Misva
#156: To Not Eat Impure Fish
The
Torah in Parashat Shemini (Vayikra 11:11) forbids eating fish belonging to a
non-kosher species. As discussed in an
earlier Misva, a fish is considered kosher if it has fins and scales;
otherwise, it is not kosher and forbidden for consumption. One who eats a Ke’zayit of flesh from a
non-kosher species of fish is liable to Malkut.
This
command is binding in all times and in all places, and upon both males and
females.
Misva
#157: To Not Eat Impure Fowl
The
Torah in Parashat Shemini (11:13) introduces the command forbidding the consumption
of non-kosher species of birds. The
reason behind this command, of course, is the same as the reason for the
Torah’s other dietary restrictions. As
the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, G-d knows that certain foods are harmful to
either our body or our souls, and so He commanded us to refrain from certain
foods for our own benefit, in order to preserve our physical and spiritual
wellbeing.
The
Torah does not specify the properties which signify a bird’s kosher or
non-kosher status, as it does for animals and fish. It lists twenty-four species of birds which
are forbidden, making it clear that all other species may be eaten, but it
gives us only the names of the species, and the identity of some of these
species cannot be definitively ascertained.
The Rabbis, through oral tradition, presented a number of guidelines for
determining the kosher status of different species of birds. First, any “Dores” – “bird of prey” – is
forbidden for consumption. This refers
to any bird that thrusts its claws into another bird to kill it. If a bird is not a bird of prey, then it is
kosher if it features all of the following three properties: one of its fingers
is longer than the others; it has a crop (part of the stomach), and its
Kurkuban (gizzard) is shaped in a certain way (“Niklaf”).
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that even if a bird which is not predatory has just one
of these three properties, it may be presumed kosher. He explains that the only non-kosher bird
which is not predatory and has just one of these properties is the Oreb
(raven), which is a widely recognized species.
Hence, if one encounters a different species that is not predatory and
has just one of these three properties, it can be presumed kosher. Moreover, the Sefer Ha’hinuch asserts, if a
bird has none of these properties, it may nevertheless be presumed kosher as
long as it is not a “Dores.” The reason,
he explains, is that the only two non-kosher birds that are not predators and
have none of these properties are the “Peres” and “Ozniya,” and according to
tradition, these species live in remote areas, and not in regions populated by
human beings. Hence, we need not be
concerned that this kind of bird which we come across belongs to one of these
two species. The Sefer Ha’hinuch cites
those who claimed that nowadays, we must be concerned that these species may,
in fact, live in areas of human habitation, and we thus must refrain from
species with none of these three properties, as they may be a “Peres” or
“Ozniya.” However, the Sefer Ha’hinuch
dismisses this claim as an unnecessary measure of stringency.
If
a bird is not predatory, and has exactly two of the three physical properties
mentioned above, then, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, we must be concerned that it
might belong to one of the non-kosher species.
Therefore, he writes, such a species may be eaten only if there is a
tradition that it is permissible.
In
light of the various opinions that exist regarding the determination of a given
species’ status, it is generally accepted to eat only those birds regarding
which there is a tradition permitting them for consumption. This practice has given rise to some
controversy surrounding the consumption of turkey, which was found only in
America, and not in Europe or in Sephardic lands. As there was no tradition allowing the
consumption of turkey, some Poskim, including Rav Shlomo Kluger (Galicia,
1783-1869), forbade the consumption of turkey.
Most Poskim, however, felt that are enough reasons to assume that the turkey
is a kosher species, and thus those who are accustomed to eating turkey
certainly have Halachic authorities upon whom to rely.
The
prohibition against eating non-kosher birds applies in all places and in all
times, and to both men and women. One
who intentionally eats a Ke’zayit of meat from a non-kosher species of bird is
liable to Malkut.