A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Mr. Sam Gindi - Heard from R' Avigdor Miller zt"l

Torah Lecture

Hashem knows our Thoughts! Good intentions are rewarded even the deed wasn’t yet done!

Lectured by Mr. Sam Gindi - Heard from R' Avigdor Miller zt"l

Published
August 11, 2026
Duration
5:35
Lecture code
SG-186

Creation and Hashem’s Knowledge

  • Mr. Sam Gindi reflects on the beautiful sky and the air created by Hashem: the same oxygen sustains all life, including fish, birds, octopuses, giraffes, alligators, other animals, and flowers.
  • Contemplating this life-giving creation points to Hashem’s power and care. One of the Rambam’s 13 fundamentals, Mr. Sam Gindi says, is that Hashem knows what is in our minds. He sees good thoughts, and a person is rewarded for them, including good intentions while learning Torah.

Torah’s Lessons About Intention

  • The parashah teaches an important lesson about righteous intentions, even when they do not produce an accomplishment. Mr. Sam Gindi recalls the rabbi’s teaching that the secrets of Torah are “on top” of the Torah, and that its plain meaning is itself essentially its secrets.
  • A derashah presents the case of three false witnesses accusing a man of murder. Two witnesses would be sufficient to bring the penalty, and those two would be liable to death for false testimony in a capital case.
  • The third false witness is unnecessary, yet he is also liable to death. Though his testimony adds nothing, he is punished for joining the false testimony with that intention.

Sharing in a Mitzvah

  • The same principle applies positively: someone who joins a virtuous deed shares its reward, even if the deed would have been accomplished without them.
  • For example, a group delivers packages through Bikur Cholim to people who need them. If three people are already doing the work, an additional person may not be needed, but joining the group still earns a complete reward.

Shem and Japheth

  • Noah was uncovered, and Shem took a garment to cover his father, backing up without looking at him out of respect. Japheth also joined in covering Noah.
  • The word “took” is singular because Shem began the act. Japheth was not needed; he merely took hold of the edge of the garment. Nevertheless, he was blessed with wide dominions. Mr. Sam Gindi identifies these with the Greek empire, saying Japheth received this reward for his willingness to participate.

Reward for Good Desires

  • Hashem values those who pray for good causes and good people, even when they cannot participate in the deed itself. He also rewards those who sincerely desire in their hearts to take part in good causes.
  • Mr. Sam Gindi urges listeners to intend to go to shul, learn Torah, give tzedakah, and do other good deeds, explaining that even these good intentions are rewarded.