot truly offer comfort. He connected this to the criticism of Job’s friends, who tried to explain Job’s suffering philosophically, as the Rambam writes in the Guide.

The Ponevezh Rav’s Response to a Holocaust Survivor

  • About twenty-five years ago, Rabbi Eliyahu Lopian’s son, then an elderly rabbi in Hong Kong, told Levy a story he had heard firsthand.
  • A Jewish Holocaust survivor came to the Ponevezh Rav, Rabbi Yosef Shlomo Kahaneman, who had lost his entire family except for one son in the United States. The survivor asked what could be said about a million innocent children murdered in an unprecedented way.
  • Rather than rebuking him for speaking of loss to someone who had himself lost his family, the Ponevezh Rav stroked his hand and acknowledged that he was right: the souls of the children who had not sinned ascend to the Throne of Glory and, as it were, have a claim against the Master of the Universe. He invoked, “The Rock, His work is perfect, for all His ways are justice.”
  • The Rav then said in Yiddish, as Rabbi Lopian translated it, that, as it were, the Holy One, blessed be He, has no choice but to bring those souls back down to this world; they are the souls of those who return to Torah. The Ponevezh Rav said this thirty years before the baal teshuvah movement began to grow.

The Tragedy as a Communal Sacrifice

  • Levy said that people do not know the ways of Heaven. At the memorial gathering in Israel during the shivah, great rabbis spoke of a “communal sacrifice.” He wondered what the criteria are for distinguishing a communal sacrifice from an individual one, and acknowledged that he did not know whether his own thoughts were correct.
  • He observed that people may instinctively distance themselves from another person’s tragedy. But when tragedy strikes people whose righteousness is widely known, it can make others feel that they, too, have a part in it.
  • Rabbi Avraham and the Rebbetzin, he said, have given, are giving, and will continue to give themselves—body and soul—for the Jewish people. Some of their deeds are known, some will become known, and some of their self-sacrifice will never be known.
  • Levy also spoke of Rabbi Yosef’s generous heart and the warmth with which he greets everyone, including strangers. In such a case, he suggested, the tragedy is understood as communal rather than individual: there is no one to blame, and the community comes and atones.

A Pledge to Improve

  • Levy said that the community could not comfort Yossi, his siblings, or the parents on either side: they had not themselves suffered, and they could not fill the terrible void causing the family’s sorrow.
  • He hoped that those present would pledge, after hearing the rabbis, to improve their own ways, so that their efforts would be for the elevation of the souls.