A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Ashear

Living Emunah

The Purpose of Hishtadlut

Lectured by Rabbi David Ashear

Published
November 17, 2026
Duration
06:10

We know that Hashem controls everything that happens in this world. Although we have to make a hishtadlut to accomplish things, it is not our efforts that bring about results.

Everything happens only from Hashem. And the question was asked, if Hashem is going to do whatever He wants anyway, why did He require us to make a hishtadlut?

The Chovot HaLevavot in the Shar HaBitachon explains, one of the reasons is to test us. Hashem, in His infinite wisdom, created us with many needs that require us to go out and make efforts to fulfill.

Throughout that process, we're constantly being tested to see if we're going to stay faithful to Him. We're in this world to grow and fulfill a purpose, and a major part of that purpose is overcoming Nisyonot. We read about our greats throughout history and see how much they accomplished through the tests that Hashem gave them.

When we truly internalize that our efforts are not what bring us success, it becomes easier to make the right decisions. We know Hashem never needs us to do anything wrong to give us what He wants us to have.

The great Mechanech, Rabbi Moshe Turk Z"l, who lived to the age of 99, served as the principal of the Talmud Torah, Yesodeh HaTorah in Tel Aviv for 50 years.

His grandson, who heard the following story directly from his grandfather, related what happened when Rabbi Turk first moved to Israel.

At that time, there was tremendous poverty. Many families barely had enough food to survive from one day to the next.

Rabbi Turk felt so fortunate that he found a job working in a store. He was a dedicated and trustworthy worker and would thank Hashem for the zechut, to be able to support his family with dignity.

One day, the owner of that store, who was not religious, approached him and said, "I'm very happy with your work and I want you to continue here, but there's one condition. You can't wear your kippah. I have no problem with you being religious, but in this store, we don't wear kippot."

Rabbi Turk couldn't believe what he was hearing.

His kippah was a symbol of his yirat shamayim, a constant reminder that Hashem was above him and that he was always in his presence. And he told the owner how important it was to him, but the owner would not change his mind.

Rabbi Turk was faced with a very difficult decision.

He had a family to support. It was very hard to find a job, and he had no idea where he would find another one. But one thing was clear.

It couldn't be that Hashem wanted him to compromise his avodat Hashem to earn a livelihood. Anyway, it was Hashem providing his parnasah, and he surely would do it without requiring him to take off his kippah.

And so he left the job.

He prayed to Hashem to find another way to support his family. In the meantime, with more time available, he began spending his days learning in a local yeshiva in Tel Aviv. He became so involved in learning and eventually helping that yeshiva, Yesodeh, HaTorah in different ways.

Over time, he was given more responsibilities there until eventually he was appointed the principal, a position he would hold for the next 50 years.

During those years, he helped be mechanech thousands of students, instilling in them Torah and Yirat Shammayim.

Many years later, a father came to the school with his son who was approaching his bar mitzvah.

The father asked Rabbi Turk if he could prepare the boy, teaching him how to put on his tefillin and read the Torah.

Rabbi Turk happily agreed.

The father then said, "I know this is not part of your regular responsibilities. Tell me how much I should pay you."

Rabbi Turk said, "For you, I wouldn't charge a thing."

"Why not?" the man asked.

Rabbi Turk said, "Because I owe you everything that I have today."

The man didn't understand why.

Rabbi Turk continued, "Don't you remember me many years ago? I worked for you in your store. You told me I couldn't wear my kippah and I had to leave."

The man was so embarrassed when he realized who was standing in front of him.

Rabbi Turk explained everything worked out exactly the way it was supposed to. Losing his job at that time led him to the yeshiva where he couldn't be happier.

The grandson related how Rabbi Turk recognized Hashem was testing him when he faced that very hard decision. It was a difficult Nisayun.

He was living in a time of poverty, with a family depending on him and was being asked to give up his paranasa and Baruch Hashem, he passed that test.

Hashem doesn't need our efforts to give us what we're supposed to have. He wants us to make efforts because of what we could accomplish in our Avodat Hashem through them.

Especially when it comes to earning a livelihood, there are so many Nisayunot. A person may feel he has to compromise on something important to succeed. He may feel pressured to do something dishonest or sacrifice his Torah learning or give up other parts of Avodat Hashem because of a business that demands so much of his time.

But if we truly believe Hashem is providing our paranasa, we have to recognize He never needs us to go against His will to get it.

With Hashem's help, we should always have the clarity to make the right decisions and overcome all the tests that come our way and continue growing closer to Hashem.