The
Torah commands in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 22:27), “Ve’nasi Be’amcha Lo
Ta’or” – not to curse a “Nasi,” referring to either a Jewish king, or the head
of the Sanhedrin. This verse, then,
establishes a Biblical prohibition against cursing either of these two
leadership figures.
In
explaining the reason behind this command, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that every
society needs leadership, people whose decisions and rules are accepted and
obeyed. Otherwise, everyone will follow
his or her own decisions and guidelines, and chaos would ensue, as people will
fight with one another. In both
religious matters as well as general matters, there need to be leaders with the
authority to determine policy. The Sefer
Ha’hinuch writes that even though a leader will, on occasion, likely err and
make the wrong decision, it is nevertheless imperative that the people accept
the leader’s authority in order to prevent chaos and lawlessness. It is preferable to have a flawed leader who
occasionally errs than no leader at all.
Therefore, the Sefer Ha’hinuch explains, in light of the great
importance of stable leadership, the Torah requires showing respect to leaders,
because otherwise, if people degrade and insult their leaders, they will not
obey their laws, and the social fabric will then begin to unravel. For this reason, the Torah forbade cursing a
king – the political leader – or the head of the Sanhedrin – the religious
leader.
Of
course, this law applies to both men and women, and when there is a king or
Sanhedrin. One who curses one of these
leaders has transgressed this prohibition, and if the person invoked the Name
of G-d, then he receives Malkut. Although generally one is not liable to Malkut
for transgressing a prohibition without committing an action, an exception is
made in the case of one who invokes the Name of G-d. (The Sages inferred this exception from a
pair of verses in the Book of Debarim (28:58-59).)
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch notes that there is a separate Torah prohibition that forbids
cursing any Jew, and there is also a separate Torah prohibition that forbids
cursing a judge. Therefore, one who
curses the head of the Sanhedrin – who is also a judge – has transgressed three
Torah prohibitions, and is thus liable to three sets of Malkut. If the head of the Sanhedrin is one’s father,
and he curses him, then he receives four sets of Malkut, as there is also a
distinct prohibition against cursing one’s parent.
The
Torah formulates this command as forbidding cursing “Nasi Be’amcha” – “a leader
in your nation.” The Gemara understands
this as referring specifically to a leader who acts in accordance with “Ma’aseh
Amcha” – the way Jews are supposed to act, to the exclusion of a sinner. As such, the Torah prohibition against
cursing a Nasi does not apply to cursing a wicked leader. Some maintain that a wicked king is not to be
shown respect at all, as evidenced by the story told in the Gemara of Rabbi
Shimon Ben Shetah, who testified in court against King Yannai, a wicked
king. Generally, a defendant is required
to stand when the witnesses testify about him, but when a king is on trial, he
is not required to stand, due to the special respect owed to him. Rabbi Shimon Ben Shetah, however, ordered
King Yannai to stand, seemingly proving that no respect is owed to a wicked
king. Others try drawing proof to the
contrary from the story of the prophet Eliyahu, who ran ahead of King Ahab in
order to show him respect after the revelation of G-d on Mount Carmel. Ahab was clearly a wicked king, and thus the
fact that Eliyahu showed him respect would seem to indicate that even wicked
kings must be respected. However, some
dismissed this proof by claiming that after the spectacle at Mount Carmel, when
the nation recognized G-d and proclaimed, “Hashem Hu Ha’Elokim” (“Hashem is
G-d”), Ahab was, at least for a short while, considered a Ba’al Teshuba
(penitent sinner), and for this reason Eliyahu showed him respect. But once Ahab resumed his sinful conduct,
then there was no requirement to treat him with respect.