The
Torah in Parashat Behar (25:4) introduces the prohibition against agricultural
work during the Shemita year, which is observed every seven years in the Land
of Israel. The Sefer Ha’hinuch discussed
the reasons behind the Shemita year earlier, in reference to the Misva to
declare one’s fields ownerless on the Shemita year (Misva 84).
In
discussing this Misva, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that one who performs
forbidden agricultural work during Shemita “Bi’zman Ha’bayit” – in the times of
the Bet Ha’mikdash – has transgressed this prohibition and is liable to Malkut. The commentaries note that the Sefer
Ha’hinuch did not actually mean that the Torah commands regarding Shemita apply
specifically during the times of the Bet Ha’mikdash. For in truth, the Biblical prohibitions
relevant to Shemita apply only when the majority of the Jewish Nation lives in
the Land of Israel. And thus even during
the Second Commonwealth, when the Bet Ha’mikdash stood, the Misvot of Shemita
did not apply on the level of Torah law, because only a minority of the Jewish
Nation was living in the land at that time.
When only a minority of the Jewish Nation lives in Israel, the laws of
Shemita apply only Mi’de’rabbanan (by force of Rabbinic enactment).
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch lists a separate Misva (Misva 327) forbidding work involving
trees during the Shemita year (as opposed to working the ground). Interestingly, the Torah does not explicitly
forbid planting trees during Shemita. It
commands that one may not prune his vine (“Lo Tizmor” – 25:4), an activity
which enhances the vine. The Sages
deduced that if the Torah forbade an act which is beneficial for a tree, then
certainly it is forbidden to actually plant a tree. The Hazon Ish (Rav Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, 1878-1953)
noted that one who plants a tree during Shemita is not liable to Malkut, even
though he has transgressed a Torah violation.
The rule of “En Onshin Min Ha’din” establishes that the courts do not
punish for violations of a law which is derived through logical deduction (Kal
Va’homer), and is not explicated in the text of the Torah. Hence, one who plants a tree during Shemita
does not receive Malkut.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch lists an additional Misva (328) forbidding harvesting produce
which grew during Shemita, produce known as “Sefihin.” This refers to produce which grew on its own,
or that had been planted permissibly before the onset of the Shemita year. On the level of Torah law, it is permissible
to harvest small amounts of this produce for consumption, but not to harvest
normally, in large quantities. Even if a
person planted during Shemita in violation of the prohibitions of Shemita,
Torah law permits eating this produce, and forbids only harvesting it in large
quantities as he normally does. The
Sages, however, forbade eating produce which grew during Shemita, because there
were people who would plant during Shemita, in violation of Torah law, and then
sell the produce claiming that it had been planted before Shemita. This prohibition applies to vegetables, grain
and legumes, which grow quickly. It does
not apply to fruits, which take a long time to grow, such that there is no
concern that they would be deceptively presented as having been planted before
Shemita.
One
who collects “Sefihin” – even nowadays – is liable to “Makkot Mardut” (lashes)
for violating the Rabbinic enactment forbidding “Sefihin.”