A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eli Mansour

Torah Lecture

Book of Shemuel 2 Perek 17 (24-29) and 18 (1-18) The Hanging

Lectured by Rabbi Eli Mansour

Published
April 2, 2008
Duration
55:04
Lecture code
SNSB20

The End of Perek 17: Amasa and David’s Supporters

  • Rabbi Mansour begins with the aftermath of Achitophel’s suicide: Achitophel recognized that David would prevail and that joining Avshalom had been a mistake. He killed himself, as previously explained, to keep the king from taking his estate and to leave an inheritance for his children.
  • David reached Machanaim as Avshalom crossed the Jordan with his men in pursuit. Avshalom appointed Amasa as commander in place of Yoav ben Tzeruyah.
  • Amasa’s father was Yitra haYisre'eli, and his mother was Abigail, daughter of Nachash. The rabbis identify Nachash as Yishai, David’s father. The Gemara calls Yishai Nachash because he died through the death brought about by the serpent: Yishai himself had not sinned, and would not have died had God not decreed death in Gan Eden after Adam listened to the serpent.
  • The Gaon miVilna explains that returning to the earth is not a curse but a reality—and, in a sense, a blessing. A physical person cannot see God; returning to the dust removes the physical side and prepares a person to see the Shekhinah. Eliyahu HaNavi, who was entirely spiritual, did not need burial and went up to the heavens.
  • The Mefarshim ask why Yishai, who had not sinned, still needed burial. One commentator offers the chiddush that Eliyahu HaNavi never sinned, either intentionally or unintentionally, and therefore transformed the physical into the spiritual. Yishai did not sin intentionally, but did sin unintentionally; the Gemara’s phrase that certain people died belo avon means without intentional sin, since avon refers to intentional sin. Thus Yishai was not on Eliyahu’s level.
  • Yishai’s sister was Tzeruyah, the mother of Yoav. Abigail and Tzeruyah were sisters, making Amasa and Yoav cousins. Rabbi Mansour notes that Tzeruyah was Yoav’s mother, not his father.
  • The Mefarshim say Yoav’s father was not considered respectable enough for Yoav to be identified by him, while Amasa’s father was respectable. Avshalom’s choice of Amasa was also tit for tat: David had Yoav as his general, so Avshalom chose someone from the same family. Rabbi Mansour refers listeners to Rashi, who connects Nachash with the serpent’s counsel.
  • Avshalom and his army camped in Gilad. David began receiving help from outside leaders: Shobi ben Nachash, Machir ben Amiel miLo-Devar, and Barzilai haGiladi from Rogelim. Shobi was the son of Hanun ben Nachash, king of the Ammonites.
  • These supporters brought David and his people practical supplies as well as moral support: beds and mats, basins, earthenware utensils, wheat, barley, flour, toasted grain, beans, lentils, honey, butter, sheep, and cheese made from milk. They understood that David’s people in the wilderness would be hungry, tired, and thirsty.

David Organizes for Battle

  • As Perek 18 begins, David counted the people with him. The rabbis ask how this was permissible, since counting Jews is considered a bad omen and previous national censuses had preceded defeat.
  • Re'em answers that the prohibition applies when counting the entire nation. David was counting only a selected portion of the people for this battle, not taking a census of all Israel.
  • David appointed officers over thousands and hundreds, organized the army into divisions, and divided it into three parts. One third was placed under Yoav.
  • The Rambam writes that appointments in Israel, including commanders and officers over even fifty people, must be given to Jews. Since Itai HaGiti was not Jewish, the Mefarshim ask how David could appoint him.
  • Da'at Zekenim miBa'alei haTosafot answers that a non-Jew may be appointed when no suitable Jew is available. If qualified Jews have already been chosen and no other Jew is capable, the leader may choose a non-Jew; apparently, no one was as qualified as Itai HaGiti. Rabbi Mansour emphasizes that David observed halakha, so the Chachamim examined his actions and explained how they accorded with Torah.
  • David intended to go to battle with his men, as kings did, but they urged him to remain in the city. They reasoned that Avshalom’s aim was David himself: if David stayed behind, the soldiers could retreat without being pursued. If David accompanied them, Avshalom would pursue the whole army to capture him. Since David was worth ten thousand of them, they argued that even losing half their number would be preferable to having him with them and risking still greater losses.
  • They asked David to support them from the city. The Targum explains this as praying for them; they believed his prayers, including Tehillim, could help them in battle. The Malbim explains that David would remain behind to study Torah.
  • Rabbi Mansour connects this to the Gemara’s teaching that Israel’s victories were in the merit of the yeshivas in Jerusalem: soldiers fought, while those studying Torah supported them through their learning. The Torah does not deny the need for soldiers, but here the people believed David could help them more through prayer or Torah study than by fighting.
  • David accepted their advice, saying he would do what seemed good to them. He stood by the gate as the people went out by hundreds and thousands.

David’s Order and the Forest of Ephraim

  • David instructed Yoav, Avishai, and Itai HaGiti to deal gently with Avshalom. Rashi explains that if Avshalom appeared in battle, they were to have pity on him and not kill him. Rabbi Mansour highlights the father’s mercy, despite Avshalom’s rebellion and his treatment of David’s concubines.
  • Rabbi Mansour asks how David could spare a mored b'malchut, a rebel against the king, when Avshalom was plainly rebelling. The Rambam answers in Hilchot Melachim that only the king may kill a rebel against the king. David therefore had authority to choose not to enforce that punishment. Rabbi Mansour notes the precedent of Shimei ben Gera, whom David had previously ordered to be left alone while Shimei was stoning him. David also understood the rebellion as punishment from God for his role in the Bathsheba scandal.
  • Although David gave the order to the officers, the rest of the people heard it as well.
  • The battle took place in the forest of Ephraim. The commentators ask how there could be a forest of Ephraim east of the Jordan, since that land belonged to Reuven, Gad, and half the tribe of Menashe.
  • Rashi explains that Yehoshua had stipulated that any tribe could graze its cattle in any forest. Ephraim, though separated from the forest by the Jordan, was the closest tribe in Israel to it and used it, so the forest was called Ya'ar Efraim.

Avshalom Is Caught in the Tree

  • David’s forces defeated Avshalom’s army in a great slaughter; 20,000 men died. As Avshalom’s men fled through the forest, wild animals killed more people than the sword.
  • Avshalom chanced upon David’s servants while riding a mule. Rashi explains that vayikarei means the encounter happened by chance. His long hair—he was a nazir—caught in the branches of a great terebinth. He was left hanging between heaven and earth when the mule rode out from beneath him.
  • Rashi cites the rabbis’ account that Avshalom drew his sword to cut his hair, but saw the fires of Gehinnom below him and feared he would fall into them if he cut himself free.
  • The Gemara in Sotah discusses this, and the Ben Ish Chai, in Ben Yehoyada, asks how the Gemara knew Gehinnom was beneath him, since the Pasuk does not mention it. Citing the Zohar’s teaching of seven places of Gehinnom, including Tita HaYaven, he notes that the Pasuk’s statement that Avshalom hung between heaven and earth seems unnecessary. The difference in numerical value between Hashamayim and Ha'aretz is 99, the same as Tita HaYaven.
  • The Gemara says, “Avshalom b'se'aro marad”—Avshalom rebelled through his hair. A nazir’s hair expresses a lack of concern for physical appearance, but Avshalom treated his hair as important and weighed it when he cut it. The Gemara’s measure-for-measure explanation is that his arrogance was tied to his hair, and he was punished through his hair.

