A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

DH #138 - 11-24-25 - Answering Amen in Vain

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
December 9, 2025
Duration
1:25
Lecture code
RDT-241

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Our hachamim (sages) warned against answering what's called an amen yetoma, an orphaned amen. That is to say, an amen that is not properly responding to a beracha (blessing) that is considered a valid halachic beracha. The hachamim were very concerned about beracha levatala (saying Hashem's name in vain). As such, they said that answering amen to something that is in vain would also constitute such a violation. Therefore, one should be careful to avoid that.

Therefore, if a person is listening to a recording of a shiur (class), and he hears that the rabbi on the recording made a beracha, because live when he was actually giving the shiur, he said, Now you're listening to the recording and you hear him say, You cannot answer amen to that beracha, because since the beracha is not happening in the moment, it's not live, it's not a valid beracha, to answer amen to such a beracha would be considered an amen yetoma.

However, if a person was listening to a class that was live via Zoom, FaceTime, Skype, or some other technology, then, since it's happening in real time, although it's being altered, a person does have the right to answer amen. He's not obligated to answer amen, but it is proper that he should, and he's not considered to have answered an amen yetoma.

However, to fulfill one's obligation of something that he needs to recite, if he was trying to fulfill his obligation of making a beracha or hearing the Megillah through some kind of technology, we would say that only if they were in a very extenuating circumstance should they ask a hacham to potentially use that, and probably without a beracha. Have a great day.