Although it is
customary to refrain from eating meat during the Nine Days (from the 2nd
of Ab through Tisha B'Ab), Hacham Ovadia Yosef ruled that eating meat is
allowed for health purposes. For
example, if a physician advised a patient to eat meat for his health, or if a
patient is recovering from illness or from a procedure and he wishes to eat
meat to make him feel stronger, he may do so.
In fact, Hacham Ovadia ruled that since meat during the Nine Days is
forbidden by force of custom, and not according to the strict Halacha, there is
room to allow anyone who feels a medical need to eat meat to do so. However, Hacham Ovadia cautioned that a
healthy person who has no need for meat, but simply wants to eat some meat
during the Nine Days, must not do so, and violating this custom without a valid
reason constitutes a grievous sin.
Additionally, if a
patient's medical need can be met by eating fish, then this should be
preferred.
A pregnant woman who
experiences a craving for meat may – and, in fact, must – be given meat, as
failing to satisfy a craving for a particular food during pregnancy could
endanger the fetus. A woman within
thirty days after childbirth, and a woman who is nursing an infant, may eat
meat in order to maintain her strength. Hacham
Ovadia considered the possibility of allowing even a woman during menstruation
to eat meat if she feels the need, as she might be weakened by the loss of
blood, though he remained uncertain about this leniency.
One who eats meat
during the Nine Days for medical reasons does not require Hatarat Nedarim
(annulment of vows) before eating meat.
Normally, one who discontinues a custom must first perform Hatarat
Nedarim, but in this case, since the custom allows eating meat for health
purposes, the patient does not break the "vow" by eating meat. However, a patient with a chronic condition
that will always require him to eat meat during the Nine Days, who thus needs
to permanently discontinue the practice of refraining from meat, should perform
Hatarat Nedarim.
Is it permissible to
feed meat to children during the Nine Days?
When it comes to
non-kosher food, there is a debate among the Rishonim as to whether one may
feed children food that is forbidden Mi'de'rabbanan – by force of Rabbinic
enactment. All agree that one may not feed
a child food that the Torah itself forbids, but the Rashba (Rav Shlomo Ben
Aderet of Barcelona, Spain, 1235-1310) maintained that foods proscribed by the
Rabbis may be fed to children. According
to the Rashba, it would certainly be permissible to feed children meat during
the Nine Days, as meat is forbidden in this period only by force of
custom. The Rambam, however, ruled that
no forbidden food may be fed to children, even food which the Torah permits but
the Sages prohibited. Accordingly, the
Mishna Berura ruled that one may not feed meat even to very young children
during the Nine Days. Hacham Ovadia
Yosef, however, disagreed, arguing that meat is not forbidden at all during the
Nine Days, and we refrain from meat only by force of custom. Moreover, the Magen Abraham (Rav Abraham
Gombiner, Poland, 1635-1682) maintained that the custom to refrain from meat
during the Nine Days from the outset did not include children. Another reason to permit feeding meat to
children is that according to some opinions, this custom has the status of a
vow, and children are allowed to eat food proscribed merely by force a
vow. Additionally, a number of Poskim
noted the frailty of children, particularly in modern times, such that denying
meat to children who are accustomed to eating meat could adversely affect their
health. And, it is permissible to feed
children food whose permissibility is subject to a debate among the Poskim, and
the practice to refrain from meat during the Nine Days is not universally
accepted. For all these reasons, Hacham
Ovadia maintained that children should not be denied meat during the Nine
Days. The only exception he made was for
a twelve-year-old boy, who, since he will soon become a bar-mitzvah, should be
trained not to eat meat during this period.
(It is worth noting
that when it comes to fasting, Hacham Ovadia felt very strongly that children
should not be allowed to fast, as they require food for their health. He ruled that children under the age of
bar-mitzvah – even twelve-year-olds – should not fast, even on Yom Kippur, and
that Rabbis should announce in the synagogue on Yom Kippur that parents should
return home to make sure their children eat.)
It is permissible
during the Nine Days to eat meat and drink wine at a Se'udat Misva – meaning, a
meal that constitutes a Misva. One who
wishes to eat meat at a Se'udat Misva does not require Hatarat Nedarim, because
the custom itself allows eating meat at such an event, and thus the "vow" is
not being broken.
One example is the
meal celebrating a Berit Mila. All
guests who were invited to participate in the meal may partake of meat and
wine, but clearly a person who does not know the family cannot just show up at
the meal in order to enjoy meat and wine.
Although it is
permissible to eat meat at a Berit, one may not take some meat home from the
meal; eating meat is allowed only at the meal itself. The leftover meat should either be frozen or
distributed to the needy. However, the
infant's father, the Mohel and the Sandak are allowed to eat meat that entire
day. For them, the day of the Berit is a
Yom Tob, and so they may eat meat at any point during that day, even after the
meal.
