A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ariel Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Tazria Sometimes, it’s not the time

Lectured by Rabbi Ariel Mizrahi

Published
April 14, 2026
Duration
30:07
Lecture code
RAM-219

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us on this beautiful Tuesday morning as we study a double header, Parashat Tazria and Parashat Metzora. The Parashah, of course, deals with a leper, a person who receives the affliction of Tzara'at. He gets this interesting discoloration, whether it's on his hand, his clothes, his house, or his body—anywhere. The Torah says that he has to go to the Kohen, not to a doctor. It's the Kohen who decides this person's fate, which is crazy. If the Kohen says, “Tameh (impure),” now this guy's life has changed, at least for a week, for two, maybe more. He has to go through a whole process of quarantine and then purity. Our Rabbis tell us that it's a punishment for lashon hara (gossip), for hubris, for arrogance, and for different things. Either way, a man is supposed to introspect when he receives this Tzara'at, this form of leprosy. Again, we don't really have this today, but the Torah talks about it, and we have many lessons to learn.

The Pasuk (verse) says, “The Kohen shall...” Inspect the nega, the affliction. He shall take a look and compare the color on his skin to the Benjamin Moore colors—you know, all the different colors in that album or whatever they give you. He shall see: Is it white? Is it white? Does it match? Which shade of white? How deep? Has the hair also turned white, or hasn't it? All the laws—that's why you go to Kohen school, to learn them. The Kohen finally sees and decides: Is this guy Tameh, or is he Tahor (pure)? But the Pasuk says that after the Kohen takes a look, it says again that the Kohen shall take a look. The Meshech Chochmah, by Meir Simcha Kohen of Dvinsk, obviously wants to know. He asks, why does it say V'ra'ah haKohen twice? It's a very simple, very fair question. Why does it say, “He shall see it,” and then, “He shall see it”? The Meshech Chochmah explains something very, very beautiful about these two words.

You know, the Gemara says in Mo'ed Katan that sometimes a Kohen, who's cold, you know, gets a call: “Hi, Kohen, I have a white. I want to make an appointment.” The Gemara says that at certain times of the year, the Kohen delays the meeting. That means the guy calls and says, “I have a sickness. I may have Tzara'at.” What does the Kohen say? “Well, Pesach is coming up. I don't want to ruin the guy's Pesach, so call me in a week. I'm away; I'm not available.” The Kohen delays the meeting if it's a holiday, or if the guy got married and you don't want to ruin his Simcha (joy). The Torah says that you actually postpone the meeting, the inspection. That's crazy. If a guy has COVID, I don't care what's coming up: you have to go check it out, test yourself. Are you negative? Are you positive? But the Torah says to delay the test here. Delay the test. Do you know why? Because the Torah is also a way of pleasantness.

Here is a person who was being punished for something he did wrong. He spoke gossip. He ruined someone's life. You know, sometimes gossip can kill somebody. People don't realize how bad gossip is. I just said, “What did you just say?” Someone could break up because of what you just said. Someone could fire someone because of what you just said. I had a lady calling me, crying. “You had a guy in your shul, Rabbi. He called my boss and told him bad stuff about me, all lies, because I didn't want to sell him a house without first having him sign, which is all the protocol anyway. And he didn't want to sign, and he was trying to circumvent it so he wouldn't have to pay me the interest—or the percentages, rather. Because he was upset at me, he called my boss, and I got fired. The boss said, ‘We can't have bad reputations. We have to fire you. We're sorry.’” Why? Because your little ego got in the way? You ruined someone's life. Now they're fired, months and months without a job. For what? For what? Just so you could say, “I was right. Look, I got the better end of the stick.” So you speak gossip, you spread lies, you ruin someone's life. And now Hashem is sending this guy a wake-up call: “Dude, go into quarantine.” He sends him some leprosy, some Tzara'at. And yet, and yet, and yet, says the Torah, as much as we want to teach this guy a lesson, if it's not the right time—if the holiday is coming up and he has to go away for Pesach on a winter vacation trip or to a Pesach program, or it's Shavuot, or whatever, or he just got married—it's not the right time, says the Torah. Delay the inspection. Yes, even for this gossiper, even for this person who ruined someone's life, we're not going to ruin his life now. We're going to be sensitive. We must teach him a lesson. But the Meshech Chochmah says this is what the Pasuk is teaching me: the Kohen shall first see the affliction, but he also has to see something else. He has to look at the person. Is this person in a situation in life where he will be receptive to this lesson, to this message, to this criticism? I have to see what he has, but first I have to see where he's up to in life. Sometimes a person isn't ready to hear a message. It's not the right time.

