A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Sutton

Daily Bitachon

The Torah Definition of Wealth and Poverty

Lectured by Rabbi David Sutton

Published
December 17, 2019
Duration
05:03

We continue with the advantages of having a bitachon outlook when things don’t necessarily go right (or when we aren’t sure if they’ll go right).

In the words of the Hovot HaLevavot,

The one who relies on G-d,

נפשו במנוחה ולבו שלו מצד הגזרות

His soul is at peace (he’s tranquil and relaxed), and his heart is serene, regarding the decrees of G-d.

There are people that are often worried about what will be, but the Baal Bitachon is not,

לדעתו כי הבורא ינהיגן לטובתו

Because he knows that whatever G-d is doing to him, or leading him, to is the best way for him to go, both in this world and the next.

On the other hand, the one who doesn’t rely on G-d is always in pain,

‎ודאגה ארוכה ואבל ועצב ‎לא ימושו ממנו בטובה וברעה.

And has elongated worry (which we will call anxiety), mourning and sadness (what we call depression)

This is before modern day psychology! The Hovot Halevavot is telling us that a man who doesn’t have bitachon is anxious and depressed about what might be, even in the absence of actual problems. He’s afraid of what might happen. He’s never happy, because he’s always worried.

He quotes a beautiful pasuk from Mishleh that also happens to be the last line of the Shulchan Aruch Or Hachaim (with the commentary of the Rama).

Shlomo HaMelech tells us:

‎ כל ימי עני רעים

All the days of the poor man are bad

‎וטוב לב משתה תמיד

But a man with a good heart is always at a party.

Initially, upon reading this, one might think that the man in a low financial bracket is always miserable, but Mishleh is not meant to be understood literally. Mishleh is a mashal.

If this was meant to literal, it would say the poor man is miserable, but life is always a party for the wealthy man.

But it doesn’t say that. It compares the poor man to the one with a good heart. Therefore, as the Gemarah tells us, this “poor” man is not referring to one who is monetarily poor. Rather, it means he’s poor in his brain and in his outlook on life. He’s poor because he lacks דעת -knowledge, and understanding. Without the right outlook on life, a person is truly poor. If he does have the right outlook, he’s truly wealthy, because he knows how to approach every situation.

The Gemara in Masechet Nedarim says

אמר אביי, נקטינן, אין עני אלא בדעה.

Abaye says, we have a tradition, that whenever it says the word. “ עני -poor” it means poor in intellect and knowing how to looks at things.

Based on this, the Maharsha tells us that when we see the term “עני -poor” used to describe financial status, it’s actually a borrowed term. A person can have no money and be the happiest man in the word. “Poor” means you don’t know how to approach life.

The Gemarah in Nedarim continues, saying that in Israel, they used to say:

‎, דדא ביה- כולא ביה -‎דלא דא ביה- מה ביה.

If you have knowledge (you know how to view things properly), you have everything, But if you don’t have this understanding, you have nothing

‎דדא קני- מה חסר ? ‎דדא לא קני- מה קני?

If you’ve acquired knowledge (the right outlook) what are you lacking?

If you haven’t acquired the right outlook, what do you have?

Therefore, the wealthiest man is the man that knows how to look at things properly.

Rabbenu Yonah quotes this pasuk and says,

טוב לב, משמח מחלקו

The one who is happy with his lot is Tov Lev- happy.

This can only happen with bitachon. It means knowing that my house, my wife, and my children are all perfect for me, and that every little challenge I go through is exactly what I need.

The man who’s a Tov-Lev (happy, content), he’s at a constant party. He’s thrilled with life. That’s Tov Lev.

Finally, Rabbenu Yonah says,היא מידה טובה את מאד

This is the greatest of traits to have. It’s real wealth.

The mishnah in Pirke Avot says,

איזה הוא עשיר? השמח בחלקו

Who is wealthy? The one who is happy with his lot.

Rabbi Ades points out that it doesn’t say it’s another way to be wealthy, or that it’s a substitute for being wealthy or that it’s artificial wealth. No. This IS wealth. The Hovot HaLevavot is teaching us that the definition of a wealthy person, in our lexicon, is someone with the right attitude.

And a poor man is someone who has the wrong attitude on life.

That’s the Torah definition of wealth and poverty, and it all comes from Bitachon.

Bitachon gives us this power. With Bitachon, we aren’t anxious, or nervous, or worried. We are wealthy, and happy. We are partying because we know Hashem is taking care of us.

Have a wonderful day.