The
Torah commands in the Book of Shemot (12:9), “Al Tochelu Mimenu Na U’bashel
Mebushal Ba’mayim” – that one may not eat the meat of the Korban Pesah when it
is in a state of “Na,” or if it had been boiled in water (or any other liquid). The word “Na” is commonly translated as
“raw,” but in truth, it means “not fully roasted.” If one eats the meat of the Korban Pesach when
it is completely raw, he fails to fulfill the affirmative command to eat the
meat roasted, but he does not violate the prohibition against eating it “Na,”
because “Na” refers to meat which has begun to be roasted over fire but has not
yet been fully roasted.
More
specifically, “Na” refers to meat which has yet to be roasted to the point of
“Ma’achal Ben Derusai” – the point at which it is just barely edible. Once the meat of the Korban Pesach has
reached the minimum level of edibility, it is no longer considered “Na,” and
thus it may be eaten. Both sides of the
meat must be roasted until the point of “Ma’achal Ben Derusai” for the meat to
be permissible for consumption (just as on Shabbat, one who cooks meat is not
in violation of Shabbat unless both sides reach the level of “Ma’achal Ben
Derusai”).
Like
all the Misvot relevant to the Korban Pesach, this Misva applies to both men
and women.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that the reason behind the Misva is that as we
celebrate our nation’s Exodus from Egypt, we should conduct ourselves as
distinguished noblemen. In ancient
times, the masses, who could not afford to eat large quantities of meat, would
boil their meat, even though roasted meat tastes better, because roasting
causes the meat to contract, whereas boiling has the effect of expanding
it. Only the wealthy aristocracy, who
could afford large quantities of meat, would roast their meat to enjoy the
enhanced taste, because it did not matter to them that the meat contracted over
the process of roasting. On Pesach, as
we celebrate our freedom from bondage, we are to conduct ourselves in a regal
manner, and so the Torah forbids eating the meat of the Korban Pesach in a
state other than fully roasted.
Additionally,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, meat can be prepared more swiftly by roasting than
by boiling. Thus, roasting the meat of
the Korban Pesach serves to commemorate the “Hipazon” – the haste with which
Beneh Yisrael left Egypt, when they needed to prepare the meat of the sacrifice
in the quickest way possible.
The
Rambam, in his listing of the Misvot, includes under this prohibition both
eating meat of the Korban Pesach which is not fully roasted, and meat of the
Korban Pesach which was boiled. The
Ramban, however, disagrees with this classification, and lists two separate
prohibitions: one forbidding eating meat of the Korban Pesach which has not
been fully roasted, and another forbidding eating meat of the Korban Pesach
which had been boiled. Therefore, if one
ate both kinds of meat – a piece which is not fully roasted, and a piece which
had been boiled – then according to the Rambam, he is liable to just a single
set of Malkut (lashes), whereas according to the Ramban, he is liable to two
sets of Malkut.
An
interesting question arises according to the Ramban in the case of meat of the
Korban Pesach which was partially roasted, and, before it reached the point of
“Ma’achal Ben Derusai,” it was taken off the fire and then boiled in
water. If one would then eat this meat,
would he be in violation of both prohibitions, or only a single
prohibition? Of course, this question
does not arise according to the Rambam, who in any event includes both
partially roasted meat and boiled meat under a single prohibition. But according to the Ramban, who maintains
that these constitute two separate prohibitions, for how many violations would
one be liable if he partakes of meat of the Korban Pesach which was both
partially roasted and boiled in water?
At
first glance, we would apply to this case the rule of “En Issur Hal Al Issur” (literally,
“a prohibition cannot descend upon a [different] prohibition”) – that once
something is forbidden by force of one prohibition, it cannot then become
subject to another prohibition.
Seemingly, once the meat becomes forbidden because it is partially
roasted, it cannot then also become subject to a separate prohibition when it
is boiled, and thus one who eats this meat would be liable for just a single
violation – eating partially roasted meat.
The Minhat Hinuch, however, notes that the rule of “En Issur Hal Al
Issur” is not applicable to this case, because Halacha makes an exception in a
situation of “Issur Mosif” – where the second prohibition is more inclusive
than the first. If the second prohibition
expands the prohibition beyond the parameters of the first prohibition, then
the object in question indeed becomes subject to both prohibitions. In the case under discussion, boiling the
meat has the effect of rendering it permanently forbidden. Partially roasted meat, while currently
prohibited for consumption, can become permissible if it is left to continue
roasting on the fire. But once it is
boiled in water, its prohibited status becomes permanent. Since the second prohibition contributes an additional
element to the meat’s prohibited status, it takes effect, and the meat should
thus become forbidden by force of both prohibitions – the prohibition against
eating partially roasted meat of the Korban Pesach, and the prohibition against
eating boiled meat of the Korban Pesach.
On the
other hand, the Minhat Hinuch writes, one might argue that boiling the
partially roasted meat has the effect of erasing the meat’s prior history,
so-to-speak, such that it is no longer considered to have been partially
roasted. If so, then even according to
the Ramban, a person who eats this meat would be liable for only a single violation
– eating boiled meat of the Korban Pesach.
The Minhat Hinuch leaves this question unresolved.