Beruchim Habaim, Rabotai, my teachers. Shavua Tov, and Beracha (blessing). We continue our study of the Nevi'im, the Prophets. We find ourselves in Sefer Shmuel Bet, Perek (chapter) Yud Zayin, and tonight we're going to begin from Pasuk (verse) Kaf-Dalet. In our last class, we ended by learning about the suicide of Achitophel. Achitophel realized that David was going to win, that his alignment with Avshalom was a mistake, and that he was going to be punished by David for his rebellion. Therefore, he chose to commit suicide, as we explained, to protect his estate, so that the king would not be able to take all his possessions and he could leave some inheritance to his children.
But the war obviously is not over. Avshalom is still alive. The Pasuk writes in Kaf-Dalet that David came to a place called Machanaim, and Avshalom was on the warpath. Avshalom had already crossed the Jordan River, he and all his men in hot pursuit of David. “Ve'et Amasa sam Avshalom tachat Yoav al hatzava,” Avshalom appointed Amasa over the army in place of Yoav. Yoav ben Tzeruyah was David HaMelech's general. Who was Avshalom's general? The Pasuk says it was Amasa. Who was Amasa? The Pasuk tells us, “Ve'Amasa ben ish, Ushmo Yitra haYisre'eli.” Amasa's father was called Yitra haYisre'eli, who was the husband of Abigail, who was Abigail bat Nachash, the daughter of Nachash. Who was Nachash? The rabbis tell us Nachash was actually Yishai. David HaMelech's father was called Nachash. Why? The Gemara says he died by the death of the snake. Yishai never sinned. Why did he die, then, if he never sinned? He only died because God said to Adam and Eshon after he listened to the snake and ate from the tree. He said that were it not for the curse God gave in Gan Eden, Yishai would never have died. Therefore, they call him Nachash to remind us that he died without sin.
It should be pointed out that the Gaon miVilna writes that the statement that God said man must return to the earth because that's where he came from is not a curse. Even though we understand it to be a curse, he says it's a reality. Since we are human beings made up of physical material, it is impossible for a human being made up of physical material to see God. It doesn't work; it's a clash. The physical cannot visualize the spiritual. Therefore, it's a blessing to us that we will go back to where we came from, decompose, shed our physical side, our materialistic side, and then be prepared to see the Shekhinah (Divine Presence). So it's actually a blessing. Those are the facts: because you're afar (dust), you must go back and rid yourself of the afar in order to prepare yourself to see the Shekhinah.
That's why he says, for example, that Eliyahu HaNavi, who was all spiritual, wasn't buried. Eliyahu HaNavi just disappeared. He flew up to the Shamayim, the heavens, and that was his end. Why? Because certain human beings were on such a level that they had no physicality. Therefore, they didn't need to go into the afar. He says that if it was a curse, Eliyahu HaNavi would also have to go down. But it's not a curse.
So the Mefarshim (commentators) ask: Why did Yishai have to be buried? Yishai must have been one of those people who had no physical side, after all; he never sinned. I saw one of the Mefarshim—he wants to explain, and it's a chiddush (novel insight)—that Eliyahu HaNavi never sinned at all, not meizid, intentionally, and not shogeg, unintentionally. Therefore, he transformed his physical into spiritual. Yishai, on the other hand, while he did not sin intentionally, intentionally he did sin. They want to prove it from a—from a—the Torah says in—it says there's nobody, even the greatest, who will not make a—what do you mean?—an unintentional sin. There's nobody who's free from unintentional sin. Even Yishai committed unintentional sins. When the Gemara says that four people died belo avon, without sin, that's the language of the Gemara. They died without avon, sin. Avon is intentional. Therefore, Yishai was not on the level of Eliyahu HaNavi, and therefore he needed to be buried.
For our purposes, Amasa's father is Yitra. His mother is Abigail. Abigail is the daughter of Yishai, bat Nachash (daughter of Nachash). Achot Tzeruyah (sister of Tzeruyah). Yishai had a sister. Yishai's sister was Tzeruyah. Who was Tzeruyah? Em Yoav, mother of Yoav. Yoav ben Tzeruyah. Most people make the mistake of thinking Tzeruyah was Yoav's father. It's the famous trivia question they ask the kids for a million dollars: Tell me who Yoav ben Tzeruyah's mother was. And it's obviously a true question because Tzeruyah was Yoav's mother—Yoav ben Tzeruyah. So you have Tzeruyah and Yishai, brother and sister. They had children. Yishai had Amasat, or Yishai's daughter is Abigail. Abigail had Amasa, and Tzeruyah, his other sister, had Yoav, so they were cousins.
The Mefarshim say that it seems Yoav's father was not a respectable man. It doesn't tell us exactly what he did, but he wasn't respectable enough that we don't even refer to Yoav by his father. Here the Pasuk goes out of its way and says he was the son of his father, meaning his father was a respectable, good man. Therefore, Avshalom over here is playing tit for tat: your Yoav is David's general, so he picks someone from the same family, Amasa, to be his general. Again, you can read this all in Rashi, by the way. But Nachash—Rashi says it was because of the serpent's counsel.
Avshalom and the Jewish people camped in the Gilad region. When David came to—that's where he was—he met the son of Nachash there, meRabbat Bnei Amon, from Rabbah of the Ammonites, from the people of Amon. He was a goy (non-Jew). David HaMelech started to get some support. Now the pendulum had started to swing in David's favor. While in the last chapter nobody was going out to help David and David was alone, now we see he's starting to receive some support from foreign leaders: Machir ben Amiel miLo-Devar, and Barzilai haGiladi, Barzilai from Gilad, meRogelim.
The Pasuk just tells us who these people are. It says, Shobi ben Nachash, “who Hanun ben Nachash I was the son of the king.” What did they bring David? Not only did they lend him moral support, but they brought him physical support. It says they gave him mishkav (beds), mats in order for him to rest on support, basins, clean themselves, ukhli yotzer, earthenware utensils to eat from; chittim, wheat; se'orim (barley), kemach, flour, and kali, toasted grain; u'pol, ful is like ful beans; adashim, lentils; vekali, and toasted lentils; u'dvash, honey; chemah, butter; and tzon, sheep, and cow's cheese—the way that she explains it, she says cheese, cheese made from milk. They brought it to David because they surmised the people must be hungry, tired, and thirsty in the Midbar, the wilderness.
That ends Perek Yud Zayin. And now we begin to learn how David HaMelech and his armies are going to overtake Avshalom and his armies, the most dramatic chapter in all of Nevi'im. “Vayifkod David et ha'am asher ito”—David counted the people who were with him.
The first problem we're faced with: David counted the people who were with him. The rabbis ask, “I thought you're not allowed to count Jews.” They say that when you count Jews, God forbid, it brings trouble, and we've seen in the Nevi'im that when the Jews were counted by number, they lost. And over here David counts the people, and they're going to win. So Re'em says that this rule that counting Jews is a bad omen applies only when you're counting all the Jews, when you're taking a census of the entire nation. Over here David wasn't going to use all the nation to fight against Avshalom. He was only taking a select group of the nation. Therefore, he counted part of the nation; therefore, it wasn't a transgression against Yisrael. So he pointed over the people.
Sarei Alafim are officers to lead a thousand. Sarei Me'ot are officers to lead a hundred. He started to organize the army and appoint its management. He split them into divisions. David sent them forth. He split them into three parts. A third of the people he sent under Yoav's hand. He was the general of a third of the army. He's Yoav's brother.
The question is raised: We have no problem with David's choice of Yoav, and we have no problem with David's choice of Avishai, since they were both Jews. But the Rambam writes that all positions in Israel—for example, sar tzava, the general of the army, and sar hamishim, even the manager of 50 people among the Jewish people—“lo yihyeh ela miYisrael,” they can only be appointees who are Jewish. Itai HaGiti wasn't Jewish. How then can David appoint a non-Jew to such a position?
The way they answer it is from the Da'at Zekenim miBa'alei haTosafot: that's only when there's somebody suitable who's Jewish. Then you can't appoint a goy. But if he's the best you have, if you chose the best Jews and you still need another guy to lead the people, and there's nobody among the Jews who's qualified, capable, and talented, then you can even start pulling from the goyim. It seems that nobody was qualified like Itai HaGiti, and therefore it was permissible for David to take him. You see, all these fine technicalities must be addressed because David was much more religious than all of us, and he kept the halakha, Jewish law, and every move he made had to have biblical approval. Otherwise, David doesn't do it. So the Chachamim (Sages) always looked at David and measured everything he did in the light of the Torah. They had to find a way to explain that his actions were correct.
So David tells the people—David says he's coming, he's going to fight with them, as Jewish law tells us. Jewish kings used to fight, leading the people into war. The people didn't like that idea. They tell David, “Stay home, don't come with us. It's not advantageous.” They say that if they flee from Avshalom's armies, the armies will pay no attention to them. You see, if we feel that we're being outnumbered, we should run away. Avshalom doesn't want to kill us. He just wants to kill you. So when he finds out that you're not with us, he'll just leave us alone. But if he knows that you're with us, he'll pursue us, and you're endangering us. So you're giving us a way out here.
Now, if Avshalom is more powerful than we are, he's not going to fight us, because he's only going after you anyway. So don't put us in harm's way. And even if he kills half of us, they will pay no attention to us, because you're worth 10,000 of us. Which means that if you don't come, even if he kills half of us, it won't be as many as he'll kill if you're with us. If you're with us, he'll kill many more because they'll have an incentive to catch you. So stay home and help us from the city.
How could David help the Jewish people from the city? But, as the Targum says in its interpretation, it'll be better—pray for us, pray for us from the city, in order to help us. They really believed in this. They believed that David could be more useful by reading Tehillim, Psalms, probably the ones he wrote, or by praying—whatever he's going to pray—that would help the Jewish people in war.
The Malbim writes that he used them to stay back. That means he's going to stay back to learn Torah. The Gemara says that our feet were standing in war; we were winning wars. The Gemara says, in what zechut, merit, did the Jewish people have that they were able to win wars? It was the yeshivas in Jerusalem, because the yeshiva men were sitting back in the yeshivas and studying. While today they're called, you know, trying to run away from the army, they're called lazy, they're called trying to flee from their responsibility. Our Torah looks a little differently. Certainly you need soldiers, certainly you need an army. They don't say no. But the Torah is coming to tell you over here: David was a great warrior. It figured to be a big asset for David to help them fight the war. They held no, his prayers would do them much better. It was the—that gave us, “Stay home. You'll do better for us over there.”
Pasuk Daled. “Vayomer alehem hamelech, asher yitav be'einechem e'eseh”—the king said, “Whatever seems good in your eyes, I will do.” As you see, that means if you want me to stay home, I'll stay home. David HaMelech is anav, humble; he takes the advice of the people. “Vaya'amod hamelech al yad hasha'ar”—the king stood by the gate—“ve'chol ha'am yatzu leme'ot vele'alafim”—and all the people went out by hundreds and thousands. So it wasn't such a small army over here: by the hundreds and by the thousands.
He gives a royal command to his three generals: Be gentle to the young man. Don't kill my son. Rashi says that if he presents himself in front of you at the time of the war, have pity on him. He's requesting, “Don't kill him.” You see over here what it means, the mercy that a father has for a son. After all, what did he do? He raped his pilegshim, his concubines. He waged a mutiny against his father. And here David is saying, “If you see him, leave him alone. Have mercy.”
The question is, how is David allowed to do that? Isn't he a mored b'malchut, rebel against the king? Mored b'malchut, hayabshalom. If there's anybody who was ever rebellious against the king, it's Avshalom. Halakha says, mored b'malchut, hayabshalom. How could David subvert justice and say, “Leave him alone”?
So the Rambam answers this question in his Hilchot Melachim. The Rambam writes that “mored b'malchut, rak hamelech yachol lehorgo”—only the king can kill him. Therefore, if the king decides to let him go, like we saw a precedent when Shimei ben Gera was stoning David, David held at that point, “Leave him alone.” It's the king's decision whether he wants to enforce his power to kill or not. Here also, he understands this was a curse of God, a punishment for his role in the Bathsheba scandal, and therefore he accepted it, and therefore he says, “Have mercy on him.”
