A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eli Mansour

Torah Lecture

Talk in Yeshiva R. Mordechai Attie, may he live a long and good life.

Lectured by Rabbi Eli Mansour

Published
June 12, 2023
Duration
27:23
Lecture code
REM-SBAM-83-03

Korach, Leadership, and Torah Study

  • The opening derashah examines Korach’s accusation to Moshe and Aharon: “Why do you exalt yourselves over the congregation of ה׳?” Although the Targum presents the words as an accusation of boasting, the Torah had just testified that Moshe was more humble than anyone on earth.
  • The Ketav Sofer explains that Korach’s charge was not necessarily that Moshe and Aharon were personally arrogant; Korach argued that the very fact that they were leaders meant they were exalting themselves over the congregation.
  • This is connected to the Gemara in Megillah, which says that Torah study is greater than saving lives—a statement that seems puzzling because saving a life overrides Shabbat and is of the greatest importance.
  • The Chatam Sofer explains that the Gemara is not instructing someone to study Torah instead of saving a life. Rather, when Heaven assigns someone to save a life, it may assign that task to someone who studies less, allowing a person devoted to Torah study to continue learning while others carry out the rescue.
  • The Chatam Sofer uses this idea to explain the Gemara’s account of Mordechai: Mordechai saved lives, but initially was among the sages appointed there and had a fifth share. His son, the Ketav Sofer, applies the idea to Korach’s words.
  • The opening remarks then connect leadership and fruitful influence to Aharon’s staff. After the Korach episode, each leader brought a staff, and Aharon’s staff blossomed with buds, flowers, and almonds.
  • The almond tree’s wood is weak and unsuitable for durable furniture; a stronger tree, such as an oak, might seem a more fitting sign of strength. More generally, the remarks compare fruit-bearing trees, which are weaker than non-fruit-bearing trees, to the claim that women bear children though they are physically weaker than men.
  • The lesson offered is that one who wants words to bear fruit should be more humble and vulnerable; humility allows words to have an effect.

The Torah and the Land as Two Inheritances

  • Rabbi Mansour notes that it is the twenty-sixth of Sivan, the day Haman’s decrees were annulled, and connects this date with the earlier reference to Mordechai in Tractate Megillah.
  • Although the Jewish people are in exile, the parashah is Shelach Lecha, about the spies. Rabbi Mansour points to two Torah passages that call something an inheritance: “The Torah that Moshe commanded us is the inheritance of the congregation of Yaakov,” and “I will give it to you as an inheritance; I am ה׳.” The Torah and the Land of Israel are both described as inheritances.
  • The Torah has remained with the Jewish people since it was given at Mount Sinai nearly 3,500 years ago. Rabbi Mansour cites the promise, “Even when they are in the land of their enemies, I will not reject them or abhor them, to destroy them and break My covenant with them, for I am ה׳.”
  • The Torah accompanied the people into Babylonia and Europe. Even during the Holocaust, Rabbi Yechezkel Abramsky, of blessed memory, wrote Chazon Yechezkel in the depths of hell.
  • Rabbi Mansour says that “the Night of Broken Glass” is an inadequate description of Kristallnacht, since breaking glass was not the worst crime that night. A thousand synagogues in Germany were burned, as were Torah libraries containing Shas and works of halachic authorities. He describes the perpetrators as descendants of Haman and says they intended to abolish Torah, knowing that without Torah there would be no Jewish people.
  • Despite those attempts, the Torah was never taken from the Jewish people, even for one day; today, it continues to flourish and grow in all its parts.
  • The relationship with the Land of Israel has been different: for most of Jewish history the people were outside the Land, both Temples were destroyed, and the Land lay desolate for nearly 2,000 years. Even now, living there is difficult, with enemies and danger surrounding it.
  • Rabbi Mansour asks why the Torah has been a constant companion while the relationship with the Land has been so difficult. He offers the explanation that the two inheritances were received differently.
  • At Sinai, the people responded to the Torah, “We will do and we will hear.” Rabbi Mansour describes this wholehearted acceptance as something only angels could say: they accepted the Torah because ה׳ said it was good. In his explanation, the Torah has never forgotten that reception, and the people’s acceptance carries the promise that Torah will remain in the mouths of them, their children, and their children’s children until the end of time.
  • The people received the Land differently. They came to Moshe in turmoil, asking to see what the Land was like; after the spies returned with their report about the giants and the fruit, the people wept instead of accepting the Land as they had accepted the Torah. Rabbi Mansour says that the Land is sensitive and remembers this response: unlike the Torah, which protects the people, the Land has continued to hold their initial rejection against them.

