A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Mr. Sam Gindi - Heard from R' Avigdor Miller zt"l

Torah Lecture

Hashem Did Not Allow Us to Go Through Esav's Land! Saving Us from Assimilation!

Lectured by Mr. Sam Gindi - Heard from R' Avigdor Miller zt"l

Published
July 10, 2025
Duration
7:17
Lecture code
SG-47

The Sun, Torah, and Listening to the Parasha

  • Mr. Sam Gindi begins by reflecting on the sun’s energy: sunlight sustains life, and the food people eat, their senses, movement, and vitality all ultimately depend on that energy.
  • He recommends taking 10 deep breaths of fresh air, which he says oxygenate the blood, lift the spirit, and encourage a positive attitude ahead of Shabbat.
  • He urges listeners to live with the parashat HaShavua, because Hashem speaks personally through the world and especially through Torah; recognizing this creates both a privilege and an obligation to listen carefully.
  • He cites the Gemara’s teaching in the name of Rebbe Yehuda HaNasi not to miss a day in the Beit Midrash: that day may bring essential instruction or information, even salvation.

Bnei Yisrael and Edom

  • Mr. Gindi describes the Bnei Yisrael as weary after leaving Mitzrayim and enduring hardship in the desert, including relying on man from Shamayim, as they travel toward the promised land.
  • Moshe Rabbeinu sends a messenger to Edom, identified with Esav, asking permission to pass through. He appeals to their kinship as brothers, recalls what the Jews endured in Egypt, and offers to buy water and avoid causing any harm.
  • Edom refuses and comes out armed, threatening to kill and destroy them if they enter. Mr. Gindi calls this a terrible rejection of Moshe’s appeal for compassion.
  • He asks why Hashem would have the Bnei Yisrael take a long, circuitous route rather than pass through Edom, and introduces R' Avigdor Miller’s explanation.

The Danger of Assimilation

  • According to R' Avigdor Miller’s explanation as presented by Mr. Gindi, Edom and Yaakov’s descendants were twin peoples who looked and lived alike. He gives examples of shared appearance, food—including mahshi and yebra—and manner of life.
  • Mr. Gindi says that this likeness made passage through Edom a danger of assimilation, and that Hashem protected the Jewish people by not allowing them to go through the land.

Separation and Antisemitism

  • Mr. Gindi says that compassion should not be expected from Esav or the Goyim, while Yehudim are, in his words, Rachmanim, Bayshanim, Bayshanim, Gomlei Chasadim; he describes Goyim as achzarim.
  • He says that secular Jews build Holocaust museums in the hope that people will feel compassion, but claims that those people instead feel that they “didn’t finish the job.”
  • He describes anti-Semitism as longstanding and invokes the rule “Esav, soneh, Yaakov.” He answers the question of why the Goyim hate the Jews by saying that Hashem made it so as Havdalah—a separation.
  • He cites a pasuk in Tehillim, paraphrased as “He changed their minds,” and says Hashem changed the Egyptians’ minds to hate His people. In his account, the Egyptians had reason to love the Jews, but the Jews were becoming too close to them and beginning to assimilate.
  • Mr. Gindi says Hashem’s purpose was to preserve His “baby boy,” His firstborn son—the Jewish people—and prevent their purity from being diluted through mixing and assimilation. He presents antisemitism as a blessing that keeps Jews separate from the Goyim.
  • He concludes that the other nations have been assimilated and mixed with one another, while the Jewish people remain separate, and says that this is why they should thank Hashem.
Words in this lecture2
Parashat Hashavua
Terms Parashat Hashavua, the Torah portion of the week.
Also written: Parshat Hashavua
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem