A verse in the Book of
Hoshea (14:3) states, "U'neshalema Farim Sefatenu" – "We will compensate for
the cows with our lips." This means that
in the absence of the Bet Ha'mikdash, when we are unable to offer sacrifices
("cows"), we can attain atonement with our lips – by reciting the sections of
the Torah that discuss the sacrifices, as through this recitation we are
considered to have actually brought these sacrifices. The verse mentions cows, even though other
animals were also offered as sacrifices.
The Ibn Ezra (Spain, 1089-1167) suggests that since the cow is the
biggest animal offered as a Korban, the verse specifies this animal, expressing
the idea that even the large offerings can be substituted nowadays with our
mouths. Others suggest that the
reference to cows alludes to the sin of the golden calf, the grievous sin which
our ancestors committed that requires atonement. Finally, there are those who explain that
this refers to the situation where the entire nation inadvertently commits a
severe misdeed based on a mistaken ruling of the Sanhedrin, a situation which
requires the offering a cow for atonement ("Par He'alem Dabar Shel Sibur"). The point being made is that we have the
opportunity to attain atonement even for grave sins despite the absence of the
Bet Ha'mikdash, through the recitation of the sections of the Torah dealing
with the sacrifices.
A story told in
Masechet Shabbat (12b) seems, at first glance, to contradict this concept. The Gemara there discusses the enactment
legislated by the Sages that one may not read by candlelight on Shabbat, as he
might tilt the lamp to move the oil toward the flame to make it steadier, which
would constitute an act of Shabbat desecration.
Rabbi Yishmael Ben Elisha felt confident that he would certainly not
make the mistake of tilting the lamp, and so he read by the light of a candle
on Shabbat. He ended up mistakenly
tilting the lamp. After Shabbat, he
wrote in his ledger that when the Bet Ha'mikdash would be rebuilt, he would
bring an animal as a Hatat (sin-offering) to atone for this inadvertent
violation. It seems that Rabbi Yishmael
was not able to atone for this misdeed by reciting the section of the Hatat; he
needed to actually bring the sacrifice in order to attain atonement.
One explanation might
be that reading the section of Korbanot (sacrifices) is effective if one never
has the opportunity to actually offer the required sacrifice. But if a person has the privilege of living
to see the rebuilding of the Bet Ha'mikdash, then he must offer the sacrifice
even though he had recited the section in the Torah.
By contrast, the
Sapihit Bi'dbash (Rav Hiya Pontremoli, Turkey, 1764–1831), citing the Ma'abar
Yabok, asserted that a sin committed during the time of the Bet Ha'mikdash is
more grievous, and thus necessitates the actual offering of a sacrifice. After the Temple's destruction, sins lack the
same level of gravity, and so they can be atoned even with the recitation of
the Korbanot. However, this view appears
irreconcilable with the Gemara's account of Rabbi Yishmael, who was obligated
to bring a sacrifice for an offense committed after the Temple's destruction. Moreover, the Arizal writes that a person
must fulfill all 613 Misvot, and so souls will need to be reincarnated and
return after the Bet Ha'mikdash is rebuilt so they can fulfill the Misvot that
require a Bet Ha'mikdash. This teaching,
too, implies that reciting the Korbanot is not considered equivalent to the
actual offering of the sacrifices.
A more compelling
approach was advanced by the Petah Ha'debir (Rav Haim Binyamin Pontremoli, Turkey,
d. 1873), who distinguished between the atonement achieved through the offering
of a sacrifice, and the Misva to offer the sacrifice. Reciting the verses that speak of a required
sacrifice suffices to atone like that sacrifice, but it does not suffice to
satisfy the halachic requirement to bring that sacrifice after committing a
misdeed. Therefore, even though Rabbi
Yishmael could earn atonement through the recitation of Korbanot, he still bore
the obligation to offer a sacrifice when the Bet Ha'mikdash would be
rebuilt. Likewise, the Arizal taught
that one will have to return after the restoration of the Mikdash to fulfill
the Misvot of the sacrifices that could not be fulfilled without a Temple, even
though atonement can be achieved even in the absence of the Bet Ha'mikdash,
through the reading of Korbanot.
One might wonder,
then, why we do not read each day the entirety of Parashat Vayikra, which goes
through all the different sacrifices which an individual can bring and those which
one must bring on certain occasions. If
reading about a sacrifice earns a person atonement as though he actually
brought the sacrifice, then it would seemingly be recommended to read this
entire Parasha each day.
Some explain that one
attains atonement for his misdeeds through Torah study, and so it is not
necessary to read the sections of all the sacrifices every day. Rabbenu Yona (Spain, 1200-1263) writes that
when a person makes the decision to perform Teshuba (repentance), he should
increase his amount of Torah learning; if he had been accustomed to learning
one page a day, then he should learn two pages a day, and so on. This is because Torah study has the ability
to erase guilt for one's misdeeds. This
is why the blessing in Shemona Esreh in which we beseech G-d to help us repent
begins, "Hashibenu Abinu Le'Toratecha" – "Return us, our Father, to Your
Torah." As Torah learning is a crucial
element of repentance, we ask Hashem to draw us closer to Torah study so we can
repent properly. This concept has been
understood on the basis of the laws of "Kashering" utensils. The basic principle of "Kashering" is that a
non-kosher flavor is expunged from a utensil through the same medium through
which it was absorbed. Thus, utensils
that were used to cook non-kosher food through direct exposure to fire must be
directly exposed to fire to eliminate the forbidden taste so they may become
permissible. The Yeser Ha'ra (evil
inclination) leads us to sin through the "fire" of forbidden desires, and so we
cleanse ourselves from wrongdoing through Torah learning, which is likened to
fire. Therefore, some Rabbis explained
that it is preferable to immerse oneself in Torah learning to achieve
atonement, rather than spend time reading the sections of the Korbanot.
Rav Haim Palachi
(Turkey, 1788-1868) explained that reading all the sections of the Korbanot is
unnecessary because we recite the chapter of "Ezehu Mekoman," which goes
through all the various kinds of sacrifices, and this is sufficient for us to
be considered to have offered any sacrifice we are required to bring.
Another approach was
taken by the Hida (Rav Haim Yosef David Azulai, 1724-1806). We are required to recite 100 Berachot each
day, and we also recite each morning Baruch She'amar, which contains eleven
expressions that begin with the word "Baruch" (not including the two instances
of "Baruch" that begin and end the concluding blessing of Baruch She'amar). These 111 blessings, the Hida writes, correspond
to the 111 verses of Parashat Vayikra, and by reciting them we are considered
to have recited all of Parashat Vayikra.
This discussion
underscores for us the importance of reading the Korbanot section each
morning. As we have seen, this
recitation is not simply an admirable and worthwhile practice; it actually
provides us with atonement as though we brought the sacrifices in the Bet
Ha'mikdash. Therefore, one should make
every effort to arrive on time in the synagogue so he can recite this section
and reap the great benefits that it offers.