The
Torah in Parashat Ahareh-Mot (Vayikra 17:1-4) warns that one who slaughters an
animal sacrifice outside the Azara (courtyard of the Bet Ha’mikdash) is liable
to Karet (eternal excision from the Jewish Nation).
Interestingly,
the Torah does not directly forbid slaughtering a sacrifice outside the Bet
Ha’mikdash, but only warns that this act is punishable by Karet. Now there is a general rule that the Torah
does not punish without issuing a prohibition forbidding the act for which it
warns of punishment. The question thus
arises as to how the Torah could warn of punishment for slaughtering a
sacrifice outside the Bet Ha’mikdash if it never issued a prohibition against
such an act. The Gemara explains that
the Torah in a separate context forbids placing a sacrifice on an altar outside
the Bet Ha’mikdash, and the offering of a sacrifice on the altar is linked to
the slaughtering. As such, the
prohibition against placing the sacrifice on the altar outside the Bet
Ha’mikdash is extended to forbid slaughtering a sacrifice outside the Bet
Ha’mikdash.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that the reason for this Misva is because G-d designated
one particular site as the place for the offering of sacrifices, in order for
people to be moved and inspired by the awe and sanctity of that site. If it were permissible to offer sacrifices
anywhere, then people would have less esteem for the Bet Ha’mikdash, and then
the experience of visiting the site would be less impactful.
The
Torah warns in this context that if one slaughters a sacrifice outside the Bet
Ha’mikdash, then “Dam Ye’hasheb Le’ish Ha’hu, Dam Shafach” – “This will be
considered like bloodguilt for that person; he has spilled blood.” In a certain sense, this person is guilty of
murder. The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains
that G-d allowed killing animals only for our practical needs – such as eating
– and for atonement through the offering of sacrifices. Killing an animal for no reason, however, is
wrong. Therefore, if a person
slaughtered an animal outside the Bet Ha’mikdash, where this is forbidden, then
he has shed blood, taking an animal’s life for no valid, constructive purpose.
One
violates this prohibition and is liable to Karet once he slaughters the
sacrifice, even if the animal is later offered on the altar in the Bet
Ha’mikdash.
This
prohibition applies only to animal sacrifices which are suitable to be
offered. If an animal is, for whatever,
unfit as a sacrifice, then slaughtering it outside the Bet Ha’mikdash does not
transgress this prohibition.
This
prohibition applies in all locations and in all times, even nowadays. If an animal is consecrated as a sacrifice,
and somebody slaughters it, he has transgressed this prohibition. If one slaughtered the animal with the
intention of transgressing this prohibition, he is liable to Karet, and if he
committed the violation unintentionally, then he is required to offered a
Korban Hatat (sin-offering).