One of the most striking aspects of the Tisha B’Ab observance is the omission of the “Tahanunim” prayers. These prayers, which beseech G-d for forgiveness, are omitted on joyous occasions, such as Shabbat and holidays, when it is inappropriate to somberly reflect on our sins and ask that they be forgiven. Surprisingly, they are omitted also on Tisha B’Ab. The Rabbis explain that in Megilat Echa, the book of elegies mourning the destruction of Jerusalem that we read on Tisha B’Ab, the day of the destruction is referred to as a “Mo’ed”: “Kara Alai Mo’ed Lis’shbor Bahurai” (1:15). Therefore, this day is treated like a “Mo’ed” – a festival – in that the “Tahanunim” prayers are omitted.
Many have asked the question of how Tisha B’Ab could possibly be called a “festival.” It is, of course, the saddest day of the year, when we reflect upon and mourn the calamities that G-d brought upon the Jewish People because of our misdeeds. What is “festive” about such a day, when we fast, sit on the floor, and mourn?
The answer emerges from a closer reading of the word “Mo’ed.” The root of this word is “Va’ad” (“Vav,” “Ayin,” “Dalet”), which means “meet.” The Mishkan was called “Ohel Mo’ed,” which means “the tent of meeting,” because it was there where Beneh Yisrael met with Hashem in the closest possible way. The holidays are called “Mo’adim” because they are special occasions when Hashem comes to meet with us. Normally, we are busy with work and our mundane responsibilities. On the holidays, we are freed from our regular routines and obligations so we can “meet” Hashem and spend time building our relationship with Him.
Tisha B’Ab is also a “Mo’ed,” because it is a time when we meet with Hashem.
We might draw an analogy to a company that is falling apart, reporting significant losses. The CEO calls a meeting for all employees, who all fear the worst. They are all but certain that they will be fired, or that the company is filing for bankruptcy and closing down. They arrive a the meeting, and the CEO sternly repudiates the staff for their poor performance, for the mistakes they made that caused the business to nosedive.
As uncomfortable as the meeting is, the employees are elated – because the boss didn’t fire them, because he made it clear to them that he believes that they can right the ship, that he trusts in their ability to get the business back on its feet. The meeting was certainly not a happy one, but the very fact that the meeting happened was a cause of great joy – because it showed that they still had their jobs, that the business wasn’t closing down, that there is hope for recovery.
This is what Tisha B’Ab is. It’s a very difficult and uncomfortable meeting with Hashem. We hear, read about and reflect on the grave mistakes we have made that led to destruction and calamity. But the purpose of this “meeting” is not to “fire” us, but to the contrary – to encourage us, to make us believe that we can do better, that we can fix what is wrong and save the “business.” Tisha B’Ab is a “Mo’ed” because it is a time when we meet with Hashem. The meeting is difficult and uncomfortable, but it also assures us that Hashem still wants a close relationship with us, and trusts that we can become the great nation that we are meant to be.

