The
Torah commands in Parashat Kedoshim (Vayikra 20:23), “Ve’lo Telchu Be’hukot
Ha’goy” – that it is forbidden to follow the practices of the non-Jews. The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, based on the
ruling of the Rambam (Hilchot Abodat Kochabim 11:1), that this applies even to
customs such as style of dress. The
Safra adds that we are not permitted to attend the kinds of events that non-Jews
attend in “theaters, circuses and stadiums.”
Likewise, it is forbidden to cut one’s hair in a manner that resembles
the non-Jews’ styles.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that the Torah forbade following non-Jewish practices in
order that we avoid excessive intermingling with gentiles, which could lead to
foreign worship and intermarriage.
The
Maharik (Rav Yosef Kolon, 1420-1480), in one of his responsa (88), addressed
the question of whether a Jewish doctor is permitted to wear the customary
doctor’s uniform (such as the white coat in our times). This uniform would be worn not in order to
imitate the gentiles, but rather for a practical purpose – so that people would
know that he is a physician. Is this
nevertheless forbidden?
The
Maharik replied that since this garment is worn for a beneficial purpose, and
not in order to resemble the non-Jews, this is allowed. The Vilna Gaon (1720-1797), however, disagreed. Advancing a much more stringent view on this
prohibition, the Gaon maintained that it is forbidden to dress in the style of
the non-Jews regardless of the intent.
The
general consensus among the Halachic authorities permits adopting practices
followed by non-Jews that are rational, and forbids adopting practices that
have no rational basis. Thus, for
example, some Poskim forbid placing candles on a cake for one’s birthday. While there is a rational reason to celebrate
a birthday, there is no rational reason for placing candles, and then making a
wish and blowing them out. Therefore,
Rav Avraham Blumenkrantz (1944-2007) ruled that birthday candles violate the
prohibition of “Hukot Ha’goyim.” Similarly,
Rav Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986) discusses the question as to whether it is
permissible to make a point of eating turkey on Thanksgiving. Leaving aside the question of whether having
a celebration on this holiday is allowed, eating specifically turkey has no
rational basis, and thus this might fall under the prohibition of “Hukot
Ha’goyim.”
Some
communities do not wear neckties for this reason, claiming that there is no
rational basis for wearing this particular kind of garment. Others, however, permit neckties, as they are
worn for the purpose of looking respectable.
The Poskim also discuss the question as to whether using the Gregorian
calendar instead of the Jewish calendar might perhaps violate this prohibition.
The
underlying principle is that we must not be viewing the conduct of the non-Jews
as a model and example for us to follow, as we are bidden to follow the
dictates of the Torah.
This
prohibition applies in all times and places, and to both men and women. One who conducted himself in a manner
resembling the gentiles is in violation of this command and is liable to
Malkut.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch concludes his discussion by emphasizing that we are to distance
ourselves from the behaviors of the non-Jews, and devote ourselves fully to
fulfilling Hashem’s will, and that those who do so will be rewarded both in
this world and in the next world.