A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Shelby

Torah Lecture

Daily Mishnah: Seder TAHAROT Masechet Ohalot 16:4-5

Lectured by Rabbi David Shelby

Published
November 9, 2026
Duration
5:52
Lecture code
RDSH-MY-140

Searching for Buried Remains

  • When someone searching for treasure finds a body, he must check the area for 20 amot. He does not check every amah: because an amah must be left between bodies, checking the amah immediately next to the body could falsely suggest the area is clear. He checks every other amah from the place where the body was found.
  • He continues digging until he reaches stone or earth that was never dug, which indicates that no one is buried there.

Dirt, Stones, and a Kohen’s Terumah

  • Certain kinds of dirt are treated as possibly impure. A kohen is not allowed to dig there; nevertheless, if he did so and found nothing, he may eat.
  • This differs from a pile of stones that fell on someone. If a kohen removes the stones one by one, he may not eat terumah.

Natural and Public Boundaries

  • A person searching may stop when he reaches a river or large body of water, such as a swamp or pond, or when he reaches a road, since these are assumed not to contain buried remains.

When the Surrounding Dirt Must Be Removed

  • In cases where bodies were found in a field, it matters whether the location was an actual grave. When a body is moved from an actual grave, the dirt beneath it must also be taken, since it absorbs liquids from the body. If the body was moved from a place that was not its permanent burial place, or was there temporarily, the dirt need not be taken.
  • When the Mishnah says “hakol tahor” (“Everything is pure”), it refers to the surrounding dirt, not the body. The dirt around a body that was not in an actual grave is tahor; around an actual grave, it must be removed.
  • If bones are scattered through a field, they are collected one at a time, and the dirt beneath them is tahor.
  • If a body is in a temporary cavern, it is moved bone by bone, and the dirt is tahor.
  • A pit that was used for burial but never covered is not considered a real kever, so its surrounding dirt need not be removed.
  • Likewise, if a pit contained miscarriages or people who died but was never covered, the dirt remains tahor. Rabbi Shimon disagrees with the Tanna Kama: if the pit was designated as a kever from the outset, Rabbi Shimon requires the dirt to be removed even though the pit was not covered. The halakha follows the Tanna Kama.