The Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909)
writes that mothers should wash the hands of their young children in the
morning – even children who have yet to reach the age of Hinuch (training in
Misva observance). Firstly, he explains,
young children touch food, and if their hands are not washed in the morning,
the foods they touch will become contaminated by the Tum'a (impurity) that
descends upon the hands overnight. Secondly,
washing the hands of young children in the morning has a significant spiritual
impact, as it helps to lead them toward the path of purity and holiness.
By contrast, Rav Shneur Zalman of Liadi (first Rebbe of
Lubavitch, 1745-1812) writes that the hands of young children do not become
impure overnight. Before a youngster
becomes Bar-Misva, Rav Shneur Zalman explains, he does not have a pure Neshama
(soul) that leaves during the night which would cause the forces of impurity to
descend upon him. Therefore, according
to Rav Shneur Zalman, there is no requirement to wash a young child's hands in
the morning. Similarly, the Sitz Eliezer
(Rav Eliezer Waldenberg, Jerusalem, 1915-2006) writes that the prevalent custom
is to be lenient in this regard, and not to ensure to wash the hands of
youngsters below the age of Hinuch.
However, Hacham David Yosef, in Halacha Berura, writes that
nowadays, when washing hands is a very simple matter, there is no valid reason
to be lenient, and parents should ensure to wash the hands of even their young
children.
If a mother is a Nidda, it is preferable for her not to wash
her young children's hands in the morning.
Rav Yisrael Bitan writes that at first glance, we might think to allow
her to wash the children's hands, since this washing is not required according
to the strict Halacha, and so we do not need to treat it stringently. In truth, however, once we have established
that it is proper to satisfy the opinion that impurity indeed descends upon the
hands of young children, the washing should be performed in a manner that
removes the Tum'a without any uncertainty.
Rav Haim Palachi (Turkey, 1788-1868) writes that water poured by a
person who is Tameh cannot remove the Tum'a from the hands, and so when a
mother is a Nidda, the children should pour the water over their hands
themselves if possible, and if not, then the father should pour the water. The water should not be poured by an
unmarried girl who has already reached adolescence, as she, too, is a Nidda. Rav Haim Palachi writes also that the washing
should be done by a Jew, and not by a gentile, such as a non-Jewish housekeeper
or nanny.
The Yalkut Yosef writes that a woman who is a Nidda is
allowed to pour water over her children's hands, citing this ruling in the name
of the Be'er Moshe (Rav Moshe Stern of Debrecen, 1914-1997). The Be'er Moshe reached this conclusion based
on the Halacha permitting a Nidda to pour water on others' hands for Netilat
Yadayim before eating bread, assuming that this should apply as well to the
morning Netilat Yadayim. Rav Yisrael
Bitan noted, however, that the morning hand-washing involves the removal of
impurity, and thus differs from the washing before a meal. As mentioned, several sources indicate that a
person with impurity is incapable of removing the impurity from another
person's hands in the morning. Rav Bitan
thus concluded that although those who wish to be lenient have a basis on which
to rely, it is preferable for a woman who is a Nidda not to wash her children's
hands for them in the morning.
More generally, the Kab Ha'yashar (Rav Tzvi Hersh Kaidanover,
d. 1712) writes that if a person wishes to have somebody else pour the water
over his hands for Netilat Yadayim, he should ensure to have this done by a
G-d-fearing, religiously-devout individual.
The Zohar teaches that each morning, Eliyahu Ha'nabi goes to Me'arat
Ha'machpela to wake up the Abot (patriarchs), and he washes their hands so they
can pray. The fact that Eliyahu was
chosen for this role, the Kab Ha'yashar, writes, shows that washing should be
done by a righteous person.
Rav Bitan emphasized that washing the hands of young
children in the proper way is important for their religious growth. The Shulhan Aruch (Orah Haim 4:18) writes
that failing to observe the requirement of Netilat Yadayim can cause a Torah
scholar to forget the material he has learned.
Rav Haim Palachi explains that Torah knowledge can be acquired only if
one is in a state of holiness, and therefore, one who compromises his holiness
by failing to wash his hands as required cannot retain his Torah knowledge. Indeed,
the letters that precede the letters that spell "Torah" are Shin, Heh, Kof and
Dalet – which spell the word "Kedusha" ("sanctity"). This shows that holiness is a precondition
for Torah. If parents want their
children to absorb Torah and grow in Torah learning and observance, they must
ensure to maintain the children's state of purity, and this necessitates
washing their hands each morning, even when they are very young.
The Hazon Ish (Rav Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, 1878-1953) is said
to have taught that one who seeks to retain his Torah knowledge must ensure to
always speak truthfully, to recite the traditional "Yehi Rason" prayer before
learning, and to meticulously observe the laws of Netilat Yadayim. In fact, it is told that when the Hazon Ish
was a child, his family ensured that all the children had their hands washed in
the morning already from a very young age.
Rav Haim Palachi noted that proper observance of the Netilat
Yadayim requirement also ensures that one will always have a sufficient supply
of water, even in times of drought, and will succeed in maintaining the purity
of his thoughts.
Summary: From a strict Halachic standpoint, it is
questionable whether young children below the age of Hinuch (training in
Misvot) must have their hands washed in the morning. Nevertheless, this should be done, as this
contributes to their spiritual growth. A
woman who is a Nidda – including the mother – should not wash the children's
hands, and neither should a gentile, such as a non-Jewish nanny.