A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

DH #106 - 10-17-25 - Contracted Work by a Goy on Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
October 20, 2025
Duration
2:34
Lecture code
DT-DH106

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

It's permissible for a person to drop off their clothes with a non-Jewish launderer before Shabbat and set a price for how much it's going to cost. Then the non-Jew decides when he wants to go ahead and clean them. If he decides to clean them on Shabbat, that's his decision. It's called ada'ata denafshei. You didn't instruct him to do it for you. The operation is happening off the premises of the Jew, and he set a price beforehand. So now, since it's a contracted job, if the goy (non-Jew) decides he wants to clean the Jew's clothing on Shabbat, that's up to him. You didn't instruct him to. Therefore, it would be permissible.

Like I said, it's because it's not happening in the Jew's house. There are no clear indicators that people walking by will notice that it's happening for a Jew. So it's not something that becomes public, and it's the non-Jew's decision to do it. But what happens if the particular thing you're contracting the goy to do is happening on the premises of the Jew, in the Jew's home? And especially if it's happening in something that's called mechubar la-karka. So, for example, you have a contract with your gardener to come and mow the lawn a certain number of times per month. Now he comes and wants to mow the lawn. Well, this is happening on your premises, on the premises of the Jew. It's mechubar la-karka. It's connected, and it becomes much more public. So even though the goy decides on his own when he wants to come, and you didn't instruct him, and he wants to do it to get paid, it's a problem because of mar'it ayin. Because people are going to see what's going on. They're not going to know that you contracted it. And therefore they're going to assume that the person is hiring them for the day to be able to do it and you instructed them.

Therefore there's a mar'it ayin situation. However, Hacham Ovadia says that if it's customary for the people of the town to all use a contractor, that's the normal way of doing things, and therefore there would not be a mar'it ayin situation. So then he says it's not a problem because everyone's going to know you don't pay the gardener for each time he comes. You pay based on a contract. If that's the standard, then it becomes permissible.

But one thing that a person should look out for, especially in these types of cases, is what they call zilzul Shabbat. Particularly with something like mowing the lawn or fixing the roof, or things of that nature, because they have a very public nature to them. They make a lot of noise. They can disrupt the neighborhood's peace and quiet on Shabbat. There is a concept of zilzul Shabbat. It is preferable for a person to try to avoid this and to tell their gardener or contractor, "Please don't come," even though everybody knows it's being contracted. Please don't come on Shabbat. It disrupts the neighborhood. It downgrades the serenity and peace and tranquility on Shabbat. And therefore we shouldn't do it. But if they happen to show up and everybody knows, then if there's nothing the person can do about it, it's not against the halakha (Jewish law) for him to allow the person to do it, since everybody knows it's contracted and the guy does it on his own. Shabbat Shalom.