Yoav and the Death of Avshalom

  • A man saw Avshalom hanging and reported it to Yoav. Yoav asked why he had not struck Avshalom to the ground, and said he would have given the man ten pieces of silver and a belt.
  • The man replied that even a thousand silver pieces would not make him kill the king’s son. David had ordered the generals not to harm Avshalom. The man added that he could not conceal such an act from the king, and that Yoav himself might later deny having instructed him to do it.
  • Yoav stopped pressing him and asked only where Avshalom was. The man eventually showed him the place.
  • Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer praises the man’s uprightness. The Mefarshim ask why he deserves special credit for obeying the king’s order. They explain that David had directed the order to the generals, so the man could have argued that it did not apply to him; Yoav was asserting that he should have killed Avshalom. The man understood David’s true wish to protect his son and stood by it, even when challenged by the general. That, rather than mere obedience, showed his yashrut and temimut.
  • Yoav took three spears and thrust them into Avshalom’s heart while he was still alive. The Mefarshim explain that Yoav considered Avshalom a rodef: while Avshalom lived, his army would continue fighting and endanger Israel. Killing him would break their morale and end the threat. Yoav therefore held that the danger posed by Avshalom overrode the king’s command.
  • The man who refused to kill Avshalom may have held the view that when a pursuer can be stopped by merely wounding him, he may not be killed. Yoav, as the person being pursued, held that he could kill Avshalom to save himself and the people, even contrary to the king’s order.
  • The Gemara explains the three spears measure for measure: Avshalom had stolen the hearts of three—his father, the court, and Israel. He had deceived David, beit din, and the people, including through his claims at the gate that David could not judge fairly. Rabbi Mansour stresses that suffering is measured precisely, though without a prophet people cannot know why a particular measure was decreed.
  • Ten young men carrying Yoav’s weapons then struck Avshalom and killed him. The Gemara explains that this was measure for measure for Avshalom’s having slept with his father’s ten pilegshim.
  • Yoav sounded the shofar to signal victory and stopped the people from pursuing the defeated army.
  • The Gemara says Avshalom’s head and body were separated, but a miracle brought his head to the ditch where his body was placed. Because they considered him a rebel against the king, they did not bury him in an ordinary cemetery; they threw him into a large ditch in the forest and piled stones over it. The people, frightened by what had happened, returned to their tents.

Avshalom’s Fate and Monument

  • In Sanhedrin, kuf-gimmel, Rabbi Meir says that Avshalom has no share in Olam Haba, based on the Pasuk saying that he was struck and killed. Rabbi Mansour explains that Avshalom died suddenly, without time to do teshuvah. Though he had been hanging over Gehinnom, the account does not say that he repented before he was killed. Rabbi Mansour notes that in the next lesson they will learn of David’s prayer for his son, which may have been a prayer to release him from Gehinnom; at this point, the Gemara’s statement is that he has no share in the next world.
  • During his lifetime, Avshalom built a monument for himself in Emek HaMelech, saying that he had no son to memorialize him. He called it Yad Avshalom. Rabbi Mansour says it can still be visited near Yerushalayim and Ir David.
  • Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz, the Mir Rosh Yeshiva, used to visit Yad Avshalom during the Aseret Yemei Teshuvah. Although it is not considered a holy site, he prayed there by recalling Avshalom’s rebellion, the suffering he caused David, and David’s mercy toward his son. He then asked God to have compassion on His children, who had rebelled and sinned, just as David had compassion on Avshalom. Rav Chaim considered the site a place that could me'orer rachamei shamayim.
  • The Gemara’s question, “Ve'Avshalom lakach”—what did Avshalom take?—is answered, “Mikach ra lakach le'atzmo”: he made a bad bargain for himself. Rabbi Mansour compares this to the Gemara’s description of Korach in “Vayikach Korach.” Avshalom’s monument was the beginning of his pursuit of power and rebellion; although he sought to memorialize himself, he ended in a failed, non-heroic death.
  • Radak says that after Avshalom was first buried in the ditch, his body was later exhumed once the bones had decayed and the bones were buried elsewhere. He had initially been denied an ordinary burial because he was a mored b'malchut.

The News for David

  • The remaining question is who will tell David that Avshalom has died, since David is not expecting the news and there is a rule against being the bearer of bad news.
  • Rabbi Mansour leaves the account at this point, noting that the coming lessons will discuss how the message is carefully relayed, who delivers it, David’s reaction, and his prayer for Avshalom.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem