A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Hashem doesn’t believe in cancel culture

Lectured by Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Published
January 3, 2022
Duration
29:50
Lecture code
YST22-01

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

There is a very famous question that is asked. We know we’re in the middle of the parashiyot (Torah portions), where Hashem sends ten makot, ten plagues, to punish the Mitzrim. Why does Hashem have to go through a series of ten makot, ten plagues? Why doesn’t Hashem just go straight to Makat b’chorot, go to the most severe of all the plagues, and put the Mitzrim against the most severe of all the makot? Paro will send them. He said that if the whole objective of the makot is to send the Jewish people, to take the Jewish people out of Mitzrayim, then just go straight to Makat b’chorot, and you’ll be able to take them out. Why does Hashem have to build up and go through dam (blood), Tzefardea (frogs), kinim (lice), arov (wild animals), Dever (pestilence), Shechin (boils), barad (hail), and Makat b’chorot?

Look, this answer raises many questions. I saw a new answer to this question that wowed me. It is the answer of Seforno. Seforno explains that Hashem wanted to give Paro and the Mitzrim the ability to do teshuvah (repentance). He saw that they were enslaving Bnei Yisrael, that they were torturing the Jewish people, and He said, “If I go straight to Makat b’chorot, I’m just going to wipe them out.” He says, “But I’m going to wipe out these Resha’im.” We know that at Keriat Yam Suf, Hashem told the angels to stop singing. He said, “My handiwork are drowning in the water.” Do you think Hashem wants to destroy even the Mitzrim? He says, “I want the Mitzrim to do teshuvah, rather than do teshuvah and then have Me wipe them out.” Therefore, says Seforno, Hashem had a buildup of makot. Slowly: “Let me hit them a little, and a little, and a little, because maybe, through the smacks that I give them, they’ll come and do teshuvah.” You see how merciful Hashem is. Even the most wicked people walking around, people who are torturing His children for 210 years, are not people Hashem is simply going to wipe out. Even those people, Hashem wants to give the ability to do teshuvah. He would rather they do teshuvah than have to wipe them out.

I heard a story about a Nazi after the Holocaust. He was an active Nazi, someone who himself killed Jewish people. After the war, he realized that he had been brainwashed by Hitler, brainwashed by the whole Holocaust. He said, “You know, I really feel bad for what I did. I want to do teshuvah.” He said, “Not only that, I want to convert to Judaism.” He was so hurt by what he had done to the Jews that he wanted to come and convert.

So what did he do? He went to a Bet Din (rabbinical court), number one. They saw this Nazi walking in. “Who are you?” “Yeah, I came from Germany, but I want to become Jewish now.” They looked at him and said, “Right, get out of here.” He went to the next Bet Din and said, “Yeah, I want to convert.” They told him, “Look, you literally had the blood of the Jewish people on your hands. Do you think we’re going to accept you into our kehillah (community)? We’re going to accept you into our shul (synagogue)? Get out of here.” They kicked the guy out.

He went to a third Bet Din. Again, they were ready to send him out. One of the rabbis got up and said to the rabbis, “Are you telling me there’s a sin out there so bad that Hashem wouldn’t take you back? Are you telling me there’s a sin you could do so bad that Hashem won’t let you do teshuvah? No matter what you do, even if you do the worst averah (sin) in the Torah, if you want to do teshuvah, Hashem will take you back. So who are we to say about somebody else that he did the worst thing imaginable to human beings, to the way humans should act? Who are we to say that we’re not taking that person back?” They said, “You’re right. You’re a hundred. We’re going to let the person convert; we’re going to accept that person.” Because that’s what Hashem does. Even the Resha’im, He lets them do teshuvah; even the Resha’im, He brings them closer. Who are we to say that we’re not going to act like Hashem?

We find a concept that when Hashem punishes people, He punishes midah keneged midah. He punishes what we call measure for measure. The question is, why? Somebody does an averah, Hashem wants to punish the person, and He punishes him measure for measure, midah keneged midah. Why does Hashem have to punish in the same way the person did the averah? Does Hashem have a sense of humor? Like, “Oh, you did this to Me, so I’m going to go and do the same exact thing back to you”? Or is it poetic justice? When somebody does an averah, Hashem wants to punish the person midah keneged midah. The question is, why? Why does Hashem punish people measure for measure?

I saw a beautiful answer from Rabbi Rav Chaim Shmulevitz. He explains that people have a big misconception about why Hashem punishes people. People think Hashem is sitting in Shamayim (heaven), holding a bolt of lightning, and when you go and make mechalel Shabbat (desecrating Shabbat), He’s ready to zap you, ready to strike down with lightning anyone who transgresses any of the aveirot. You go and commit a sin, and He’s ready to squash you, hurt you, and get you. People have this fear of Hashem, that Hashem is coming to get them if they step one step out of line.

