The Gemara (Berachot
60b) teaches that before entering the restroom, one should make a declaration
(beginning with the words "Hitkabedu Mechubadim") asking the angels that
accompany him to wait outside, and to protect him, while he performs his bodily
functions. As the angels do not enter
the restroom, the individual respectfully addresses them before he enters, explaining
that he needs to briefly leave them so he can tend to his bodily needs.
Maran (Rav Yosef Karo,
author of the Shulhan Aruch), in Bet Yosef (Orah Haim 3), cites Rav David
Abudarham (Spain, 14th century) as commenting that this prayer was
instituted only for the exceptionally pious, who are indeed accompanied by
angels wherever they go. For other
people, making this declaration would be a display of arrogance. The Bet Yosef writes that it is thus improper
to make this declaration nowadays, as nobody can honestly claim to have
achieved such spiritual greatness that he is accompanied at all times by
angels. Maran rules accordingly in the
Shulhan Aruch.
By contrast, the Hida
(Rav Haim Yosef David Azulai, 1724-1806) cites the Masat Shimurim (Rav Natan Shapira
of Jerusalem, 17th century) as asserting that this Beracha should be
recited even nowadays, as it helps block harmful spirits and improper thoughts,
thereby assisting a person in maintaining his purity. Additionally, the Hida cites Maharam Papirash
(Rav Meir Poppers, d. 1662) who claimed that the Arizal reinstated the
recitation of this prayer before using the restroom. What's more, Rav Haim Palachi (Turkey, 1788–1868)
notes in his work Ru'ah Haim that the angel who would learn with Maran
instructed him to recite this declaration (Maggid Mesharim, Matot), even though
Maran ruled in the Shulhan Aruch that it should not be said.
The Kaf Ha'haim (Rav Yaakob Haim Sofer, Baghdad-Jerusalem, 1870-1939),
after bringing these sources, concludes that a person who devotes himself
exclusively to Torah study should make this declaration, but all others should
not. He then advances a different
approach, suggesting that since those who discouraged the recitation did so
because it would be a display of arrogance, all people may recite this
declaration when they are in the privacy of their homes, as there is then no
concern of appearing arrogant.
Rav Yaakov Emden (Germany, 1697-1776), cited by the Hida,
claimed that although the Arizal instructed people to recite it, this was only
when people would perform bodily functions outdoors in open fields, where evil
spirits are found, and so even the Arizal would not encourage its recitation
nowadays. And even the Arizal's closest
disciple, Rav Haim Vital (1543-1620), writes (in his commentary to Tehillim)
that the custom is not to recite this declaration. The Hida similarly observes that even
Kabbalists do not make this declaration.
Amidst his discussion of this topic, the Hida cites Rav
Yehiel Kasteltz as challenging the Shulhan Aruch's ruling that this declaration
should not be made. He notes the famous
tradition that we are all accompanied by angels on Friday night as we return
from the synagogue, and they bless us if they see that the home is properly
prepared for Shabbat. It is for this
reason that the "Shalom Alechem" hymn is sung in every Jewish home on Friday
night to welcome the angels. Rav Yehiel
objected to Maran's assumption that people nowadays are not worthy of the
divine presence or of being accompanied by the angels. The Hida responds by sharply criticizing Rav
Yehiel for dismissing Maran's comments, noting that Maran merely observed the
widespread practice not to make this declaration, and offered his
explanation.
As for the angels that accompany us on Friday night, the Ben
Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909), in his Od Yosef Hai, explains
that these angels come not for our honor, but for the honor of Shabbat – just
as Eliyahu Ha'nabi attends every Berit Mila out of respect for this precious
Misva, and not to give honor to the people.
Hence, we are not generally accompanied by angels, but angels join us on
Friday night in honor of the sacred day of Shabbat. Anyone who nowadays feels that he is worthy
of being accompanied by angels is guilty of arrogance.
Interestingly, the Ben
Ish Hai further writes that on Yom Kippur, when our sins are forgiven and we
conduct ourselves on a very high spiritual level, one may make this declaration
before using the restroom, and this would not be a display of arrogance. The Yalkut Yosef observes that from Hacham
Ovadia Yosef's comments in a responsum in his work Yabia Omer, it appears that
he concurred with this view. In
practice, however, Hacham Ovadia was never seen making this declaration, not even
on Yom Kippur.
Regardless, the
widespread custom is not to make this declaration anytime.