Very significant. All the people heard the king's order. The order technically was only to the officers. However, everybody else was also there, and they heard David the king's wish to the Jewish people. The people went out to the field against the army of Israel. The war took place at the forest of Ephraim. It's a technical point, but the rabbis are all struggling to understand where in the world Ephraim got a forest. This war is being fought on the other side of the Jordan. Ephraim didn't live on the other side of the Jordan River. The tribes of Reuven, the tribes of Gad, and half the tribe of Menashe lived on that side. That's where this was being fought. How is it possible to have Ya'ar Efraim? Ya'ar Reuven, I understand; Ya'ar Gad, Ya'ar Menashe, but Ya'ar Efraim on the other side of the Jordan?
So let's look at Rashi. Rashi asks, “U'me'ayin hayah ya'ar le'Efraim be'ever haYarden mizrachah, shelo nitna sham chelek ela livnei Gad, ulivnei Reuven, ul'chatzi shevet Menashe?”—“And from where was there a forest of Ephraim east of the Jordan, when no portion there was given except to the tribes of Gad, Reuven, and half the tribe of Menashe?” Exactly the question. “Ela mitoch shehitnah Yehoshua ... sheyehu merain ba'choreshin”—rather, because Yehoshua made a condition that they could graze in the forests. Yehoshua partitioned Israel with the following condition: any tribe can have its cattle graze in any forest it wishes. The forests are considered open property for everybody. That was the condition Yehoshua laid down. The closest tribe in Israel to that forest was Ephraim, except they had the Jordan separating it. So the people of Ephraim would cross the Jordan and graze their animals there. So it was called that because they had the easiest access to it out of all the tribes, and they used it. Okay, now you know; you learned something.
The Israel army was defeated terribly by the servants of David. It was a slaughter, a great slaughter on that day. 20,000 men died. The war spread all over the land. You see what happened? They started to run away. The people of Avshalom realized they were doomed, so they started to flee throughout the forest. And that was a mistake they made, because the Pasuk tells us the wild beasts of the forest killed more people than the sword devoured that day. You have to remember they're fighting in a forest. There are animals there, wild animals. So when Avshalom's men started to run away, there was nowhere for them to run. They became prey to all the wild animals. More people that day died as a result of being devoured and killed by wild animals than by the war itself.
Pasuk Tet, verse nine, says, “Vayikarei Avshalom lifnei avdei David”—Avshalom chanced to meet the servants of David. Avshalom now met, or chanced to meet, the servants of David. Rashi says, “Vayikarei lashon mikreh”—the word vayikarei means by chance. It wasn't planned. Maybe Avshalom was running away, but it happened that they met by coincidence. There's no coincidence. Avshalom was riding on a mule. The mule passed under a tree, under some branches, ha'elah hagedolah, the great terebinth, and “vayyechezak rosho ba'elah”—his head got caught in the tree. You have to remember Avshalom's hair was very long. Avshalom was a nazir, one who took a Nazirite vow. As he was riding, his hair got caught in the tree. “Vayitan bein hashamayim u'vein ha'aretz”—he was suspended between heaven and earth, between the sky and the earth. “Vayipared asher tachtav”—the mule went out from under him, and the mule rode away. So now Avshalom is suspended in mid-air.
Rashi tells us, “Amru rabboteinu, shalaf charbo liktzot se'aro”—our rabbis said he drew his sword to cut his hair. He took out his sword in order to cut his hair, even though he was a nazir. But he said, “This is—if I don't escape from this, they're going to kill me.” So he took out his sword in order to cut his hair. But he saw already the fires of Gehinnom were underneath him. He knew that if he cut his hair, he'd fall right into the depths of Gehinnom. So he was caught, dangling on the tree.
The Gemara says this in Sotah—actually, there's an interesting Ben Ish Chai. This also comes from the Gemara Sotah. The Ben Ish Chai says, how did the Gemara know that Gehinnom was underneath him? It doesn't say anywhere in the Pasuk that there was Gehinnom. It just says he was suspended. So the Ben Ish Chai writes in his Ben Yehoyada, from the Zohar, that there are seven different Gehinnom, seven places of Gehinnom. One place is called Tita HaYaven. Now, he says, if you look at the Pasuk, obviously, if his hair got caught on the tree, isn't it obvious that he was suspended between the sky and the earth? Why does the Torah have to tell us “Vayitan bein hashamayim”? It's obvious. So the Ben Ish Chai says like this: the difference between the numerical values of the word Hashamayim and Ha'aretz—the difference in numerical value between Shamayim and Hashamayim and Ha'aretz—is 99, the same numerical value as Tita HaYaven, the name of that Gehinnom.