My friends, this is such a powerful idea. Timing in life is everything. A lot of times, we want to say something, but that doesn't mean we should say it. Just because it should be said doesn't mean it should be said now. King Solomon, Shlomo HaMelech, writes, “Everything has a time.” There's a time for peace, a time for war, a time to laugh, and a time to mourn. Sometimes we don't allow people the time and space they need to go through their feelings and emotions. Mourning is important. When a person is mourning, crying, or sad, it would be a very big mistake to try to rush him out of that period, out of that stage, and tell him, “Don't worry, don't cry.” That's actually a mistake. You're not supposed to tell him, “Don't cry.” Cry. This is a good time to cry. If not now, then when? Avraham cried for his wife. He didn't cry a lot, but he cried. He cried at the end of the day. He cried.

Sometimes at a shiva (mourning period) house, we go to pay our respects, and people say the dumbest things, the dumbest things possible. Some people say really dumb things. But we have to realize, my friends, that there are some things you shouldn't say at a shiva house. Maybe you believe it. Maybe philosophically your hashkafa (religious outlook) is that Hashem had a plan and Hashem knows what He's doing. But is that what you say to someone who just lost a child, who just lost a loved one? That it was their time? “Hashem knows what He's doing.” This person doesn't want to hear that right now. He doesn't want to hear all your emunah (faith) speech. “This person is in a better place.” So what? What does that have to do with anything? Maybe they're in a better place. I miss them. I miss them. They're gone. I miss them. They're not in my life. How does it help that they're in a better place? We have to think carefully before we open our mouths, before we say something. A lot of times we're uncomfortable with the awkward silence at a shiva house or whatever, so we open our mouths and speak as if we think we have to fill the silence. The Torah says, “One second, before you speak, Mr. Kohen, first look at the guy. How does he look right now? What's going on in his life? Is he in a headspace where he can hear what you're about to tell him? Is this the right time to say it?” If not, it would be a very big mistake to open your mouth. You don't administer. You don't inspect. Just because something should be said doesn't mean it should be said. It's not always about what needs to be said. It's also about when it needs to be said. There are so many examples of this. It's a very insensitive thing to say to someone. There are many examples of this in the Torah.

For example, when I rebuke my friend for a sin, the Torah says I have to rebuke him. But make sure you don't cause him to sin. If you rebuke him right now, your words will fall on deaf ears. Because of your rebuke, he's actually going to become more bitter. He's going to turn it on its face. He's not ready to hear it. Right now is not the right time. Sometimes our spouse is going through something. They're emotional. Our spouse just lost a job, or whatever it is. Maybe they're annoyed. Maybe they're excited about something. Now you come in and you want to throw, you know, they had a bad day, a hard day. They had to pick up; this one threw up, this one lost their thing, this one forgot their lunch. They had a whole day. It was hectic. They were very busy and stressed. They sit down with you to talk about it, and then what do you do? “By the way, why didn't you pick up the cleaners? How come the luggage is still packed, you know, unpacked? Why didn't you? What are you doing?” It's not the right time. It's not the right time. Okay, maybe it annoys you. Maybe you should address it. Maybe something annoys you. Maybe they're not praying religiously, or they're not where you want them to be, or they're not responsible. Whatever it is, there are a million and one things we want to tell our spouse. Timing. Timing, my friends.

Our children: when we want to tell them, “Be respectful, be this, be that,” timing is everything. You tell your kid in the middle of a hangout with his friends? You're going to start rebuking your kid? Or in the middle of a fight, you're going to pull him aside and say, “Hey, you're wrong”? What are the chances your kid's going to hear that? The Torah says you have to tell your children. But sometimes you have to think: When is the best time to tell my kid? Is it in the house? Maybe when we're walking to school later on in the day? Maybe a week later? Maybe at bedtime? Maybe when he wakes up in the morning, when I drive him to school? I have to find the right time to address the problem. I'm not saying you shouldn't address the problem. Address the problem. Talk to your kid. They have to learn values. Absolutely. We have to transmit those values to our kid, to our children, whether it's honesty or respect, whatever the value is. One hundred percent. I'm not saying don't tell them. Tell them. But the Torah says, when's the right time to tell them? You have to think about that too. It's not only, “What's your message?” but, “When's your message?” Maybe in the middle of the Pesach trip, when everyone is there—what's your goal? Your goal is that the kid should hear it and change. You can tell him now, but his head's all the way downstairs at the pool. Do you think it's going to register? Do you think it's going to make a difference? These are things we have to think about in life. When we say something, is this the right time? The Torah says the Kohen has to take a double look. First, he has to see: Is it white? Is it not? Fine. But there's another look you have to take. Not only, “Is it white?” but, “One second, is the time right?” That's a nice title: “Is it white? And is the time right?” Okay, maybe it's something along those lines. Either way, you have to see if the time is right. Just because something can be said, should it be said? Should it be said?