The Rabbi says, “No, that’s not why Hashem punishes people. You know why Hashem punishes people? Hashem knows how much reward you get for keeping the mitzvot (commandments), and He knows how much olam haba you get if you refrain from doing the aveirot and keep the Torah. All Hashem wants to do is give you olam haba, the reason you were created, because He wants you to enjoy in the next world. He wants to give you olam haba. When Hashem sees you committing aveirot, you know what hurts Hashem? It hurts Him that I want to do good for you, and you’re stepping out of line, so I can’t give you the good I want to give you.”

So what does Hashem do? Hashem says, “I want to punish you to have you stop doing the aveirot. When you stop doing the aveirot, you’ll come back to My Torah, and I’ll be able to give you reward.” He says, “Hashem doesn’t want to punish you just because you insulted Him, so now He wants to get you back. Hashem wants to punish you only to bring you back on the right path.” He says, “Therefore, that’s why Hashem punishes people midah keneged midah, measure for measure. Hashem is saying, ‘I’m not here just to hit you; I’m not here just to smack you. I’m here to rehabilitate you. If my smack isn’t going to result in you coming back and getting back on the program, then what was the smack worth?’”

So Hashem says, “I have to do midah keneged midah, measure for measure. There has to be a hint toward what you have to work on as you come back to the path. Then the punishment will fulfill something. The punishment will achieve something: when I give you this punishment, you’ll know what you have to come back to, and you’ll get back on the right path.”

The Rabbi says in an even greater chidush (novel insight) that we see this with Moshe Rabbeinu. Moshe Rabbeinu prayed 515 times to Hashem to go into Eretz Yisrael, and Hashem told him to stop praying. What language did Hashem use to Moshe Rabbeinu? He told him, “Rav lach (Enough for you).” He said, “Stop praying. Rav lach.” And Chazal tell us, why did Hashem use that language, Rav lach? Because when Korach came to Moshe asking for the Kehunah (priesthood), Korach and his group of people, Moshe Rabbeinu told them, “Rav lachem (Enough for you).” So Hashem came midah, and used those same words back to Moshe Rabbeinu.

The Rabbi asks the question: “I don’t understand. You want to tell me why Moshe Rabbeinu went into Eretz Yisrael? The reason he didn’t go into Eretz Yisrael is because he hit the rock. The punishment for hitting the rock was not going into Eretz Yisrael. What happened here? The way Hashem told him that he wasn’t going in was with this word, Rav lachem. Who cares? Who cares? Listen, I want to go into Eretz Yisrael. I want to go into Eretz Yisrael. There’s a reason I’m not going in, because I hit the rock. That’s my real issue here. I want to go into Eretz Yisrael, and you’re not letting me go into Eretz Yisrael. Who really cares about the way you told me why I’m not going in? What’s the big deal? You told me Rav lach because I said Rav lachem. Who cares how I spoke to someone, or how you speak to me? It’s not really the greater issue that’s on the floor.”

The Rabbi explains, “You’re right. There was no personal insult or punishment from Hashem telling Moshe Rabbeinu, ‘Rav lach.’ It was just that when Moshe Rabbeinu said that to Korach, he may have been a little insensitive toward Korach. Hashem wanted to give Moshe Rabbeinu a lesson, to do teshuvah for that action. He said, ‘I want you to do teshuvah for the way you were insensitive to Korach. I’m just going to notify you with these words, Rav lach, so you can work on the insensitivity you showed Korach.’ It wasn’t in any way a punishment toward Moshe; it was just a reminder for him to do teshuvah.”

You see from here a fascinating chidush: all Hashem wants you to do is teshuvah. If you can do teshuvah without having to get a smack on the wrist, if you can do teshuvah just by being notified of what you did wrong, then that’s what Hashem will do. Hashem isn’t here to hit you, hurt you, or punish you. Hashem is here only to rehabilitate you. If you can be rehabilitated just by being notified of what you did, then that’s all Hashem has to do. So Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu, “Rav lach,” because He wants him to do teshuvah for that action. There’s no real reason for you to do teshuvah; I’m not giving you a punishment. I’m just giving you a notification to go and do teshuvah.

