The Bet Yosef
(commentary to the Tur by Maran Rav Yosef Karo, author of the Shulhan Aruch)
cites Rav Yishak Abuhab (Spain, 1433-1493) as stating that when one recites the
list of the eleven spices of Ketoret, he must do so carefully, from a written
text, in order to ensure not to mistakenly omit any of the spices. As we say in the section from the Gemara
recited in the Ketoret section, "Im Hisar Ahat Mi'kol Samaneha Hayab Mita" –
leaving out even one of the eleven ingredients of the Ketoret constitutes a capital
offense, punishable by death. Since we
read the Ketoret section in lieu of the offering of the Ketoret in the Bet
Ha'mikdash, one who mistakenly skips one of the ingredients would be in
violation of this capital offense. The
Bet Yosef speculates that this might be the reason why Ashkenazic communities do
not recite the Ketoret section on weekday mornings – due to the concern that
one might recite this section quickly, given the pressures of the workweek, and
mistakenly omit one of the spices. Indeed,
the Rama (Rav Moshe Isserles, Poland, 1530-1572) explains on this basis the
Ashkenazic custom not to recite the Ketoret on weekdays.
The Bet Yosef comments
that if the Ashkenazim received a tradition to omit the Ketoret on weekdays,
then he certainly will not argue with their tradition, but if this is done only
due to the fear of skipping one of the spices, then this practice is not
acceptable. He explains that when the
Gemara speaks of the death penalty as the punishment for leaving out one of the
spices of the Ketoret, this refers to the Kohen Gadol offering a deficient
incense on Yom Kippur. The only time it
was ever permissible to enter the Kodesh Ha'kodashim – the inner sanctum of the
Bet Ha'mikdash – was when the Kohen Gadol went there to perform the special Yom
Kippur service, and this required the offering of Ketoret. If the Ketoret was deficient and thus
invalid, then the Kohen Gadol would be in violation of a capital offense when
he entered the Kodesh Ha'kodashim on Yom Kippur. It goes without saying that this has no
relevance at all to somebody who mistakenly omits one of the spices when
reciting the section of the Ketoret and listing its ingredients.
A different view is
held by the Rambam, who maintained that a Kohen incurs the death penalty for
offering a deficient Ketoret even on ordinary weekdays, and not only on Yom
Kippur. However, even according to the
Rambam, the punishment is incurred not for bringing a deficient Ketoret, but
rather for entering the Bet Ha'mikdash for naught, since the offering brought
was not valid. Clearly, this does not
apply to one who mistakenly skips one of the spices while reciting the Ketoret.
Moreover, even if one
insists that offering a deficient Ketoret itself constitutes a capital offense,
there is no basis for extending this to a person who omits one of the spices
during the recitation of this section.
Therefore, while of
course one should always try to ensure to recite all the words of the entire
prayer service properly, there is no reason to be especially "scared" when
listing the ingredients of the Ketoret.