Meat may be eaten at a
Berit even in the case of a "Mila She'lo Bi'zmanah" – a Berit that was
performed after the infant's eighth day because he was sick and unfit for
circumcision on the eighth day. However,
if the baby was deemed healthy enough for a Berit Mila before the Nine Days,
the Berit may not be delayed until the Nine Days for the purpose of serving
meat and wine, as it is forbidden to unnecessarily delay a Berit. And if the Berit was unnecessarily postponed
until the Nine Days, meat and wine may not be eaten at the meal.
Hacham Bension Abba
Shaul (Israel, 1924-1998) ruled that if the Berit was cancelled at the last
minute because the infant became sick and unfit for circumcision, the meat that
was prepared for the Se'uda may be eaten, despite the fact that no Berit took
place. He bases this ruling on the
principle that if a person genuinely tried performing a Misva, but was
unsuccessful due to circumstances beyond his control, he is nevertheless
credited with the fulfillment of a Misva.
Since he planned to perform the Misva and attempted to do so, he
receives credit for a Misva despite the outcome. Hence, if the infant suddenly became unfit
for Berit Mila, the parents are nevertheless considered to have fulfilled the
Misva of giving him a Berit that day, and thus the meal qualifies as a Se'udat
Misva, where meat and wine may be served.
The customary Zohar
recitation conducted on the night before a Berit does not qualify as a Se'udat
Misva, and thus meat may not be eaten at this event. This is the ruling of Hacham Ovadia Yosef.
The meal at a Pidyon
Ha'ben is considered a Se'udat Misva, and thus meat is allowed.
If a boy turns
thirteen during the Nine Days, and a meal is held on his birthday to celebrate
the occasion, then this meal qualifies as a Se'udat Misva, and meat may be
served. However, if the meal is held on
a different day, and not on his birthday, then meat may not be eaten at the
meal. If the boy's birthday is Ereb Rosh
Hodesh Ab, the meal should be postponed until after Tisha B'Ab.
A Siyum celebration
following the completion of the study of a Masechet (tractate of Gemara)
constitutes a Se'udat Misva, and meat may be eaten at such an event. All those invited to participate in the meal
may eat meat, even if they were not involved at all in the learning of the
Masechet. If a Siyum is made in a meat restaurant,
those who happen to be in the restaurant may listen to the Siyum and eat meat
(though it would certainly be inappropriate to intentionally go around to meat
restaurants in the hope of finding a Siyum).
Hacham Ovadia Yosef
ruled that it is permissible to specifically schedule the completion of a
Masechet for the Nine Days, though one who finished a Masechet before the Nine
Days may not intentionally leave the final line for the Nine Days for the
purpose of eating meat.
Although some people
look askance at the widespread practice to arrange Siyum celebrations for the
Nine Days in order to permit meat, many great Rabbis not only approved of this
practice, but even encouraged it. Some
explained that by celebrating Torah learning we actually make a significant
contribution to the rebuilding of the Bet Ha'mikdash. And it is told that the Ba'al Shem Tob
(founder of Hasidism, 1698-1760) specifically arranged his Torah learning such
that he would make a Siyum during the Nine Days – not because he craved meat
and wine, but rather because this weakened the power of the Satan. The Satan wields great strength during this
time of year, and one way we overpower the Satan is by increasing our Torah
learning and celebrating our learning accomplishments. In fact, the letters that spell Satan's name
– Samech, Mem, Alef and Lamed – can be read as an acrostic representing the
phrase "Siyum Masechet En La'asot" – "Do not make a Siyum of a Masechet," or
"Se'udat Misva En La'asot" – "Do not make a Se'udat Misva." The Satan specifically does not want us to
conduct Siyum celebrations, and so we are encouraged to do so during this
period when the Satan's strength is at its height.
Thus, as many great
Sages encouraged making Siyum celebrations during the Nine Days – and
especially in light of the fact that to begin with, meat and wine are forbidden
during this period only by force of custom – one should not object to those who
make Siyumim for the sake of permitting meat and wine.
Hacham Ovadia writes
that it is improper for several people to divide a Masechet between them, such
that each studies only a small portion, for the sake of conducting a joint
Siyum.
The Jewish community
of Izmir, Turkey, had the custom not to allow meat at a Siyum during the Nine
Days, and to eat fish, instead. Hacham
Ovadia ruled that members of that community who settled in Eretz Yisrael may
adopt the lenient practice of eating meat at a Siyum.
A mourner in the
twelve-month period of mourning for a parent, Heaven forbid, may attend a Siyum
celebration as long as no music is played.
As music is not permitted at a Se'udat Misva during the Nine Days, a
mourner is allowed to attend and partake of meat and wine.