A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

Class #31 - Chapter #10 - Avoiding Hillul Shabbat When Lighting Hanukkah Candles

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
January 26, 2026
Duration
12:14
Lecture code
RDT-345

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good afternoon. We’re in chapter 10 of Chazon Ovadia, Laws of Hanukkah. In this chapter, we’re talking about lighting the candles on Friday afternoon, Halakha yod aleph, making sure people pay attention to the time so they don’t panic and accidentally light the candles after sunset, when it is already Shabbat. We’re also talking about lighting the Hanukkah candles on motzaei Shabbat, Saturday night, when Shabbat ends.

On Erev Shabbat (eve of Shabbat), when one lights the Hanukkah candles near the entrance to his home, he should make sure to put something there to protect the candles, so that when he opens the door to go in and out, the wind doesn’t blow them out. This applies to people who light the candles right at their doorway, where the candles are literally exposed to the outside when they open the door. This is how it used to be, and people still do it today in Israel: they light outside.

When a person lights outside on Friday afternoon, there is another concern: making sure he doesn’t do something that will put out the candles. If he lights right by the entrance and the wind comes in when he opens the door, or the force of opening the door creates a gust that will put out the candles, he has to be mindful of that. He should either put something around the candles to block the wind, or open the door gently, making sure there is no wind or force that will put them out. Otherwise, he is causing them to go out, which is a violation on Shabbat.

It is also forbidden to attach the Hanukkiah (Hanukkah lamp) to the door. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen anybody do this, but if it is attached so that opening and closing the door causes the candles to go out, or causes them to diminish or grow, that is a problem. Even if he opens and closes the door gently, the oil will sway one way or the other, either moving away from the wick or closer to it, causing the flame to burn brighter or weaker. That could be a violation of extinguishing or lighting.

To make a long story short, when a person lights the candles on Friday afternoon, if they are by the door, he has to make sure that nothing he does will cause them to diminish, grow, or burn brighter, because that would be a violation on Shabbat. Even though he does not intend this explicitly, if it is guaranteed to happen, it is forbidden. But if they are wax candles, and there is no oil to move away from the wick, then that would be okay.

If he attaches the candles to the door, the door does not become Muktzeh (items set aside from use). Since the door is attached to the house, and the house is attached to the ground, the door is not its own movable entity; it is part of the larger structure of the house. The concept of Muktzeh does not apply to it. Muktzeh applies only to movable items. Even though the door swings open and closed, because it is attached to the house, it is not considered a utensil; it is considered part of a structure. Just as there is no violation in opening and closing a window, or anything like that, the door cannot become Muktzeh either.

After the Hanukkah candles go out on Friday night, once they run out of fuel, one may not move the Hanukkiah with whatever residue is left on it: the remains of wax candles, the wicks, or, if he uses cups of oil, the burnt-out wicks. He cannot move the Hanukkiah from its place unless he made an explicit condition on Friday afternoon. This is part of the laws of Muktzeh.

When a person lights a candle going into Shabbat, the fact that he lit it means he is not going to touch the item—the candlesticks or candelabra—once Shabbat begins, because moving it would be a violation of Muktzeh. The rabbi said that, generally speaking, whenever an item is Muktzeh when Shabbat begins, that status extends throughout the entire Shabbat, no matter what. There is one exception: candles. Why are candles an exception? When a person lights them, he knows they will not burn forever and anticipates that at some point they will go out on Shabbat. So it is reasonable to assume that although he lit the candle going into Shabbat, he might have in mind that when it goes out, he will want to move it. But the rabbi says he has to make an explicit condition. This also applies to Shabbat candles.

Let’s say a person lit the Shabbat candles on his dining room table, where everybody is going to eat, and then on Shabbat morning he wants to move them off the table to make room for more guests. He can do so only if, before Shabbat, he made a condition that once the candles go out, he will be permitted to move the candlesticks. If he had that in mind ahead of time, knowing and anticipating that the candles would go out, then he could move them. But if he did not, then once he lit the candles, he gave them the status of Muktzeh. If he did not make the condition ahead of time, that status remains for the entire Shabbat. The same law that applies to the Shabbat candlesticks applies to the Hanukkiah. So if one lights the Hanukkiah on Friday afternoon and wants to be able to move it during Shabbat after the candles have gone out, he has to make that condition before Shabbat begins.

That ends our discussion of lighting candles on Friday afternoon. Now we transition to lighting candles on motzaei Shabbat. Shabbat is ending. What do we do about lighting Hanukkah candles and also making Havdalah (a clear ending of the Shabbat)? We have two things to do, both having to do with lighting fire. What do we do first? On Motzaei Shabbat Hanukkah, in the synagogue, we light the Hanukkah candles first and then make Havdalah. At home, we light the other candle and then the Hanukkah candle. But at home, we reverse the order: first we make Havdalah, and then we light the Hanukkah candles.

What is the logic behind doing things in a different order in the synagogue and at home? The first thing we have to realize is that in the prayer a person says on motzaei Shabbat, he says Atah Honantanu. That is called a Havdalah. That prayer in Arvit (evening service) essentially ends Shabbat for him. The time passes, and he makes a clear declaration that Shabbat is over. He recites Havdalah in the Tefillah (prayer), so that really ends Shabbat. At that point, the person is able to do Melachah (forbidden labor).

