A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
R' Speakers Guest

Torah Lecture

A Slap in the Face Rabbi Fischel Schachter

Lectured by R' Speakers Guest

Published
May 13, 2026
Duration
3:12
Lecture code
VAY-EYN-224

The Yetzer Hara’s Response to Failure

  • Rabbi Fischel Schachter compares looking back at a failure to an old woman who puts a car in reverse and mistakes the reversing camera’s chaotic images for a violent movie. The Yetzer Hara urges a person to think, “You tried to be good, and you blew it,” and to give in after feeling slapped in the face.
  • A friend from yeshiva chose not to go home for Yom Kippur because he feared encountering certain nisyonot. His family was upset, but he stayed in the dorm and failed there too. He felt he had failed both in bein adam lechaveiro and bein adam laMakom.

A Commitment Can Build a Path Forward

  • A Maggid Shiur told the friend about Rav Moshe Soloveitchik, the great Rav in Switzerland, who had once been Reb Chaim Kanievsky’s roommate. Rav Moshe was sent to moshavim to encourage people to send their children to yeshiva, and this was very matzliach.
  • One morning Rav Moshe returned at 4 a.m. and found Reb Chaim still awake. Though they were both Bachurim, Reb Chaim sat down to learn the daf, saying that he did not go to sleep without learning it. He kept falling asleep.
  • The next morning Reb Chaim asked whether he had understood even one word. When Rav Moshe said no, Reb Chaim asked why he had learned. Rav Moshe answered that keeping the commitment would lead to hundreds of dafim that he would understand. The point was that even if someone fails in the moment, trying to do the right thing can create a path forward.

Keeping a Kabbalah After a Setback

  • When a friend in yeshiva asked whether to become a Mekabel, Rabbi Fischel Schachter said he had decided to remove the radio from his car. He asked his mechanic, Pete, to take it out; Pete objected that it was the only thing that worked in the car. While trying to remove it, Pete mistakenly took out the horn, lights, and blinkers before finally removing the radio.
  • The friend decided not to listen to the radio. The next day he called after being pulled over for a ticket because he was not wearing a seatbelt, and asked what he should learn from it. Rabbi Fischel Schachter replied, “Don’t ask me advice.”
  • Later the friend invited him to Chicago without initially explaining why. At a Seudat Hoda’ah, the friend told the story, including the ticket and the seatbelt. After he put on his seatbelt, a tractor trailer fishtailed; his car went over an embankment and turned over five times. He came out without a scratch, though his tooth was bleeding. State police told him that without his seatbelt, he would not have survived.
  • Rabbi Fischel Schachter said the friend survived because he had taken on a Kabbalah, been slapped in the face by the setback, and nevertheless held to his commitment.

Shemirat Einayim and Tests of Resolve

  • Trying to observe Shemirat Einayim does not mean everything will be easy or go smoothly. Rabbi Fischel Schachter says that, as the Baal HaTanya says, a person will always be tested.
  • If a person rides through the test and maintains the commitment, “here comes the big beracha.”