Is one allowed to put on clothing before washing Netilat
Yadayim in the morning? Often, during
the winter, people want to put socks on their feet before stepping on the cold
floor and going to wash Netilat Yadayim.
Is this permissible, or must one be concerned that the impurity will
transfer from their hands onto their garments, thus causing harm?
The Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909), in
the work for which he was named (Ben Ish Hai, Parashat Toledot, 6), cites the
Arizal's teaching that one may not touch his clothing before washing his hands
in the morning. He therefore bemoaned
the common practice to put on socks before stepping on the cold floor in the
morning during the winter.
Hacham Ovadia Yosef, however, questions this ruling, noting
that there is no indication in the Gemara that the hands contaminate garments
or utensils before the morning hand-washing.
Indeed, one obviously touches the handles of the washing cup before
washing, and clearly there is no concern that the impurity will adversely
affect the cup. For that matter, one touches
his bedding before washing in the morning, and nowhere do we find any
requirement to wash one's bedding each day because it is contaminated.
Moreover, the Ben Ish Hai elsewhere – in Od Yosef Hai (Parashat
Toledot, 10) – seems to have retracted this position. There the Ben Ish Hai brings the Minhat
Aharon as ruling that one may not touch his garments before washing in the
morning, but he then observes that very few people observe this stringency. He suggests that the harmful forces on one's
hands do not affect garments, and so this is allowed – in direct
contradistinction to his comments in Ben Ish Hai.
Some proposed reconciling this contradiction by noting that
the Od Yosef Hai was published posthumously by disciples of the Ben Ish Hai,
and it is thus possible that they may have introduced their own opinions into
the text. If so, then the lenient ruling
in Od Yosef Hai does not represent the Ben Ish Hai's authentic position. Hacham Ovadia, however, vehemently dismisses
this claim, writing that he personally knew the Ben Ish Hai's disciple who
printed Od Yosef Hai – the great sage Rav Bension Hazan (1877-1951) – and he
could certainly be trusted to authentically present the actual words of the Ben
Ish Hai. Evidently, the Ben Ish Hai
retracted his stringent opinion, and concluded that one may, in fact, touch his
clothing before washing in the morning.
Nevertheless, the Kabbalists taught the importance of
keeping water beside one's bed so he can wash immediately upon waking, before
touching anything. (One must ensure to
keep the water next to the bed, and not underneath the bed, as food and water
situated beneath a bed while someone sleeps on it becomes impure.) Rav Yisrael Bitan writes that those who
follow this stringency are worthy of blessing, but this recommendation is only
for the especially pious. He adds that
there is certainly no need to be stringent if one goes to sleep after halachic
midnight, in light of the Kabbalistic teaching that the impurity descends upon
the hands only when one sleeps at the moment of halachic midnight.
Summary: It is permissible to touch one's clothing and even
to get dressed before washing Netilat Yadayim in the morning. The Kabbalists follow the custom to keep
water next to their bed so they can wash immediately in the morning, but this
practice is reserved for the especially pious.