A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

DH #135 - 11-20-25 - Answering Amen to a ברכה לבטלה

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
November 25, 2025
Duration
1:35
Lecture code
RDT-218

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

If one hears another Jew recite a Beracha (blessing), one is required to answer amen (so be it) to that Beracha. The rabbis say that the one who answers amen to a Beracha is greater than even the one who recited it. This is because when one affirms a statement that somebody made about Hashem, he gives it validity, and that is greater than the person who even made the statement. If nobody were to answer amen, then nobody would know whether it was really a valid statement; it could be completely made up. So one is required to answer amen to the Beracha that he heard from a fellow Jew.

Even if one did not hear the full Beracha from beginning to end, as long as he heard the last few words, he is required to answer amen. It goes even further: if a person did not hear any part of the Beracha but sees that someone picked up a fruit and is moving his lips, and it is obvious that he is making a Beracha, but he knows the Beracha was recited, he has permission to answer amen. He is not required to, but he has permission to answer amen.

If a person heard a Beracha levatala (a blessing in vain), however, he is not supposed to answer amen. According to Hacham Ovadia, this goes so far as to say that if a person recites a Beracha that the other person is not required to say, but that is according to the other person’s minhag (custom), the other person should not answer amen, because for him it is a Beracha levatala. For example, Ashkenazim (Ashkenazi Jews) say Hallel on Rosh Chodesh (new month), reciting the full Hallel with a Beracha. This is not the practice of the Sephardim (Sephardic Jews). It is their minhag to recite a Beracha, not ours. According to Hacham Ovadia, a Sephardi would not be able to answer amen to the Beracha of an Ashkenazi who was reciting the full Hallel, because for him that is considered a Beracha levatala. However, there are other poskim (halachic authorities), like Reb Eliezer Melamed, who quotes the Chida, and other Sephardim, who said, “No, once it’s a good Beracha for him, even if it’s not your Beracha, you can answer amen.” So if a person does answer amen, Yesh lo al mah lismoch (he has what to rely on). Have a great day.