A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
R' Speakers Guest

Torah Lecture

Turning Down the Job of a Lifetime Rabbi Yonah Carlebach

Lectured by R' Speakers Guest

Published
December 1, 2025
Duration
2:49
Lecture code
VAY-EYN-176

The job offer and decision

  • When his family was growing and he needed more income, the speaker was working in real estate for a large company and looking through the classifieds in The New York Times. He saw an ad from the Trump Organization for a property manager, a job that matched his experience.
  • After meeting with a lower-level manager, he went through the process of meeting several managers, as is common in large corporations. Eventually, he was told he would meet Mr. Fred Trump, Donald Trump’s father.
  • Fred Trump, then an older man, owned many properties in Brooklyn and Queens. One large property near the Belt Parkway was, the speaker thinks, called Trump Village.
  • Fred Trump said he liked everything about the speaker and was ready to hire him. He explained that Caroline would be his immediate supervisor, and that they would work closely together day to day.
  • Feeling uncomfortable about working so closely with her, the speaker asked his Rosh Yeshiva whether it was appropriate. The Rosh Yeshiva repeatedly responded, “What are you asking me?” After he asked a third time, the speaker understood the response as an indication that this was not a question he should be asking.
  • The speaker called the Trump Organization and said the job was not for him. Turning it down was very difficult because it offered a lot of money and was prestigious, but he declined. He says that afterward everything worked out much better.

The lesson of the trial

  • The speaker says that the Ribono Shel Olam (Master of the Universe) repays nisyonot (trials) many times over.
  • At any crossroads involving a nisayon (trial), a person should consider what his Rebbe would want him to do; that would obviously be the Ratzon Hashem (the will of God).
  • Rav Shmuel always did Ratzon Hashem, and the speaker says that people should try to emulate him.