I saw an interesting video. We see how different the way Hashem acts is from society, and how different our justice system is from Hashem’s justice system. I saw a video about four or five 18-year-old kids who, like 18-year-old kids do, wanted to play a practical joke. They decided, “What should we do today? We’ll stand by an underpass where cars are driving on the highway at 65 miles an hour. We’ll take stones, take bricks, and throw them from the top of the underpass. It’ll bounce off the top of a guy’s car while he’s driving. He’ll hear a thud on the top of his car, get nervous, and look around. We’ll laugh, and it’ll be our practical joke of the day.”

So they went. The first guy drove by. They took the brick and threw it off the thing. It bounced off the top of the car. They were hysterical laughing. They threw another one. It missed the car, and they were hysterical laughing. “How great!” Then they threw the third one. The guy was driving, and the brick went through the windshield and hit him. He swerved off the road. The guy died.

Now they’re showing these four kids in court, on trial. Each one of these kids, 18, 19, 20, is hysterically crying. “We didn’t mean it. We’re good kids. We were just joking around. We were just having a good time. Please look at our history. We never did anything wrong. We’re not malicious people. It was just a joke. We just threw the rock as a joke. We didn’t mean to do what we did.”

On the other side, you have the wife of this guy, hysterically crying: “I will not be consoled until someone pays for what happened to my husband.” She’s hysterical. “Someone did something. Until justice is served, I’ll never be consoled. I’ll never forgive you. Your stupid jokes ruin people’s lives, and you have to know the consequences of your actions. I will never sleep well at night until I know that someone pays for what they did to my husband.”

So what did the judge do? I know we’re a little virtual, but we also have some people here. Someone want to help out? What did the judge do? What do you do? The lawyer gets up and says, “No, they’re good. They’ll never do it again.” The lawyer says, “Look, they realize the results of their actions. They’ll never do it again.” What does the judge say?

The judge says, “It’s the money now.” Right? Just pay. He’s like, “If they pay enough, I hear you.” So the judge says, “Look, very nice. I believe you that you’ll never do it again. I believe you feel remorse. I see hysterical crying; it’s not crocodile tears. They’re real, legitimate tears of remorse for what you did. But at the end of the day, our society runs it this way: if you do something wrong, you have to pay. There are consequences for your actions.” Therefore, they put them in jail for eight years, ten years, whatever these kids have. They’re missing their whole young adulthood, sitting behind bars for a practical joke they did just to have a good time.

My question is: what would Hashem do if Hashem were the judge? What would Hashem do? Maybe you could say, “I’ll tell you.” So you know what Hashem would do, according to what we’re saying? Hashem would say, “Oh, you’re doing teshuvah. You did an averah, but you’re committing not to do it again? What do I have to hit you for? What do I have to hurt you for? What do I have to give you a consequence for your action? If you’re doing legitimate teshuvah and you’re not going to commit that averah again, if you’re doing legitimate teshuvah and you’re now a changed person from who you were yesterday, then why do I have to get involved and hit you? The only reason I would have hit you to begin with is to rehabilitate you. But if you were going to rehabilitate yourself, then why do I have to go and start hitting you?”

Hashem isn’t interested in hitting a person. Hashem is only interested in making you a better person. If you can become a better person without getting hit, then why does Hashem have to get involved? Why does Hashem have to hit you?

We live in a society that they now call cancel culture. What is cancel culture? It means you could have gone to school for however many years you went to school and worked in a profession for 20, 30 years, but you say one line out of insensitivity toward a certain race or group of people, and what happens? Canceled. You said one line, and there’s no coming back from saying it. You’re canceled forever, you’re banned, we wipe your name off the website, it’s like you never existed in this company, and you’re gone.

I was learning with some boys, and they told me, “You’ll never believe this new guy that got canceled.” I said, “Who got canceled?” They said, “There’s this coach in the NFL, and they found his emails from 11 years ago. Maybe 11 years ago he said something racist, maybe something that was not right. And what happened? They said, ‘We found these emails from 11 years ago, and, ah, you know, you’re a bad guy. Canceled, you’re out.’” Within two days, the guy was out the door. It’s like he has nothing to do with the organization; he’s gone. And I told the boys, “Look, are you allowed to say something against people? Chas V’Shalom (God forbid), you’re not allowed to say anything bad against anyone. And you want to know what’s unbelievable? You want to know what’s great? Look how different Hashem is. This guy—they found emails from 11 years ago, and they canceled it. Hashem, if you did an averah 11 minutes ago, and you did something far worse than what this guy did, and you now come and say, ‘Ah, you know, Hashem, I feel guilty. If they did an averah, I’d say, ah, you know, I have this guilt burning inside me. You know what, Hashem? I’m doing teshuvah. I’m doing legitimate teshuvah. I’m not going to do the averah again, and I feel guilty, and I’m admitting to what I did.’ And you do full-fledged, real, legitimate teshuvah. You know what Hashem says? ‘You do teshuvah, I accept you back. I take you back. Come back, my son.’”