The Gemara says, “Tanu Rabbanan, Avshalom b'se'aro marad”—the Sages taught: Avshalom rebelled through his hair. A nazir usually vows not to cut his hair in order not to give credence and importance to his physicality. He doesn't care about his physicality; it's not important to him. Avshalom was a nazir, but he didn't—he didn't learn the message of a nazir. You remember, we said he used to cut his hair when it became very weighty, but according to the halakha, it's permissible. And he used to weigh it, and it used to be very chashuv, very important. He had a little ga'avah, arrogance, or a lot of ga'avah from his hair, Avshalom. So God says, measure for measure: your sin of arrogance came from your hair, and therefore you got punished by your hair.
So now he's dangling on the tree. “Vayar ish echad”—one man saw him. So there was one fellow who saw this. “Vayaged leYoav,” and he goes to tell it to Yoav. He tells Yoav what's happening. And he said, “Hineh ra'iti et Avshalom talui ba'elah”—I saw Avshalom hanging in the tree. Yoav said to the man who told him, “Ve'hineh ra'ita,” so I don't understand: you saw him, “u'madua lo hikito artzah?”—why didn't you strike him to the ground? Why didn't you kill him? Don't you know this war is against Avshalom? Kill him! “Ve'alay latet lecha asarah chesef”—I would have given you ten pieces of silver—“va'agorah achat”—and one belt. Not so bad.
“Vayomer ha'ish el Yoav.” So the man tells Yoav, “Ve'lu anochi shokel al kapay elef chesef”—even if I were to weigh a thousand silver pieces on my hands. Even if you'd be willing to give me a thousand silver coins, I'm not going to kill the king's son. We heard him with our own ears. He commanded you three generals to learn, and he said nobody harms him. We have to understand exactly. We read one more Pasuk. “O asiti,” and even if I would kill him and cover it up, “b'nafshi sheker”—I would be acting falsely against my own life—and I would try to lie to make it seem as if I didn't know anything about it. “Ve'chol davar lo yikkached min hamelech”—nothing will be concealed from the king. At the end of the day, nothing remains concealed from the king. Even if we want to kill him and say we don't know what happened, cover up and conceal the murder, at the end of the day the king somehow always ends up finding out. There are too many loyalists to the king who will go to the king and tell him exactly what happened. So that's not an option. And not only that, Yoav, you yourself will distance yourself from me. Now you're telling me, “Yeah, go, kill him.” And then after I kill him, Yoav's going to say, “I didn't know anything about it. I didn't talk to him. I never saw this guy.”
So Yoav says, “Finished, I'm not going to ask you any further. I'm not going to bother you about this.” Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer writes, look how straight and upright this fellow was. He tells Yoav, “If you give me a thousand coins, I'm not going to do it.” So Yoav says, “Just show me where he's hanging. Forget about it. I'm not going to bother you. Just tell me where he's hanging.” So, no, nothing doing. He started to bout him. He started to beg him, which means he ended up showing him. He took him by the arm to the spot. He showed him where it was. He took him.
So the Mefarshim want to understand: where do you see the yashrut, uprightness, over here? Oh, what a tzaddik, righteous person, what an upright citizen! The king said, “Don't kill him.” He's only following the king's orders. It doesn't mean he's an upright citizen if he's doing what he's supposed to do. So how can we give this ish over here so much credit for doing something he probably was expected to do?
So the explanation is: whom did David command not to kill Avshalom? The generals. Other people happened to be there listening, but the command came to the generals. The reason, they thought, might be that when a general kills somebody, it's respectful; it's a kavod, honor, to be killed by a general. But if a common man kills Avshalom, he dies an unknowable death. Therefore, according to the strict order, this ish had a right, and that's what Yoav was saying: “You should have killed him.” David didn't command you. The reason the Midrash calls him straight and upright is that even though he had a legal way out, he knew David's will. David's will was to protect the na'ar, young man. So even though technically, according to the law, he might have been able to get around it, since he knew that David's will really was that he wanted to have Avshalom alive, he even challenged Yoav, which is not an easy thing to do when the general tells you to do something. That shows us the yashrut and the temimut, sincerity, of this fellow.