That is why, in the synagogue, we are not afraid to light the Hanukkah candles, assuming the time for Shabbat has ended and you have said Atah Honantanu right after Arvit. We are not afraid to light the Hanukkah candles because Shabbat has ended and we have made Havdalah. Why do we want to light them before making Havdalah over a cup of wine with Borei me'orei ha'esh (for the creation of fire Saturday night)? Because if we wait until the end of the prayers to light the Hanukkah candles, after Havdalah, we know what happens: half the crowd stays for Havdalah, maybe less than that, and as soon as Havdalah is over, everyone runs out. Then we lose the whole point of lighting the Hanukkah candles in the synagogue, which is Pirsumei Nisa, to spread the miracle. So, right after we pray the Amidah in Arvit, we light the Hanukkah candles. That way, we get at least a few minutes when the Kahal (congregation) is sitting and looking at the candles, and they get the Pirsumei Nisa, the publicity of the miracle. They also realize how many candles they are going to light when they go home and learn the procedure.

At the end of the Tefillah, we make Havdalah over the cup of wine with Borei me'orei ha'esh, which is fine after the Hanukkah candles. You might argue, “Rabbi, I thought we have the concept of tadir v'she'eino tadir, tadir kodem, when you have two things to do at once, the thing that comes more frequently takes priority. So Havdalah should take priority over Hanukkah.” In the synagogue, however, Pirsumei Nisa—the publicity of the miracle—is paramount for us with the Hanukkah candles, so we do not delay it until after Havdalah.

When a person goes home, though, it is a bit strange, especially for the family members. His wife and children might not have prayed Tefillat Arvit (evening service prayer), so they might not have said Havdalah. Lighting the Hanukkah candles before they have said Havdalah and made any conclusion of Shabbat could be a violation. It is also strange to light the Hanukkah candles before Havdalah when you are already home and the Pirsumei Nisa is within the family. Tadir v'she'eino tadir, tadir kodem, and you want to make a clear ending of Shabbat before you go ahead and light the Hanukkah candles. So when you go home, the person makes Havdalah first over the cup of wine, and then lights the Hanukkah candles.

Additionally, there is another svarah (reason) for the order in the synagogue: we want to formally delay the ending of Shabbat as much as possible. So we like to say Havdalah afterward, so to speak, extending Shabbat. We are not really extending it, because we are lighting candles, which clearly shows that we are not treating it as Shabbat. But we formally do not end Shabbat with Havdalah until as late as possible. That is the difference between the situations.

If a person, for whatever reason, botched the order, then lo nora (no problem), as long as he did not light candles before saying some kind of Havdalah in the Tefillah and saying Hamavdil bein kodesh lechol (Who separates between holy and ordinary). So if he went home and lit the Hanukkah candles before Havdalah, that is also okay, but ideally you want to do it in the reverse order.

Halakha yod gimel. As part of our Havdalah, we are going to make the beracha (blessing) of Borei me'orei ha'esh. We are going to light a fire and say, “I’ll make Borei me'orei ha'esh for the creation of fire Saturday night.” Let’s say a person says, “You know what, Rabbi? Why not kill two birds with one stone? I’ll light the Hanukkah candles and make Borei me'orei ha'esh on them.” Can I make Borei me'orei ha'esh on the Hanukkah candles? Or do I need a separate fire, a separate Havdalah candle, so to speak, for Borei me'orei ha'esh?

Hacham Ovadia says, “Ein levarech birkat Borei me'orei ha'esh al ner Hanukkah (One is not permitted to make the blessing of Borei me'orei ha'esh on the candles of Hanukkah).” She'en mevarechim al ner Hanukkah (For one does not recite a blessing over a Hanukkah candle). Ad sheye'utu le'oro (Until one benefits from its light). What do we do with the Borei me'orei ha'esh that we say in Havdalah? We get close to it and put our hand next to it in order to do what? Why do we put our hand next to the Borei me'orei ha'esh? To use it, to benefit from it, to feel the warmth and see the light. You get close to the candle intending to use it, and you cannot make Borei me'orei ha'esh until you have a fire that you can benefit from. But we know that it is prohibited to derive any personal benefit from the Hanukkah candles. So they do not go together. It is a paradox: you cannot make Borei me'orei ha'esh on the Hanukkah candles if you need to get close to them and benefit from them personally. Right? He says, “I’m sorry?”

He says, “Now technically, many of us light the shamash (extra candle) so we can use its light. Technically, he can make the beracha, Borei me'orei ha'esh, and go close to the shamash, since that is for the purpose of use. It might be a little closer to comfort with the others. If a person has a Havdalah candle, it is better to use that. Plus, for most people, the shamash is not a multi-wicked candle. Usually, the practice for Havdalah is to have a torch, an avukah (torch), which has multiple wicks. By letter of the law, if one does not have multiple wicks and has only a single-wicked candle, that is acceptable, especially since the wicks we have today are usually multiple threads made into something very thick. It doubles as that. But technically, you should try to have multiple wicks. Therefore, I would avoid using the shamash. If one had nothing else but that, then obviously he would be able to use it as well.”

The last two halachot talk about lighting the Hanukkah candles for those who keep the time of Rabbeinu Tam after Shabbat. We’ll talk about that in our next class. Baruch Adonai le'olam (Blessed is the Lord forever). Amen ve'amen (Amen and amen).