The
Torah in Parashat Naso (Bamidbar 7:9) commands that the Leviyim assigned the
coveted role of transporting the Aron (ark) must carry it on their shoulders,
and not by carriage or other means – “Ba’katef Yisa’u.”
The
Rambam, controversially, writes that this Misva is actually assigned not to the
entire tribe of Levi, but rather specifically to the Kohanim. Although the Kehat family of Leviyim
transported the Aron through the wilderness, the Rambam writes that this was an
exceptional, temporary provision, necessitated by the fact that there were very
few Kohanim at that time. In the desert,
the only Kohanim were Aharon and his sons, and so the entire Kehat family participated
in the transportation of the ark. Later,
however, when the Aron needed to be transported, this was done specifically by
the Kohanim, because, according to the Rambam, this Misva is assigned only to
them.
The
Ramban disagrees, writing about the Rambam’s theory, “Eno Emet” – “It is not
true.” Heaven forfend, the Ramban
writes, that this Misva changed from an obligation upon the tribe of Levi to a
Misva assigned specifically to the Kohanim.
In his view, this obligation continued to rest upon the tribe of Levi as
a whole, just as it was in the wilderness.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch concurs with the Ramban’s opinion.
It
should be noted that the Ramban agrees that the Kohanim are eligible to carry
the Aron, as they, too, are called “Leviyim” (as in the verse in Yehezkel (44:15),
“Ve’ha’kohanim Ha’leviyim Beneh Sadok”).
He disagrees only with the Rambam’s assertion that the job of
transporting the ark was assigned solely to the Kohanim.
Explaining
the reason behind this Misva, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that the Torah is our
nation’s source of honor, and it is what distinguishes us from other
peoples. Therefore, it is appropriate
that the most prominent tribe – the tribe of Levi – should be assigned the task
of carrying the Aron, which contained the Torah.
This
Misva applies only when Am Yisrael live in their land and have an Aron.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch observes the custom that was practiced among communities in his
time to remove the Torah scrolls from the ark and bring them to greet the
gentile king when he visited the town, as a display of honor and respect. When this is done, the Sefer Ha’hinuch
writes, there is no obligation whatsoever to have specifically Leviyim carry
the Torah scrolls, as this Misva pertains only to the Aron in the Bet
Ha’mikdash. Nevertheless, he adds, if a
congregation chooses to have Leviyim carrying the Torah scrolls in accordance
with the spirit of this Misva, then this is a worthwhile practice.