Torah, Nevi'im continues. Pasuk Yud-Dalet. “Vayikach shloshet shevatim b'chapo”—he took three rods in his hand. He took three spears in his hand. “Vayitka'em belev Avshalom”—he thrust them into Avshalom's heart—“odenu chai”—while he was still alive. So Yoav ends up killing Avshalom. How does he do that? Didn't the king tell him clearly, “Keep him alive”?
Yoav is also a big rabbi. Yoav also is a religious man. He also is interested in halakha. The king says no. So the Mefarshim explain that Yoav held Avshalom was a rodef, somebody who's out to kill you. Yoav held that as long as Avshalom is alive, his army is still going to fight, and Avshalom's life is threatening the lives of the Jewish people. Once Avshalom dies, the people will see that he's dead, their morale will break, and they'll run away. But as long as Avshalom is alive, it's a problem. So therefore, he held that according to halakha, somebody else might not be allowed to kill Avshalom, but since Avshalom is a rodef, and certainly he's going to come against Yoav, the general, it even overrides the will of the king, and therefore he held he was able to kill him.
The boy who didn't want to kill must have held like the opinions that say if somebody's coming to kill you and you're able to just maim him without killing him, you can't kill him. He held that maybe that's somebody else, but the one being pursued, which Yoav was, you can kill him any way you want. So therefore, Yoav held that being a real rodef overrides even the tzivui, command, of the Melech (king). The tzivui of the Melech is so long as it's not dangerous for you, but if it's dangerous for you, of course, that's what he held.
Why three spears? The Gemara says the reason was that he stole the hearts of three people: lev aviv, his father's heart; lev beit din, the court's heart; and lev Yisrael, the heart of Israel. He tricked his father, he tricked beit din, the court, who was with him, and of course he tricked the Jewish people. As we learned, if you remember, in one of our last sessions, we learned how Avshalom would stand by the gate like a politician and tell them, “Don't go there to my father. He's too old to give proper judgment. He doesn't know the halakha. He's biased toward his tribe. If I were the king, I would be fair and objective.” So he fooled David, he fooled the people, he fooled beit din. Therefore, he stole three hearts. Therefore, he got speared three times in his heart. You see, the judgment of the Borei Olam (Creator of the world) is so meticulous. It's so midah keneged midah, measure for measure. There's no mistakes, Rabotai. You have to appreciate this. Not only when it comes to Avshalom, but anytime we see tragedy, know that nothing happens without a midah keneged midah. There's a reason why, through every part of the suffering, it was this way as opposed to that way, and this much as opposed to less. Everything is calculated and measured. We just don't have a prophet to tell us what's the measure for measuring, or what we did to deserve this as opposed to that. This is not the exception. This is the rule.
Then ten young men came who carried Yoav's weapons, and they struck Avshalom and killed him. The Gemara explains that the reason he was killed by ten men is measure for measure, because he slept with the ten pilegshim of his father. So Yoav now blew the shofar (ram's horn) as a sign of victory, and the people stopped chasing the army of Israel. The war was over. Yoav restrained them. He said, “What do we have to kill people for now? The war is over. We killed Avshalom. It's over.”
The Gemara discusses how Avshalom was killed. When they decapitated him, his head flew to one area and his body to another area. So the Pasuk Zayin says they threw him into a big ditch in the forest, since they held that they could not bury him in the normal cemeteries, so they buried him in the middle of the forest. The Gemara says a miracle took place: his head came to his body. Even though the head was far away, it miraculously rolled to that ditch. So Avshalom was buried with a full body. They put a great heap of stones over the ditch, and all the Jewish people were petrified by what happened. They were scared, and they all ran to their tents. They ran to their homes.
