The
Torah in Parashat Re’eh (Debarim 12:17-18) introduces a command forbidding
eating “the tithe of your grain, your wine or your oil in one of your gates,”
instead of eating it in Jerusalem. This
refers to Ma’aser Sheni, the only of the three tithes which can be considered
“yours,” as it is eaten by the owner of the produce. Ma’aser Rishon must be given to a Levi, and
Ma’aser Ani must be given to the poor, but Ma’aser Sheni is brought to
Jerusalem and eaten there. The Torah
here commands that the tithe must be eaten “Lifneh Hashem” – “before G-d,”
referring to the city of Jerusalem, and it is forbidden to eat it outside the
city.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch, following the view of the Rambam, lists this prohibition as
three separate commands – one forbidding consuming Ma’aser Sheni of grain
(“Dagan”) outside Jerusalem, a second forbidding consuming Ma’aser Sheni of
wine (“Tirosh”) outside Jerusalem, and a third forbidding consuming Ma’aser
Sheni of oil (“Yis’har”) outside Jerusalem.
One
is liable to Malkut for eating Ma’aser Sheni produce outside Jerusalem only if
the produce had been brought to Jerusalem and was then brought outside the
city. Furthermore, this prohibition is
transgressed only if the produce had not been redeemed. The Torah allows transferring the sanctity of
Ma’aser Sheni from the produce onto money and then bringing the money to
Jerusalem, instead of bringing the produce to Jerusalem. Once the sanctity is exchanged onto money,
the produce loses its special status, and may be eaten anywhere one wishes.
This
prohibition is binding upon both men and women.
In
discussing the third in this series of prohibitions – the prohibition
concerning oil of Ma’aser Sheni – the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that one
transgresses this command by consuming a Ke’zayit of oil. Normally, the volume of Ke’zayit is used in
reference to the consumption of solid foods, and not in the context of drinking
beverages. It thus seems strange, at
first glance, that the Sefer Ha’hinuch rules that this prohibition – eating oil
of Ma’aser Sheni outside Jerusalem – is violated through the consumption of a
Ke’zayit of oil. The Sefer Ha’hinuch
addresses this question, and explains that people do not use oil as a beverage;
oil is consumed like food, and not drunk like a beverage. Although, as the Sefer Ha’hinuch observes,
some Arab populations indeed drink oil like a beverage, they are a small
minority of people. Therefore, the
volume of oil of Ma’aser Sheni that one must consume outside Jerusalem to
transgress this command is a Ke’zayit, as it is treated like a solid food with
respect to consumption.