The Torah in Parashat
Vaet'hanan (4:2) introduces the prohibitions known as "Bal Tosif" and "Bal
Tigra" – adding onto the Torah's laws, and detracting from the Torah's
laws. Rashi explains that this refers to
adding onto or detracting from a particular Misva. He gives the examples of wearing Tefillin
with parchment containing more or fewer Parashiyot (sections of text) than the
Torah requires. There are four
Parashiyot which are to be inserted in the Tefillin, and if a person adds a
fifth Parasha, then he transgresses the prohibition of "Bal Tosif," and if he
includes only three Parashiyot, then he violates "Bal Tigra." Another example given by Rashi is waving more
than four species on Sukkot, or fewer than four.
The Ramban comments
that the prohibition of "Bal Tosif" includes also introducing a new Misva to
the Torah. If a person comes along and
makes up a new law, claiming that this should be part of the Torah, he violates
the prohibition of "Bal Tosif."
Conversely, one who decides that a certain Biblical command is no longer
part of the Torah transgresses "Bal Tigra."
The Ramban clarifies
that this applies only to one who introduces a new law and claims that it is
obligatory as a Biblical imperative. The
Sages enacted numerous obligations and prohibitions, but they made it very
clear that these are not included in Torah, but are rather provisions that they
saw fit to legislate to meet a particular need.
And, they stipulated that the laws they enacted are treated differently
than the laws of the Torah, with greater leniency. Thus, they do not violate the prohibition of
"Bal Tosif."
The Gaon of Vilna (1720-1797)
brilliantly noted that both interpretations are correct, and rooted in the text
of the Torah. The prohibition of "Bal
Tosif" appears not only here, in Parashat Vaet'hanan, but also later, in
Parashat Re'eh (13:1). However, the
contexts of these verses reveals that they address two different commands. Here in Parashat Vaet'hanan, the command of
"Bal Tosif" appears after Moshe tells the people, "Listen to the statutes and
laws which I am teaching you to observe" (4:1).
Moshe is telling Beneh Yisrael that he was going to present to them the
Misvot, and he then warns them not to add more laws or to reject any of the
laws that he was teaching them. In
Parashat Re'eh, however, Moshe says, "Each thing that I am commanding you – you
shall ensure to observe; do not add onto it, and do not detract from it." It seems clear that in this verse, Moshe
speaks of each particular Misva, urging the people to observe every Misva
precisely as he commands, without adding onto the Misva or taking anything away
from it.
The Ha'ketab
Ve'ha'kabbala (Rav Yaakov Tzvi Mecklenberg, 1785-1865) follows this general
approach of the Vilna Gaon, but he notes a different distinction between the
two verses. The command here in Parashat
Vaet'hanan is formulated in the plural form – "Lo Tosifu…Ve'lo Tigre'u" –
whereas the command in Parashat Re'ei appears in the singular form – "Lo
Tosef…Ve'lo Tigra." The Ha'ketab
Ve'ha'kabbala thus suggests that here in Parashat Vaet'hanan, the Torah is
addressing not an individual, but rather the Sanhedrin, the highest rabbinic
body, which represents the entire nation.
These scholars, the leading Sages of Israel, are the ones who need the
warning not to change the Torah by introducing new laws or doing away with
existing laws. In Parashat Re'eh, by
contrast, the Torah is addressing the individual, who has no authority and
would thus never think to introduce a new Misva, or eliminate a Misva. He needs the warning not to add onto or
detract from specific Misvot, such as by adding an additional Parasha to the
Tefillin or removing a Parasha.
This command reminds
us of the timelessness of the Torah, that at no point does it become "outdated"
or in need of modification. Already from the outset, when the Torah was given,
we are told that it and all its commands are eternal and eternally binding. Today's world is, of course, very different
from the world at the time of Matan Torah, and the changing circumstances may
affect the practical application of certain Misvot, based on the details of
each Misva's requirements as determined by our oral halachic tradition. But never can we say that a Misva is no
longer binding simply by virtue of the fact that many centuries have passed
since the Torah was given. Each and
every Misva is eternally relevant, and we are bound to all the Misvot no less
now than our ancestors were millennia ago.