The
Torah in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 21:28-32) discusses situations of “Nizkeh
Behema” – where a person’s animal causes damage to another person, such as when
an ox gores another ox, or gores a human being.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch lists as the 51st Biblical command the obligation
upon Bet Din to preside over these cases and require the responsible party to
compensate the victim.
A
fundamental distinction exists between cases where an animal caused damage
while acting abnormally, and situations of an animal who damaged through normal
behavior. Oxen, for example, generally
gore, and so if an ox fatally gores another ox, the owner is responsible to pay
only “Hasi Nezek” – half the value of the damage caused. And, if half the value of the damage exceeds
the value of the ox, then the owner can just give his ox to the victim. Since this violent conduct was unusual and
thus could not have been expected, the owner’s responsibility is lower. However, if the ox had gored on three
separate occasions, and the owner was warned to guard the animal against
violent behavior, then if the ox gores another ox, the owner must pay full
compensation for the damages. Since the
animal had established a habit of violent behavior, the owner is held fully
responsible for damages it causes.
In
the case of an ox that fatally gored a human being, Bet Din stones the
animal. If, for whatever reason, Bet Din
did not kill the animal, and the animal managed to kill three people on three
separate occasions, then the owner must make a payment to the victim’s
inheritors to protect himself against punishment by G-d.
A
person is held responsible for his animal’s damages only if the damage was
caused in the victim’s property, or in a public area. If, however, an ox went into somebody else’s
property, and was then gored by an ox belonging to that property’s owner, then
the owner bears no responsibility, because the incident occurred on his
property.
Different
standards of protection are required in the case of a “Shor Tam” – an ox that
had not yet gored three times – and in the case of a “Shor Mu’ad” – an ox that
had gored three times. The Gemara
establishes that the owner of a “Shor Tam” that damages is required to pay
compensation unless he had guarded the animal at the standard of “Shemira
Me’ula” – a high level of protection. In
the case of a “Shor Mu’ad,” however, whose owner would be required to pay more
for damages, the owner is absolved even if he guarded the animal at a low
standard of protection (“Shemira Pehuta”).
The
nature of this obligation, to compensate for damages caused by one’s animal,
has been understood in several different ways.
Some Rabbis understood that the owner must pay compensation for failing
to properly guard the animal; it is only because he did not properly protect
against damage that he bears responsibility to pay. Others, however, maintained that one’s
property should be viewed as an extension of himself. Just as a person is responsible for the damages
which he causes, he is similarly responsible for the damages caused by his
animal, which is an extension of himself.
Yet a third, particularly novel, theory was advanced by the Serideh Esh
(Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg, 1884-1966), who suggested that in essence, an
animal that causes damage should be held responsible to compensate the
victim. But since an animal cannot,
quite obviously, be forced to pay compensation, the responsibility is
transferred to the owner.
Regardless,
this Misva reminds us of the emphasis the Torah places on sensitivity and
consideration, that religious life requires us to live in a way that keeps
other people’s safety and wellbeing in mind.
By commanding the Bet Din to preside over these cases and hold people accountable
for damages caused by their animals, the Torah ensures that we all act responsibly
and do what we can to maintain a safe, secure environment for everybody.