You know, the Seder (Passover ritual meal)—I said this on Pesach—has a beautiful idea in it: the Karpas. We dip the celery in the salt water. Our Rabbis tell us that it's reminding us of another dipping that took place historically, one that actually wound us up in Egypt. Which dipping? The celery in the salt water is there to remind us of which dipping? Of the dipping of Yosef's robe in the blood, our Rabbis tell us. The Karpas reminds us of the words Ketonet Passim (Yosef's robe). It's there to remind us of the reason we ended up in Egypt in the first place. It's because of the brothers' hatred and the Sinat Chinam (baseless hatred), and because they sold Yosef. So what do we do? We dip celery in the salt water. That's a very nice idea. The obvious question is: If this is such a big reason we ended up there, why is there no explicit mention of it anywhere in the Haggadah? Why do we only allude to it by dipping? We speak about Lavan, we speak about Paro, so why don't we speak about Yosef and the sale? That should be front and center somewhere in the Magid section. We should talk about that.

There's this beautiful Chiddush (new insight) in the attached Haggadah. It's a great Haggadah based on attachment theory, with a lot about emotion, trauma, and healing. It's one approach to the entire Haggadah. Beautiful. If anyone's interested in that kind of thought, that kind of thinking, Torah, help, and therapy, he says something beautiful there. In life, things are always taking place on two different planes. On the one hand, there's human action, things that we do as humans. We have free choice. We believe in free choice. We choose. At the very same time, we believe in divine providence, that Hashem has a plan, that things play out the way they play out. Yosef is a great example of this. On the one hand, the brothers sold him. At the same time, Yosef even said, “It's not you; it's Hashem. You didn't do it to me; Hashem did it to me.” Hashem did it to me. This was part of His plan. We were going to end up here anyway. That's a beautiful thing to believe: whatever I'm going through, whatever pain or challenges, whatever people did to me, to believe that it wasn't you. Hashem is doing it to me. That's a very high level. For a lot of people, that idea sits well. For a lot of people, it's hard to swallow. “What do you mean? So what, now the Nazis did nothing wrong? Hashem wanted it to happen? What are you saying? A guy abused me? So now what, he's guilt-free because it was part of Hashem's plan? What are you saying?” For some people, this could be a problem. It could raise a lot of questions. It could be difficult to swallow.

So he says, “What do we do? We put the salt water on the table.” It's an idea, an idea that we were meant to be in Egypt, that it was divine. But we're not going to say it out loud because it's not sensitive to say to people. If you appreciate it, if it sits well with you, here's the salt water, here's the celery. Eat it. Meditate on it. Think about it, and let it resonate with you. The idea is that we place it on the table. It's a concept. It exists. But we're not going to say it out loud. We're not going to force everyone at the table to hear it, because maybe people at the table are not at a point in their lives when they can...

I think this is such a powerful idea about what we're talking about. Just because something may be emet, truth, but actually truth in Judaism is not always objective. Truth is also what needs to be said in this very moment in time. If something should not be said right now, then saying it is sheker (falsehood), even though maybe, objectively, it's true. But true means: not only is it true, but is it also the right time to say it? If it's not, then it's not true. That's what Rav Dessler says. It's not true. It's not emet. If it's not the right time, it's not true.

When Yaakov told his father, “I'm Esav,” that was the right thing that had to be said at that moment in time. That was emet. That's the truth. He had to say it at that moment in time. If there's a patient who's sick in the hospital and he's dying, and the family knows it, and the guy himself asks, “How do I look, Doctor? What's...?” it doesn't help to tell him, “You look horrible. You look like you're going to die.” It doesn't help. You say, “You look great. Try to look good.” Are you lying? You're not lying. That's the emet. That's the emet. Emet means: What is the thing that needs to be said in this specific moment in time? We have to be very sensitive in life, because timing is everything.

The first commandment we were given after the Torah, after Har Sinai, concerns the laws of a Hebrew slave. The Torah goes on and explains those laws. If you buy a slave, you have to keep him only for six years, then send him away in the seventh year. It also explains how you have to treat him: you have to give him nice pillows and accommodations, et cetera, et cetera. The question is, why is this the law that's given to us right now? This law isn't going to apply until we're in Israel, with the Jubilee. The laws didn't take effect until many, many decades later. What in the world is the rush? Why is Torah telling us the law now, the second we left Egypt? What does it have to do with anything? We're going to be in the desert for a long time. They're not going to matter. Tell me something more relevant, more practical. It's not so easy to part with a slave. You get used to it. You get used to having help. People who have a housekeeper know, right? It's a big advantage. Now the Torah's telling me I have to let him go in the sixth year. I have to send him free in the seventh. It's hard, hard to do that. So it says in... So therefore, the Torah very strategically gave us the commandment right away after we were freed from slavery, because Hashem knew we would be able to empathize with the idea of a slave and setting him free. We would be able to appreciate it most right here, right now. We would be most receptive to the halakha (Jewish law) that we should let a slave go, right away after we were freed from slavery ourselves. Therefore, Hashem picked this moment in time to tell it to us, because that's when He knew we would hear it best.

