The
Torah in Parashat Ahareh Mot introduces the prohibition against engaging in
intimate relations with one’s granddaughter.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch lists this prohibition as two separate Biblical
commands – a prohibition against relations with one’s son’s daughter (“Ervat
Bat Beno”), and a prohibition against relations with one’s daughter’s daughter
(“Ervat Bat Bito”).
This
prohibition applies even to the daughter of an illegitimate child. For example, if one’s son is a Mamzer
(product of an illicit relationship such as adultery), and this son then has a
daughter, relations between the grandfather and the granddaughter are
forbidden. Likewise, if a man has a
legitimate son, and that son produces a Mamzeret, relations between the
grandfather and the granddaughter are forbidden. Even though the granddaughter is the product
of an illicit relationship, nevertheless, this prohibition applies.
The
Sages extended this prohibition further, forbidding relations with one’s
great-granddaughter – regardless of whether she is one’s son’s granddaughter,
or one’s daughter’s granddaughter.
This
prohibition is binding in all times, and in all places. One who transgressed this prohibition in the
presence of two valid witnesses, after being warned, is liable to Serefa
(execution by burning). If no witnesses
saw the violation, then the violator is liable to Karet. If the violation was committed
unintentionally, then one must bring a Hatat (sin-offering). One who violates the Rabbinic enactment
forbidding relations with a great-granddaughter is liable to Malkut for
violating the words of the Sages.
Different
opinions exist as to the definition of “Karet.”
Some explain that it refers to early death, meaning, passing away
between the ages of 50 and 60. Another
opinion is that “Karet” means sudden death, without first growing frail and
ill. (It goes without saying that this
does not allow us to say about someone who died young, or who died suddenly,
that he or she committed a grave violation and was thus punished with
“Karet.” We are never entitled to claim
to know why a person was punished in such a manner.)
The
Ramban, in his Torah commentary (Parashat Ahareh-Mot), writes that there are
three different forms of Karet: 1) losing one’s share in the afterlife; 2)
dying young; 3) a combination of the previous two – meaning, losing one’s share
in the afterlife, and dying young. The
Ramban explains on this basis the different expressions with which the Torah
refers to the punishment of Karet. In
some contexts, G-d warns that the violator will be “Nichrat…Mi’lefanai” – “cut
off…from My presence.” The Ramban writes
that this refers to the loss of one’s share in the next world, being denied the
privilege of being in G-d’s presence in the afterlife. In other instances, the Torah warns that
“Ha’ish Ha’hu” – “that person” – will be “cut off,” referring to the loss of
physical life, meaning, an early death.
And on some occasions, the Torah speaks of Karet with a double
expression – “Hikaret Tikaret,” which the Ramban understands as a reference to
the worst form of Karet – where one both dies young and forfeits his share in
the world to come.