The Theme of
Tammuz: Haman's Mindset
Welcome to
Daily Bitachon. We are going to continue exploring a theme we spoke about
previously: that the core theme of the month of Tammuz is "Vechol zeh
einennu shoveh li"—"Yet all this is worth nothing to me."
This famous
quote from Haman reveals a dangerous mindset: despite having absolutely
everything, because he was missing just one thing, he felt he had nothing.
The Root of the
Snake
This attitude
traces all the way back to the primordial snake. The Sages note that the source
for Haman in the Torah is hinted at in the verse, "Hamin ha'etz" (from
the tree), which sounds like "Haman ha'etz" (Haman on the
tree). But the Rabbis also explain that Haman is spiritually rooted in the
snake. In Bereishit 3:1, the snake asks Chavah:
"Af ki amar
Elokim lo tochlu mikol etz hagan…"
"Did God
really say you cannot eat from any tree of the garden?"
Chavah replies
that they can eat from the fruit of the trees, except for the one in the middle
of the garden, which God commanded them not to touch. The snake's strategy was
to shift her focus to the one restriction, essentially saying, "If you
can't have this, you have nothing."
Esav and the
Snake Theme
Haman descended
from Amalek, who descended from Esav. Not surprisingly, Esav continues this
exact same "snake" theme.
We see a very
interesting concept regarding this in Bereishit 25:27:
"Vayigdlu
hana'arim…"
"And the
lads grew up; and Esav was a cunning hunter, a man of the field; and Yaakov was
a wholesome man, dwelling in tents."
The Targum
translates the words "Esav ish yode'a tzayid" (Esav was a hunter) as "Vehavah
Esav gevar nachshirchan." He was a nachshirchan man. What does nachshirchan
mean? Many commentaries read it as two words: nachash yarchan, which
means "snake thighs."
Some explain
this simply to mean that when Esav was hunting, he would lie flat on his
stomach and slither like a snake to catch his prey. However, the Shelah
HaKadosh quotes a book called the Tziyuni, which offers a deeper
insight: Esav actually had a literal image of a snake etched onto his thigh. He
had a tattoo of a snake.
The Wrestling
Match
This sheds new
light on the wrestling match between Yaakov and Esav's guardian angel. The
Torah states that the angel wanted to touch "kaf yerech Yaakov"—the
socket of Yaakov's thigh. He wanted to infect the children of Yaakov with this
snake-like approach to life.
But concerning
that encounter, we say, "Velo yachol lo"—he could not overcome him. Why
not? As Bilam later declares:
"Ki lo nachash
b'Yaakov"
"There is
no sorcery in Yaakov."
Homiletically,
this can be read as: "There are no snakes in Yaakov." We do
not subscribe to that snake-like perspective. Instead, Yaakov Avinu embodies
the opposite approach: whatever Hashem gives me is good, and I am happy.
(Parenthetically,
we will see later that the wrestling match between Yaakov and the angel
actually occurred on Tisha B'Av, meaning Tisha B'Av has a deep connection to
this concept. Additionally, the Sefer Ahavat Shalom on Parshat Toldot notes
that Yaakov was the one who rectified the sin of Adam HaRishon. As the Talmud
in Bava Metzia states, Yaakov Avinu possessed the identical beauty of Adam
HaRishon. Yaakov's face is engraved on the Kiseh HaKavod [Throne of Glory],
representing the ultimate human paradigm. Therefore, he is the ultimate
spiritual counterforce to Esav, who represents the snake.)
Two Approaches
to Life: Yesh Li Rav vs. Yesh Li Kol
Where else do
we see Esav embodying the mindset of the snake?
In Bereishit
33:9, when Esav receives a massive gift from Yaakov, he initially declines it,
saying, "Yesh li rav"—"I have a lot. Keep what is yours, my
brother."
But Yaakov
insists, saying, "Veyesh li kol"—"I have everything."
The Chofetz
Chaim explains that these represent two fundamental approaches to life:
- Esav's
approach (Yesh li rav):
"I have a lot, but I could always use more."
- Yaakov's
approach (Yesh li kol):
"I have everything."
How can a
person claim to have everything? The answer is that when you recognize
that HaKadosh Baruch Hu provides exact hashgacha pratit (divine
providence) tailored to your specific needs, you realize you already possess
everything you require.
We reference
this every single day in Birkat HaMazon:
"Harachaman
hu yivarech otanu... kmo sheinitbarchu avoteinu, Avraham, Yitzchak,
v'Yaakov—bakol, mikol, kol."
What do these
three words mean?
Regarding
Avraham, the verse says, "V'Hashem berach et Avraham bakol"
(with everything).
Regarding
Yitzchak, it says he ate "mikol" (from
everything).
The
ultimate culmination is Yaakov, who proclaimed, "Yesh li kol"
(I have everything).
We ask Hashem
to bless us collectively with that exact same blessing of kol.
Lavan's Attack
on Kol
We see this
theme pop up again in the Haggadah on Pesach: "Tzei u'lmad mah bikeish Lavan
haArami la'asot l'Yaakov Avinu..." While Pharaoh only decreed against the
male children, Lavan "bikeish la'akor et hakol"—he sought to uproot
everything.
Chassidic
masters (brought down by Rabbi Shor in his commentary on Pesach, Lekach
V'Libuv) explain this deeply: Lavan didn't just want to destroy Yaakov's
physical property; he wanted to uproot the very concept of kol from
Yaakov. He wanted to destroy Yaakov's peaceful, content approach to life.
This is a major, fundamental debate on how to live.
The Ultimate
Synthesis: She'asah Li Kol Tzorki
Listen to this
unbelievable explanation that ties it all together.
Every single
morning, we recite one of our most important morning blessings: "She'asah li
kol tzorki"—"Who has provided me with all my needs." This means
that whether physically or spiritually, God has already given me every single
tool necessary to fulfill my unique mission in life.
Look closely at
the wording: She'asah li... kol tzorki.
Li (for me) and kol (everything) are the two magical words.
Now look back
at Haman. What did he say?
"Vechol
zeh einennu shoveh li."
Haman is the
exact antithesis of kol and li. He rejects the blessing of She'asahi
li kol tzorki. He looks at his life and says, "No, I do not have
everything I need. I am missing that one thing (Mordechai bowing), so it's all
worthless."
That is the
negative energy of Tammuz. That is the destructive force that led to the churban
(destruction of the Temple). And that is exactly what we are trying to undo
during this month: rebuilding our perspective to match Yaakov's, knowing that
God has given us everything we need. As we wind down the month of Tammuz, put a
little extra focus and intention into the blessing of She'asah li kol tzorki.
The Final
Clincher
To wrap this
all up: there are only two days a year when we do not recite the blessing of She'asah
li kol tzorki, and they happen to be the two days we do not wash our hands
fully in the morning: Tisha B'Av and Yom Kippur.
The Kabbalists
explain:
- On Tisha
B'Av, the spiritual impurity (tumah) is so potent we cannot
fully remove it.
- On Yom
Kippur, the holiness (kedusha) is so intense we don't even need
to remove it.
Tisha B'Av is
the day of Esav. On that day, Esav's energy temporarily takes over, so we omit She'asah
li kol tzorki. But on Yom Kippur—the day of Yaakov Avinu—we cast the sa'ir
(the goat representing Esav, the ish sa'ir) off the cliff, and the Kohen
Gadol enters the Holy of Holies. On that day, the reality of She'asah li kol
tzorki is so utterly apparent and deeply felt that we don't even need to
vocalize it.
We have covered
a massive theme with a lot of moving parts. Review these concepts, and
hopefully, we will all merit to live on that elevated spiritual level of kol.