Regarding Avshalom's afterlife, the Gemara Sanhedrin, kuf-gimmel, writes: “Tanya, Rabbi Meir omer, Avshalom ein lo chelek le'olam haba, shene'emar, vayaku et Avshalom ... vayemituhu ...”—it is taught: Rabbi Meir says, “Avshalom has no share in the World to Come, as it says, ‘They struck Avshalom ... and killed him ...’” The logic of Rabbi Meir's opinion is that Avshalom died a sudden death, when he wasn't able to make teshuvah, repentance. When he was on the tree, he was dangling over Gehinnom. It doesn't say that he repented, really. By the time that maybe he got around to repent, they were already killing him. They killed him. Now, of course, next week we'll learn how David HaMelech prays for his son. Maybe that was a prayer to get him out of Gehinnom. But at this point the Gemara is saying at least that we know he has no chelek, share, in the next world.
Torah tells us further. When Avshalom was alive, he had taken something. What did he take? He built for himself—he built for himself a monument during his lifetime in the King's Valley. He said, “I have no son who will memorialize my name.” So he called the monument after himself: the hand of Avshalom, or the place of Avshalom. To go to Jerusalem today, you can go to the Valley of the King, to Emek HaMelech, which is right outside the wall of Yerushalayim, Ir David, and you can go visit Yad Avshalom. That monument is still there today. It's an amazing thing. You can go see something from the times of the Nevi'im, something that Avshalom built with his own hands. This was to memorialize himself.
There's nothing bad about the place. As a matter of fact, Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz, zichrono livracha (of blessed memory), the Mir Rosh Yeshiva, used to go visit Yad Avshalom during the Aseret Yemei Teshuvah (Ten Days of Repentance). An amazing thing. They couldn't imagine: out of all the places to go pray in Israel, you have the Kotel HaMa'aravi, you have Kever David HaMelech, you have the Ma'arat HaMachpelah. Out of all the places to go make a tefillah, prayer, you go to Yad Avshalom. It's not considered a holy site. So the Mir Rosh Yeshiva said that he goes to that spot and says, “Borei Olam, look what Avshalom did. Look what he did to his father. Look at the troubles he caused. He built a monument in David's valley, which is a signal of his rebellious nature. He went with his pilegshim; he tried to kill his father. But what? David had mercy on him. Borei Olam, why did David have mercy? Because Avshalom is his son. God, where are your children? We have rebelled against you all year round. We have committed averot, transgressions. We have committed treason. If David, who was a mortal human being, can find it in his heart to have compassion on his son Avshalom, You, God, who are almighty and all-merciful and all-powerful, certainly can find it in Your heart to have compassion on us and forgive us for the treason we committed.” This is why he held Yad Avshalom to be a very important site. It's me'orer rachamei shamayim, it arouses heavenly compassion.
The Gemara says on this Pasuk, “Ve'Avshalom lakach.” The Gemara says, “What did he take?” “Mikach ra lakach le'atzmo”—he took a bad bargain for himself. He took for himself a bad proposition. He got involved in a bad deal. Same thing as they said about Korach, with “Vayikach Korach”—Korach took. He also got involved in a bad deal. The Pasuk says, “Avshalom lakach.” He says this was a mistake. This over here began the whole rebellion. By building this structure, this already put Avshalom on the path to eventually seek more power, and eventually building this memorial put Avshalom in the frame of mind to pursue the kingdom. And what ended up happening because of it? He thought he was going to be memorialized. He ended up dying a death, a non-heroic death, a death that was unsuccessful because of his plans against his father. That was the mikach, bargain, that he took. He says this was a mistake. It put him on the wrong path as he rebelled against his father.
The Pasuk—the Radak writes that after they buried him in the first ditch, it says they exhumed his body after the bones decayed, and then they buried him in a normal burial spot again. They buried him outside the place because he was a mored b'malchut, and then, when he had decayed, they took his bones and put them somewhere else.
What we're left with now, which is the last part of this saga, is this: Who's going to tell David now that Avshalom died? Obviously, David is not expecting to hear that news. And there's a whole law that says you're not to be the bearer of bad news. So now we're going to see in the coming weeks exactly how they decided, in a very skillful and very planned way, how to relay the message to David, who should be the messenger, and how they should say it to him. And then we're going to read of David's reaction, which is that he's going to take it very hard. And we read about the prayer that David the king is going to make for his son Avshalom. We'll hold over here.