After introducing the prohibition against offering
a blemished animal as a sacrifice, and listing the disqualifying blemishes, the
Torah (Vayikra 22:24) commands, “U’be’arsechem Lo Ta’asu” – “You shall not do
so in your land.” This is understood as
referring specifically to the blemishes involving the male reproductive organs,
such that the Torah here forbids causing such defects. This verse, then, introduces the prohibition
against castrating male animals or humans.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that the Torah forbids
castration because G-d wants all creatures to reproduce and multiply. Indeed, we are commanded, “Peru U’rebu” – to
procreate, and the animal species, too, are intended to multiply upon the
earth. The Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that
as all creatures are mortal, G-d wants the members of all species to reproduce
so as to ensure their perpetuation, as each species was especially created by
the Almighty, and must therefore be maintained.
One who castrates a creature shows that he does not wish for that
species to multiply, and thus expresses disdain for one of G-d’s creations, indicating
that he wants this species to disappear and not propagate. The Sefer Ha’hinuch’s comments are very
relevant to modern times, when people advocate for a lifestyle which does not
allow for reproduction. The Torah
teaches us that G-d wants all creatures – certainly including human beings – to
procreate, and one of our most important obligations is to do what we can to
create new life.
It is forbidden even to instruct a gentile to
castrate an animal owned by a Jew. If,
however, a gentile castrated a Jew’s animal without being asked to do so, the
Jew may take the animal back and benefit from it. But if the Jew hints to the gentile that he
wants his animal castrated, and the gentile castrated it, the Jew may not then
use the animal. In such a case, the
Rabbis impose a penalty on the Jew and forbid him from benefitting from the
animal.
If a person severed one part of the animal’s
reproductive organ, and another person severed the remaining part, they are
both liable to Malkut for jointly transgressing this prohibition.
A man is not allowed to make himself sterile even
indirectly, by drinking a potion which causes sterility. However, one is not liable for Malkut by
making himself sterile in this fashion.
Likewise, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that one may not place his fellow
in the snow to make him sterile. If he does
so, he receives Malkut Mi’de’rabbanan (by force of Rabbinic enactment).
Women are not bound by the obligation of Peru
U’rebu. Therefore, when the need arises
– such as if a woman has a medical condition which makes pregnancy or
childbirth dangerous – she may cause herself to become sterile.
This prohibition applies in all places and all
times, and to both men and women, as a woman is forbidden from castrating an
animal or a male human being. One who
violates this command is liable to Malkut.