The
Torah commands in Parashat Kedoshim (Vayikra 19:14), “Lo Tekalel Heresh” – “Do
not curse a deaf person.” The Gemara
explains this verse as prohibiting cursing even somebody who is not present and
thus does not hear the curse. The Torah
forbids cursing anybody, and mentions “Heresh” (“deaf person”) in this verse to
emphasize that one may not curse even somebody who is “deaf” in the sense that
he does not hear the curse.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch offers several different explanations for why the Torah
prohibited cursing one’s fellow. First,
he writes, people become frightened when they are cursed. Even if they are
cursed by a simple, ordinary person, they take the curse to heart, and feel
concerned and distressed. Just as we may
not inflict physical harm upon our fellow, we are likewise not to inflict
emotional harm, and the Torah therefore forbade cursing another person.
Secondly,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, the Gemara teaches that “Berit Keruta
La’sefatayim” – G-d made a “promise” to the lips, that a person’s words are
impactful. Hence, a curse will have some
harmful effect. The Sefer Ha’hinuch
elaborates on this concept, explaining that the power of speech emanates not
from a person’s physical properties, but rather from his soul, which originates
from the heavens. The Torah relates in
Parashat Bereshit that after G-d created the physical human being, “Va’yipah
Be’apav Nishmat Hayim” – “He blew a living soul in his nostrils.” Onkelos translates the expression “Nishmat
Hayim” as “Ru’ah Memalela” – “a spirit that speaks.” This shows that the power of speech is a
manifestation of the human soul. As
such, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, the words one speaks have immense power, and
can have an impact upon other people.
For this reason, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, the greater a person’s
spiritual level is, the greater the impact of his words (which is why, for
example, we ask the Sadikim for blessings).
And so the Torah forbade cursing, because such words will inflict some
degree of harm upon the other person.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch then adds yet another reason, explaining that the Torah forbade
cursing in order to help prevent fighting among people. Naturally, when somebody curses his fellow, the
fellow will respond angrily, and conflict will ensue. The Torah strives to maintain peace among
people, and it therefore forbids cursing, which instigates strife and
quarreling. The Sefer Ha’hinuch notes
that one might question this explanation in light of the fact that the Torah
forbids cursing one’s fellow even in private, behind his fellow’s back, which
will not cause any fighting. Responding
to this challenge, the Sefer Ha’hinuch cites King Shlomo’s teaching in Kohelet
(10:20) that one should avoiding cursing people even in private, “Ki Of
Ha’shamayim Yolich Et Ha’kol” – “because the bird in the sky will bring the
sound…” In contemporary jargon, this is
expressed as, “Walls have ears.” Even
when somebody speaks in private, somehow, the words get around. Therefore, the Torah forbids cursing somebody
even in private, as the curse may very well become known to that person,
resulting in friction and strife.
The
Rambam suggests a different reason for why the Torah forbade cursing,
explaining that cursing has the effect of accustoming a person to anger and
vengeance. The curse perhaps has
absolutely no effect whatsoever on the person against whom it was spoken, but
it engenders a hostile nature within the speaker, compromising his Middot
(character taits), and for this reason, the Torah commanded that we may not
curse our fellow.
This
prohibition is exceptional in that violators are liable to Malkut despite not
committing any action. Normally, only
violations committed through a concrete action are punishable by Malkut; when
it comes to cursing one’s fellow, however, due to the severity of this sin,
violators are liable to Malkut despite the fact that they merely spoke, without
performing an action. However, one is
liable to Malkut for this violation only if he cursed his fellow mentioning
G-d’s Name, or some reference to G-d, in any language (for example, “G-d should
do to you such-and-such”). Although one
violates the Torah prohibition even without mentioning G-d, Malkut are
administered only if one curses with a Name of, or reference to, G-d.
The
Gemara comments that there is one situation where a person can be liable to
four sets of Malkut for cursing a single individual – if a person curses his
father, who is the both the Nasi (similar to the position of Chief Rabbi in
Talmudic times) and the head of the Sanhedrin (“Ab Bet Din”). The son has violated four separate
prohibitions: cursing one’s father, cursing a Nasi, cursing an Ab Bet Din, and
cursing a fellow Jew.
Needless
to say, this prohibition applies at all times, in all places, and to both men
and women.