A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi David Tawil

Torah Lecture

DH #165 - 12-26-25 - Shoveling Snow on Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi David Tawil

Published
December 29, 2025
Duration
3:32
Lecture code
RDT-283

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Is it permissible for a person to shovel snow on Shabbat if they need to get out of their home and be able to make it to the Beit Knesset (synagogue), or to go to somebody else’s house for a meal on Shabbat? Kamuvan (of course), this question is only potentially a yes if there is an eruv (Sabbath boundary enclosure). If there’s no eruv, then carrying a shovel, moving the snow, or throwing the snow around in the public domain would obviously be asur (forbidden), and there would be no question. But assuming that there is an eruv that people follow, the question becomes: Is the snow muktzeh (set aside)? Rav Moshe Feinstein, in Volume 5 of Igrot Moshe, ruled that snow is muktzeh because it’s nolad (newly created). However, most poskim (halachic authorities) ruled that there is no din (law) of nolad for snow. This is the ruling of Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchatah by Neuwirth, in accordance with Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, and of Hacham Ovadia Yosef in Yalkut Yosef.

Just as if a person took ice and it melted in a cup, you’d be able to drink the ice, it’s not considered nolad because it changed its form. For something natural to go in and out of a form, from snow to liquid or something like that, it would not be considered an isur (prohibition) of nolad, and therefore he ruled that it’s not muktzeh. Therefore, it would be permissible for a person to shovel a pathway to get the snow out of the way, so they can go to Beit Knesset and perform a mitzvah (commandment). Additionally, there’s no issue of melting the snow, even though a person is not allowed to melt ice to turn it into liquid, because the person is doing it indirectly; he’s just trying to move it out of the way. If it ends up melting on its own, it is what it is. That’s why a person is allowed to walk in the snow as they wish, and it’s not considered a problem.

In terms of playing in the snow, most poskim ruled that making a snowman is asur because either it constitutes something more permanent, like building, or compacting the snow is an issue of melting it in order to create such a form. Therefore, playing in the snow in such a manner would not be allowed. Because shoveling is an activity that would be permissible for a Jew, if a person has an arrangement with a non-Jew to come and shovel their walkway, it’s not a problem. They can allow them to continue doing that. And if the goy (non-Jew) decides to bring a mechanical snowplow or a truck or something to do it, that’s a choice they’re making on their own. It’s not a violation for the Jew, and he can continue to let the goy do that.

Lastly, if there’s ice on the ground, a person can spread salt on the ice, even though it’s going to melt it, because it takes a little bit of time. And because it’s a hazard, a person is allowed to go ahead and do that so that nobody slips, falls, or is harmed, and the person is able to go ahead and do the mitzvah. If a person gets snow on their clothing, they’re allowed to gently shake it off or remove it from the clothing without pressing down hard, so it doesn’t get squeezed out of the garment. Have a great day.

A few further notes. Number one, a person should avoid shoveling areas that they don’t need, so as not to conduct unnecessary strenuous activity on Shabbat. They should really limit themselves to only the areas they need to be able to leave their house, go to Beit Knesset, and avoid any kind of harm. They should avoid shoveling out their cars and other things like that that are unnecessary on Shabbat. As well, there is no issue of shoveling as what we call choresh, like digging into the ground, because since the snow is above ground, you’re not digging into the actual ground itself. So that’s not a problem of choresh.

Lastly, although a shovel would typically be considered muktzeh as a kli shemelachto le'isur, a utensil whose normal usage is for something that’s forbidden, such as digging into the ground, you have what’s called a snow shovel. It’s designed not to dig into the ground, but rather to dig for snow. And as well, you could also use a kli shemelachto le'isur le'tzorech gufo, for some other need, which would be permissible. So since he’s not using it for the purposes of its normal, forbidden function, he’s using it for something that’s permissible, it’s not a violation of muktzeh.