Do you think Hashem wants to cancel anybody? Do you think Hashem is like, “You did that one horrible thing, and said, ‘Yeah, you know, yeah.’ Right? Yeah, forever”? Do you think Hashem wants to cancel anybody? Hashem does not believe in cancel culture. Hashem believes in everyone becoming a better person day after day. Hashem believes in rehabilitation. When a person does something wrong, you work to stop doing the averah. Do you think we just want to cancel you? Do you think we just want to punish you for what you did? It’s just a game of checks and balances.

It’s such an unbelievable midah that Hashem has. The whole concept of punishment isn’t there to hurt you. The punishment is to bring you down. That’s what we’re saying here with the Mitzri: even to the Mitzri, Hashem gives ten makot. Why? Because He wants you to come back, and He’s not ready to sign off or bring the final makot. He’s not ready to do it. He wants you to come back. So He’ll go plague after plague after plague until you can come back.

We also find, very interestingly, that in the Torah it says many times that Hashem keeps hardening the heart of Paro. It seems like Paro is ready to send Bnei Yisrael out, but Hashem keeps hardening his heart so that Paro doesn’t send them out. Many people ask: why? If Hashem’s objective is to get Bnei Yisrael out of Mitzrayim, and through the force of the makot, the force of the plagues, Paro is ready to finally submit and send Bnei Yisrael out, then your objective is going to be reached; it’s going to be fulfilled. So why does Hashem harden the heart of Paro and cause him not to send Bnei Yisrael out? Let him just send them. Okay, after Tzefardea, he’ll send them out. After the makot, go ahead and send them out. Why do you have to harden Paro’s heart and cause him not to send them out?

According to what we’re saying, I think it makes a lot of sense. If Paro had sent Bnei Yisrael out because of the makot, because of the plagues, then Paro would never really have been rehabilitated. He wouldn’t have sent Bnei Yisrael out because he truly felt remorse for enslaving them and felt that it was wrong. Why would he really have sent them out? He would have said, “Ah, because I’m tired of being hit. I’m tired of getting smacked. I’m tired of the plagues. It’s not worth it for me to keep getting hit for what I have, so just get lost, because I can’t handle any more.” But would Paro really have changed if he sent Bnei Yisrael out because of the force of the plagues? You could say no. If he had just sent them out because of the plague, there wouldn’t have been any real internal change.

So Hashem says, “That’s not what I’m doing. I’m not trying to beat Bnei Yisrael out of you. I’m not trying to beat the freedom out of you. I’m here to try to get you to change. I’m here to get you to do teshuvah. So when I hit you, it still has to be legitimate. It’s a lesson; it’s a message. But you still have to be legitimately sending them out. If you’re not legitimately sending them out, then my objective here really wasn’t reached, because the objective is not just to take them out. The objective is to get the people to change, to get the people to do teshuvah.”

There’s a boy I’m close to whose family was going through a hard time. The family went to a Kabbalist to ask, “You know, we have this going on, we have that going on. What are we doing wrong to get rid of this problem?” They went to a Kabbalistic rabbi and asked, “Please, could you tell us what we’re doing wrong to get rid of this problem?” The rabbi came back to the parents and said, “I’ll tell you what’s going on. I’ll tell you what’s wrong with you people.” He said, “Your son does such and such an averah. Your son does such and such a thing, and it’s causing your whole mazal (fortune) to go off. It’s because of your son that these things are happening.”

The parents came home, maybe a little fuming, and said, “Son, you know what the Kabbalist said today? He said it’s because of you that our mazal may be a little upside down.” So the kid flipped out. He was like, “We don’t believe in these things. He’s not a prophet. He’s not a Navi (prophet). What does he know? We don’t believe in these things.” The kid came to me: “By the way, do we believe in these things? What’s the deal? This rabbi said something, but maybe he’s not legit. Maybe he is legit, but who knows? Is that how the world works, that you do one averah and it causes a whole thing to happen? Please tell me, do we believe in these things or not?” He wanted to know how much he was the cause of these issues, we’ll call them.

