A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Understanding Tefillah #38 - השיבה שופטינו (Hashiba Shofetenu) - Return our judges and remove our distress... Without Torah law you cannot have morals or ethics

Lectured by Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Published
March 11, 2026
Duration
3:39
Lecture code
RAM-TEF38

The Request in the Hashiva shofteinu Beracha

  • The Beracha asks Hashem to restore our Beit Din and Jewish law as the way to govern the world.
  • It also asks for the return of our advisors, which the Mefarshim explain refers to kings and leaders such as David HaMelech and Shlomo HaMelech.
  • The Beracha then asks Hashem to remove the distress, sorrow, and sadness we experience.

Torah as the Foundation of Morals and Ethics

  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi explains that the Torah is not only a book of rules: it teaches morals and ethics, including how to live properly and treat other people.
  • When Torah, judges, and kings guide society according to Torah, morals and ethics do not become distorted.
  • Without Torah as the foundation of society, moral standards can change over time. Rabbi Mizrahi illustrates this with slavery: in 2026, people would call enslaving another person disgusting, whereas before Abraham Lincoln, people might have considered it permissible.
  • He gives another example involving theft: stealing is generally condemned, but in difficult economic circumstances, some might argue that people should be allowed to take what they need from stores and that police should not intervene.
  • He describes the instability of having morals and ethics change as a major source of distress and discomfort.

Praying for Jewish Law and Relief from Distress

  • Because Hashem’s Torah establishes moral and ethical principles that do not change, we pray, “Hashiva shofteinu kevarishona”: restore our Beit Din and let us conduct our lives according to Jewish law.
  • We also ask for a kingdom like that of David HaMelech and Shlomo HaMelech, with kings governing according to Jewish law.
  • With Jewish law as life’s foundation, the mental difficulty of seeing the world’s moral standards shift from one view to another is removed; those moral and ethical principles remain constant.