Moshe, Yehoshua, and the Sun and Moon

  • Rabbi Mansour connects the two inheritances through the saying that “the face of Moshe was like the face of the sun; the face of Yehoshua was like the face of the moon.”
  • Moshe’s great task was transmitting the Torah: he studied it with ה׳ for forty days and forty nights for that purpose. Yehoshua conquered the Land of Israel.
  • In the explanation Rabbi Mansour cites, the moon has no light of its own and receives light from the sun; without alignment with the sun, it remains dark. So too, the Land of Israel’s light depends on its alignment with Torah.
  • The Torah and the Land therefore cannot be separated: they are two sides of the same coin.

Gladness, Rejoicing, and the Purpose of the Land

  • Rabbi Mansour cites the Vilna Gaon’s distinction between gladness and rejoicing. Gladness belongs to the beginning of a project—such as acquiring land and materials and starting to build—while rejoicing comes at completion, when the work is finished and one can use what has been made.
  • The Vilna Gaon applies this distinction to the prayer, “They are glad as they rise; they rejoice as they come.” The sun is glad as it rises and begins its course, and rejoices when it sets after completing its work.
  • This also explains the words “Rejoice and be glad in the joy of the Torah.” A person rejoices on completing the Torah, such as at a siyum or on Simchat Torah, and then begins studying again; the new beginning brings gladness.
  • Rabbi Mansour applies the distinction to the High Holy Day prayer, “Gladness for Your land, rejoicing for Your city.” Entering the Land of Israel was gladness: after the wilderness, the people had a home and land of their own. It was the beginning of building a life there.
  • The process reached its purpose in Jerusalem, where the Temple stood and “from Zion shall go forth Torah, and the word of ה׳ from Jerusalem.” The purpose of the Land was not simply to plant crops or trees, as in any other country; reaching Jerusalem and the Torah that goes forth from it was the completion, and therefore the rejoicing.

Torah, the Land, and Jewish Peoplehood

  • Rabbi Mansour says that Yehoshua bin Nun, the first conqueror of the Land, wrote Aleinu Leshabeach. In it, Yehoshua says that ה׳ “did not make us like the nations of the lands, nor place us like the families of the earth.”
  • As Rabbi Mansour describes it, nations generally depend on having their own language, customs, and land. He gives the example of Americans: without the United States, he says, they would disperse and eventually be absorbed into other peoples, as happened when Sennacherib mixed up the nations.
  • Yehoshua’s statement means that the Jewish people are different: they do not depend on their land to remain a people, but on the Torah. The proof, Rabbi Mansour says, is that Jews remained a people through the many periods when they lived outside the Land.
  • He adds that the essence of Torah is nevertheless in the Land of Israel. Yehoshua’s testimony is especially meaningful because his own work and risk were devoted to the Land: he spent fourteen years risking his life to conquer and settle it, yet Aleinu Leshabeach says that the Jewish people are not dependent on their land as other nations are.

Repairing the Spies’ Rejection

  • When the Torah and the Land come together, Rabbi Mansour says, this repairs the spies’ evil report and comforts the sensitive Land.
  • The Land is comforted when Jews come to it, are born there, receive it with love, and give up the luxuries and advantages of exile to come with some self-sacrifice. Rabbi Mansour identifies this as a rectification of the spies’ failure to see the Land’s goodness.
  • He recounts that in 1904, at the First Zionist Congress, the possibility of a Jewish home in Uganda was considered because the Land of Israel was difficult to obtain and politically complicated. Uganda was described as beautiful and untroubled, and people were sent to investigate it.
  • Rabbi Mansour presents the proposal as another wound to the Land: it heard that the Jewish people might exchange it for another place and uproot their daughters from it. In his account, the Land remembered this and needed a rectification.
  • He then refers to a 1978 flight to Uganda, to that same place. Rabbi Mansour says that the Land’s rectification required bringing Jews back from the very place once considered as an alternative, and doing so with self-sacrifice. He says that bringing them back to the Land’s borders provided that rectification.
  • Rabbi Mansour concludes that the yeshivah is fortunate to be engaged in Torah study in the Land of Israel and to have both inheritances: “the inheritance of the congregation of Yaakov” and the inheritance of the Land. By seeing the Land’s goodness and combining it with Torah, its students participate in repairing the spies’ failure.
  • He notes that Rabbi Attie had quoted the lunar blessing, “They are glad as they rise to do their work,” just before Rabbi Mansour spoke about “they are glad as they rise.”
  • Rabbi Mansour’s closing blessing is that the yeshivah continue to grow and flourish, and that its wellsprings spread outward, with “Gladness for Your land, rejoicing for Your city, for from Zion shall go forth Torah, and the word of ה׳ from Jerusalem.”
Words in this lecture1
Shasהש"ס
Terms The whole Talmud (from the initials of the six orders).
Also written: HaShas, Ha-Shas