I told him this. Question one: “If Eliyahu Hanavi were to come down there and tell you that what this Kabbalistic rabbi said was 100% right, and that these things were happening because of that averah, would you stop doing the averah?” I said, “If he was right, would you stop?” The kid said, “100%. I would feel guilty. I’d feel I was ruining whatever was going on with my whole family. Of course I would stop.” I said, “That means you have the ability to stop. That means you could stop.” So I told him, “I want you to stop the averah, but not because of what it causes. I want you to stop the averah because it’s the right thing not to do the averah. Why can’t that be enough of a reason not to do it? You want to change? You want to stop doing the averah because you’re getting hit? ‘I’m getting hit, and I’d like to stop getting hit, so, you know, Hashem, I submit. I’m going to stop doing the averah.’ Do you think that’s what Hashem really wants from you? Do you think He wants you to stop so that He’ll stop hitting you and you’ll stop doing the averah? Hashem wants an internal change. He wants you to become a better person, and that is the reason why you do it. The punishment is coming only to cause you to become a better person through an internal change.”

So I said, “Change for the sake of changing. Become better for the sake of becoming better. Don’t just become better for the sake of stopping the hits, because ultimately that’s not going to make you a better person. It’s just going to make you someone who doesn’t have a high tolerance for friction and punishments in your life.”

The problem is that people are very reluctant to change. If people could find any way out, any excuse, any avenue out of having to change, they would love to take it. It says in the Parashah yesterday that Paro was going nuts from the Tzefardea. He couldn’t take the frogs—the croaking, the noise; they were everywhere. It says Paro went to Moshe: “That’s it. We have to end this.” Moshe Rabbeinu went to Paro and said, “Okay, we’ll get rid of the frogs. I just want to ask you: when do you want the frogs to go away?” He asked Paro, “When do you want the frogs to go away? When would you like the frogs to go away?”

If that were happening to us, what would you say? I would say, “Right now.” What did Paro answer? “Machar, tomorrow. Please get rid of them tomorrow.” Then I would say, “What in the world is wrong with you?” You’re going nuts from this thing. Moshe says, “Whenever you’d like, I’ll get rid of them.” So what do you say? Anyone would say, “Get rid of it now.” What does Paro say? “Tomorrow.” What does he have in his mind? We know Paro—we make him out to be a did, but was Paro really a did? So what in the world? Paro is saying, “Get rid of them tomorrow.”

I saw an explanation. It says that Paro was using a little psychology. Moshe Rabbeinu came to me and asked, “When would you like the frogs to go away? When would you like me to get rid of the frogs?” So his first thought is, “If he’s asking that question, what is he expecting me to say? He’s expecting me to say, ‘Right now.’ It must be that they’re really going to go away now anyway, and they’re really not brought by Hashem. They’re really supposed to leave, you know, this one. That’s why he asked me, because I’m going to say ‘now,’ and then they’re going to go away. And he’ll say, ‘Oh, look, Hashem took away the frogs.’”

So you know what I’m going to do? I’m going to say, “Tomorrow.” And when I say “tomorrow,” you know what’s going to happen? They’re going to go away right now, and you’ll see that it has nothing to do with Hashem. He’s willing to put up with another day of this terrible suffering and affliction for the potential chance to say, “Look, there’s no Hashem.” Why do I have to change? Let me risk another day’s worth of this suffering so I can stay the same person I am. We would have said, “Listen, I don’t know. Yeah, Hashem, no, Hashem, just get rid of the frogs. Get rid of them. I’ll change. I’ll do whatever you want. Maybe, yeah, maybe not. I don’t care anymore. Just get rid of this stuff.” We see how much people don’t want to change.

The idea we’re going to sign off with today is that when somebody does something wrong, there are consequences. Hashem does come and send messages to people who do something wrong. The Gemara says that when yisurim (suffering) come upon a person, you have to check your actions, because your actions are what cause things to happen—messages from Hashem, maybe punishments that come upon a person.

But a person has to know: Hashem sends suffering or punishment to a person only because He wants you to change, only because He wants to rehabilitate you, only because He wants you to become a better person. Hashem is not interested in hitting you for the sake of hitting you. Hashem is not interested in hitting you because He’s offended that you didn’t keep His Torah. Hashem only wants to give you a reward for what you do, and Hashem only wants you back on the right path. If you get yourself back on the right path without having to get smacked, Hashem will say, “That’s all great. I’m not going to have to smack you if you get back on the right path.” When Hashem comes and sends us these messages, they’re really for the sake of changing the right way, changing internally, and becoming a better person. If you do it just because you don’t want to get hit anymore, that’s also not really fulfilling Hashem’s objective.

B’ezrat Hashem (with God’s help), we will not ignore the messages Hashem sends us, and we will change from them. We will change without even having to get hit, so Hashem doesn’t have to give us any sort of punishment. B’ezrat Hashem, when we do change, the change will be legitimate. It will be a real internal change to become better people, and not just to stop Hashem’s punishments.