Grief and the Test of Faith
- Rabbi Yonatan Anava describes the family’s experience as a deep darkness: thirty-two days have passed since the tragedy, and the past month has felt as though the sun has not risen. The family is grieving and praying for the wounded.
- The Midrash relates that Adam was given one test, one mitzvah, and did not withstand it. Later, when Adam saw Cain alive after Cain had sinned, he asked how the Holy One, blessed be He, had let Cain live. Cain told him about repentance, and Adam responded: “A psalm, a song for the Sabbath day: It is good to thank the Lord and sing to Your name, Most High; to declare Your kindness in the morning and Your faithfulness at night.”
- Rabbi Yonatan says that faith is tested in times of darkness, hardship, and night. The community is now being tested: will its prayers, holidays, and customs endure?
- He asks what brings darkness into the world. In the coming Shabbat’s Torah portion, the plague of darkness is described by the words, “One person could not see another.” The Sages, he says, teach that the greatest darkness is failing to see one’s fellow as a brother—seeing him instead as a business rival, someone with a better car, or someone one wants to have less money. Competition, slander, and disputes create this darkness.
- The community in Israel and where they are gathered has shown great warmth and love. Rabbi Yonatan urges everyone to preserve and strengthen that unity, seeing one another as brothers every day, not only in times of grief.
Questions, Faith, and What Is Asked of Us
- The Sages say, “A believer has no questions,” as the great teachers of mussar in recent generations have taught. Rabbi Yonatan acknowledges how difficult this is: people have many questions and cannot understand why such things happen to such a family and community.
- He cites Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, who writes that it is permissible to ask questions about the Holy One, blessed be He; asking does not contradict faith. The questions arise because people do not understand and are too small to comprehend the Creator’s works.
- Just as people do not understand how the world is governed and moves, how a person grows, or what occurs in creation and the plant world, they do not understand the deeds of the Holy One, blessed be He, when those deeds seem so difficult.
- Moses asked, “Why have You dealt ill with this people?” If even the greatest of the prophets did not understand, Rabbi Yonatan says, people today may also not understand. They must nevertheless recognize what is being asked of them.
The Story of a Father’s Last Call
- Rabbi Yonatan tells of a medical volunteer at Shaare Zedek Medical Center. As he was about to leave, a nurse asked him to visit a man who could not speak or communicate and was near death, so that he might say the Shema with him or do what is customary before a Jew dies.
- The volunteer went to the patient’s room and tried to get a response, but nothing worked. The nurse explained that the man had been there for several years and did not speak.
- The patient suddenly looked at the ceiling and said that he was leaving the world and regretted that his son David was not there. He began recalling how David, as a boy, had accompanied him to synagogue and studied Torah with him.
- When David was nine, his mother became ill and went to Boston for months of difficult treatment. David had begged her to promise she would return and recover. Although the surgery was successful, she died and was brought back to the Holy Land in a coffin. At her grave, David cried, “Mom, you promised you’d come back—not in a coffin.”
- The father said that David then began to decline, spent time with neighborhood children, and eventually left Torah and mitzvot. When his father reminded him that he had promised his mother he would be righteous, David replied that his mother had also made a promise and had not kept it, so he did not want to keep his.
- The father began to cry. When the volunteer asked whether he wanted to speak with David, the man agreed and gave him David’s number. David had emigrated to the United States and opened a diamond business.
- The volunteer called repeatedly, but the line was busy and David did not answer. The father asked what had happened; when told David was not answering, he lowered his head and died.
- A few minutes later, David called back. The volunteer told him to recite the blessing of the True Judge because his father had died. David screamed and cried; he and his father had not spoken for years. He came to Israel for the funeral and asked the volunteer what his father had done in his final moments—whether he had recited Psalms or studied Mishnah.
- The volunteer told him that his father had called him. David then remembered that, while the calls were coming, he had been occupied with a diamond deal and arguing over its price.
Turning the Tragedy into Commitment
- Rabbi Yonatan says the community is in a similar situation. He does not know why Luza and the children were chosen, but invokes the words, “These candles are sacred, and we have no permission to use them.” He says the Holy One, blessed be He, is calling the community and wants something from it; this did not happen for nothing.
- His mother-in-law wrote in a letter: “Master of the Universe, if this sacrifice had to be made, thank You for choosing my family. But I ask for one thing: that it not be for nothing.”
- Rabbi Yonatan urges each person, especially the community, congregation, and rabbi’s family, to take stock and identify where they can improve. The response should not be limited to charity: it should include practical action to increase peace between people and strengthen Torah, mitzvot, and good deeds.
- After speaking with his brother-in-law Yosef, Rabbi Yonatan heard about the many mitzvot, joy, and holiness associated with Luza and the children. Their loss has left the world with fewer mitzvot, less modesty, and less holiness. He calls on the community to try to fill what is missing and show that their sacrifice was not in vain.
- He asks every person to take on one small commitment and carry it out in remembrance of Luza and the children.
The Rabbi and the Community
- Rabbi Yonatan says that he joined the family nineteen years ago. He and his family are Israelis and were also privileged to be part of the Damascus community, but he says he had not fully understood how fortunate he was to join the rabbi’s family.
- Over the past month, he has seen his father-in-law as “not a human being; it is an angel.” He says the community has been blessed with a great leader of Israel, marked by character and faith. The great rabbis who came to strengthen and comfort the family left more strengthened than when they arrived.
- He urges the community, especially in the Holy Land, to value what it has and to strengthen unity. He asks his father-in-law’s forgiveness for not having appreciated sooner how extraordinary he is, and says that the Holy One, blessed be He, has planted a Jew who can do this work.
- On the eve of Rabbi Yonatan’s departure, great rabbis in Israel, Ashkenazim and Sephardim alike, independently decided to write letters of encouragement and support for the rabbi, the community, and the building of a place for the community. He emphasizes that this was not because of the tragedy: the rabbis came to the shivah, saw the community members gathered there—including some who no longer looked like members of the community—and bowed their heads and kissed the rabbi’s hand.
- Rabbi Yonatan says that Rabbi Lau, Rabbi Silberstein, and Rabbi Attiya each told him that only his father-in-law can uplift and unite everyone.
- He concludes that the family and community are believers, children of believers. As the rabbis said, Luza and the children are with them and will be present at their celebrations: Luza will bring Shilat to the wedding, not in body, perhaps, but certainly in soul.

