A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Understanding Tefillah #04 - Body position during the Amidah: How to bow, which foot to lead with in עושה שלום, And... should you shake in the Amidah??

Lectured by Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Published
December 22, 2025
Duration
6:54
Lecture code
RAM-TEF04

Posture during the Amidah

  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi explains that these halachot guide a person’s physical behavior to help with proper mental kavanah during tefillah.
  • A person should stand with his feet together. Although many think this is to show that he is not running away from Hashem, the reason given is that this posture resembles how angels stand before Hashem—as if they have one foot—and a person should think of himself as standing before Hashem like one of His angels.
  • The head should be “heavy,” meaning slightly tilted down, as a sign of humility. This is the opposite of the chin-up posture associated with arrogance.
  • The hands should rest on the chest, with the right hand over the left. This is a respectful posture, unlike standing with hands behind the back or in the pockets, which is casual.
  • A person should not hold anything during the Amidah, since it may distract him from praying to Hashem.

Bowing

  • When bowing, a person should bend his back fully, as if at a 90-degree angle, with the vertebrae expanded outward. Rabbi Alex Mizrahi contrasts this with a “heke-type” bow—a slight nudge—which he describes as showing little interest in bowing to Hashem; bowing fully expresses eagerness to do so.
  • There is a discussion about bending the knees when bowing. The way Rabbi Alex Mizrahi describes as the Ashkenazi practice is to bend the knees on “Baruch” and then bend the body on “Atah.”
  • He suggests, as a possibility, that some Sefaradim may have adopted this practice because Ashkenazi rabbis taught them when they were children. He says the proper Sephardic way is to bow without bending the knees, as one bows during Modim, and to use that method at every bowing point in the Amidah.

Taking the steps back at Oseh Shalom

  • When taking the three steps back at Oseh Shalom, a person should lead with the left foot, the less dominant foot. This applies even to a left-handed person, since, as Rabbi Alex Mizrahi puts it, “we go with the majority.”
  • Leading with the left foot expresses that a person is not eager to move away from Hashem, but is walking away slowly.
  • After finishing Oseh Shalom, a person should remain in place for the time it takes to walk Dalet Amot (four cubits), which Rabbi Alex Mizrahi estimates at approximately four to five seconds. This, too, expresses that the person is not eager to leave the Amidah.

The pace of the bow

  • A person bows when saying Baruch Atah Hashem. He should go down quickly, showing eagerness to bow to Hashem, and rise more slowly, expressing that he is not rushing away from the bow.

Shaking during the Amidah

  • If a person feels he needs to shake in order to have kavanah, he is allowed to do so; nevertheless, the halacha, as Rabbi Alex Mizrahi presents it, favors standing firmly without shaking.
  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi recalls that after he taught this halacha in Shul, an older man joked, “shakers is for fakers,” saying that people shake as they fake. Rabbi Alex Mizrahi says he does not know what the man means, and offers instead the explanation of Rabbi Shlomo Wolbe.
  • Rabbi Shlomo Wolbe explains that shaking can indicate that a person does not believe Hashem is right in front of him. He compares it to meeting Hacham Ovadia Yosef: a person would enter humbly and would not shake violently while speaking to him, which would seem insane.
  • Rabbi Shlomo Wolbe’s point, as Rabbi Alex Mizrahi presents it, is that standing straight and still while speaking honestly to Hashem as though He were sitting in the chair in front of you—the Kisei Kavod (Throne of Glory)—can make for one of the most exhilarating and energizing tefillot. Contrary to the idea that shaking makes prayer more exciting, he says that being able to pray the Amidah without moving, while recognizing Hashem as present, can be profoundly energizing.