That is, my friends—what do you mean? God said it; what's the question? Who are you to question God? No, no, no. Even if I'm God, even if I'm saying, “When is the right time? When is the most opportune moment? When will you be most receptive?”—because everything has a time. Sometimes it's not the right time. Sometimes it's not the right time. We'll be very wise in life. Our parenting, our marriages, and our companies will be so much more effective. We'll run so much better if we learn this lesson, if we know what's going on not only with people, but also what's going on in their personal lives, and if we can pause and think about the bigger picture.

Maybe in a way, this is the biggest lesson for the leper. Here is a man who just spoke because of something he saw. He was so quick to judge a situation based on something. If only he would stop and think, “One second, I'm going to cause this person to get fired. One second, maybe this is not the right time. Maybe there's more to the story.” Maybe the biggest lesson is that we show him, “Dude, we're taking everything in your life into account. We're looking at your picture. You have a wedding coming up. We're not going to ruin that wedding.” Hopefully, it'll be a wake-up call to the leper himself, to this person who spoke gossip. That's something that requires a lot of thought: thinking about not only what to say, but also when to say it.

Going back to Yosef and his story: after he reveals himself, Ani Yosef, “I am Yosef.” Ha'od avi chai, “My father, is he still alive?” Our Rabbis learn from here, Oy lanu miYom haDin, “Woe to us on the day of judgment”—woe to us on the day of judgment. The musar, the rebuke, that the brothers received at that point in time: Yosef gave a very powerful rebuke in very few words. “I am Yosef. Is my father still alive?” Do you know what he was saying? Yosef was saying—not, “I'm Yosef, and, you know, why did you sell me?” Not, “I'm Yosef.” Yosef was saying something very simple: “How will I ever get back those lost years with my father?” Sometimes the biggest rebuke we give someone is, “You hurt me. You hurt me. You caused me...” I just want you to know: you hurt me. That's a rebuke that has almost no answer to it. You caused someone pain. “I want you to know, you hurt me.”

And really, sometimes an abuser will say, “Actually, you caused yourself this pain. No, I didn't do it to you. You did it to you. It's your fault.” Right? “If you didn't provoke me, I wouldn't have done it to you. I only hit you, or I only yelled at you, because you did this to me. You made me yell at you in front of our daughter. You made me do it. Look what you did. Look what you did.” Very controlling. Gaslighting: “It's your fault. You started it.”

The Pasuk says the brothers could not answer him. But it sounds like, from the Pasuk, that they actually did want to answer. What did they want to answer? We just explained: there's nothing you could answer. But maybe the Torah is saying that the brothers could actually have answered Yosef: “Really? You're blaming us for all this? We sold you? Right, because you're so innocent in all this. You didn't play a role in any of this. You weren't trying to talk gossip to Dad about us. No, no, no, you were a tzaddik. Innocent you, huh? Little victim you. You didn't do anything. You didn't stir things up. No, you're clean in all this. Right, Yosef?” The brothers really could have said, “Yosef, you're also guilty, man. It takes two to tango. We didn't pick on Binyamin. We sold you. What did you have to show off your dreams for? You had to tell Dad, tattle-tale on us, about what we're doing over there. What did you have to do? You're picking fights, Yosef. It's your fault.” The brothers could have said, “It's your fault.” They had something to say. But they didn't, because now's not the right time. When their brother is crying, confessing, opening up, making himself vulnerable, now's not the right time. Maybe at a later time we'll find a way to tell Yosef that he's also guilty. Maybe. But not today. Today he's crying. Today he's in pain. Today he needs to be allowed to vent. We have to allow people around us to vent, my friends. We have to give them that ability. We can't shut them down every time, or they won't feel like they can come to us anymore. They won't be able to confide in us. You can't open up. You can't build relationships. The brothers said, “This is not the time to rebuke Yosef. Today Yosef is right. Maybe overall he's wrong, but today he's not wrong. Today we keep our mouths shut. Let him cry.”

Pirkei Avot, Chapter 4, Mishnah 18. What does it say there? There are different versions, different Mishnayot. Rabbi Shimon Elazar says, “Do not appease your fellow at the time of his anger. Do not console him while his dead lies before him.” That's it. It's that simple. Sometimes, sometimes, it's not the right time. Not the right time today. Later.

So here's the lesson of the Meshech Chochmah from the leper. A beautiful lesson of V'ra'ahu, V'ra'ahu: Sometimes we gotta look, and sometimes we gotta look again. We have to know what needs to be said, but also, Hashem should bless us with the wisdom to know when to say it, when those around us will be most receptive to hearing our words. We'll stop over here. Have a wonderful day and we'll see you all tomorrow. Bye-bye.