After
the Torah issued an affirmative command to observe the seventh day of Pesach as
a sacred occasion, when we refrain from work (Vayikra 23:8), it then adds a
Misvat Lo Ta’aseh – a prohibition – against performing Melacha (work) on this
day: “Kol Melechet Aboda Lo Ta’asu.”
Thus, performing Melacha on this day transgresses both an affirmative
command and a prohibition.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch in this context elaborates on the concept of “Yom Tob Sheni” –
the additional day of Yom Tob observed in the Diaspora after the first and last
days of Pesach, after Shabuot, after the first day of Sukkot, and after Shemini
Aseret. In the Diaspora, an eighth day
of Pesach is observed, even though the Torah speaks of Pesach as a seven-day
festival.
The
background of this practice, as the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, is the system
used in ancient times for declaring new months.
We follow a fixed-calendar system, but long ago, the new month was
declared when the new moon was sighted. This
would happen on either the night of the 30th of the previous month –
in which case the 30th day would be the first day of the new month –
or the night of the 31st of the previous month – in which case the
31st day would be the first day of the new month. Each
month, the Bet Din would dispatch messengers to inform the Jewish communities
which day was declared Rosh Hodesh.
These messengers would not always reach the distant communities in the
Diaspora before Yom Tob, and so these communities would have to observe two
days as Yom Tob. Although we no longer
have this Safek (uncertainty), nevertheless, it was established that we
commemorate our ancestors’ practice and observe two days of Yom Tob in the
Diaspora.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch notes the debate among the Poskim as to whether these two days
are treated the same nowadays as they were in yesteryear, when an extra day was
necessary due to the uncertainty as to which day was Yom Tob. Back then, if an egg was laid on the first
day of Yom Tob, it was permissible on the second day, even though normally an
egg laid on Shabbat or Yom Tob may not be used on a different day of Yom
Tob. The reason is that if the first day
was Yom Tob, then the second day is not Yom Tob, so the egg is permissible, and
if the second day is Yom Tob, then the egg was not actually laid on Yom Tob,
and so it is not forbidden at all. Nowadays,
however, there is no uncertainty; we observe both days as Yom Tob even though
we know definitively which day is the actual day when Yom Tob is to be
observed. Therefore, some authorities
maintained that nowadays, an egg laid on the first day of Yom Tob is forbidden
on the second day, as we observe both days definitively, and not due to an
uncertainty. Others, however, disagreed,
arguing that since our observance of the second day of Yom Tob is purely
commemorative, it cannot be treated more stringently than the original practice
which it commemorates. Therefore,
according to this view, even nowadays, an egg laid on the first day of Yom Tob is
permissible on the second day.
Interestingly,
this practice to observe an additional day of Yom Tob overrides a number of
Biblical obligations. For example, we do
not wear Tefillin on eighth day of Pesach, which the Torah requires – since,
according to Torah law, this day is an ordinary weekday – because we observe
this day as a Yom Tob. Likewise, if a
baby was unable to undergo Berit Mila on his eighth day, but is able to be
circumcised on the second day of Yom Tob, he is not circumcised on this day,
because only circumcision on the child’s eighth day is permitted on Shabbat or
Yom Tob. Torah law regards this day as a
weekday, and thus requires circumcising the infant on this day, but the
circumcision is nevertheless delayed because of the custom to observe this day as
Yom Tob.
Beyond
the practical reason for the observance of a second day, as discussed, a deeper
reason has also been proposed. This has
been explained by way of an analogy to a young child who must be given
medicine. In order for the child to
receive the full dose that he needs, the parent must administer a slightly
higher dose, because the child will spit out some of the medicine. By the same token, outside the Land of
Israel, where we are exposed to impurities, we need a higher “dose” of Kedusha
in order to receive the spiritual power that Yom Tob is meant to provide us
with. Since some of the sanctity of Yom
Tob will be lost due to the impurity of the Diaspora, we need an extra day of
Yom Tob so we absorb the amount of Kedusha which we are meant to absorb.