The Gemara in Masechet
Kiddushin (31a) tells that Rav Huna son of Rav Yehoshua made a point of always
keeping his head covered, and he explained that since the Shechina hovered over
his head at all times, it is appropriate to cover one's head as a sign of
respect. This same Rav Huna is cited
elsewhere (Shabbat 118b) as saying that he was worthy of reward for ensuring
never to walk four Amot (cubits) with his hair uncovered.
In a different context
(Shabbat 156b), the Gemara teaches that wearing a hair-covering helps engender
Yir'at Shamayim (fear of Heaven) and thus prevent us from sin. It tells that a woman was warned by
astrologers that her infant son would be a thief as an adult. She understood this to mean that the boy was
born with a natural inclination toward theft.
In an effort to avoid this outcome, she saw to it that the child's head
would always remain covered, so he would be cognizant of Hashem's presence at
all times and thus stay away from sin. In
addition, she fervently prayed to G-d that he would be righteous. Once, the Gemara says, when this boy was
still a child, he was sitting beneath somebody's palm tree learning Torah, and
his head covering blew off. He looked up
and saw a cluster of luscious dates.
Enticed, he ate the dates, which were somebody's private property –
showing how a head covering helps protect a person from the Yeser Ha'ra (evil
inclination). (Thanks to his mother's
efforts, though, this boy grew to become Rav Nahman Bar Yishak, one of the
great Sages of the Talmud.)
Similarly, the Zohar
(Balak 187a) teaches that one must avoid walking more than four Amot with his
head uncovered, because the Shechina hovers over his head. The Zohar adds that this concept is alluded
to in the verse in Kohelet (9:8), "Ve'shemen Al Roshecha al Yehsar" – "Oil
shall not be lacking upon your head." The
Shechina (divine presence) is compared to fire, and Misvot are the "oil," the
fuel that sustains its presence in our lives.
Covering our heads brings us Yir'at Shamayim so that we remain loyal to
G-d's commands. The Zohar reiterates
this point later (Pinhas 245b), citing the verse, "Melo Kol Ha'aretz Kebodo"
(Yeshayahu 6:3) – G-d's glory fills the entire earth. We acknowledge and give honor to His presence
by wearing a head covering.
The Rambam, too, in
his Guide for the Perplexed (3:52), emphasizes that the great Sages
always ensured to cover their heads out of respect for the divine presence.
However, as we know,
there are many otherwise observant Jews (especially in our community) who do
not wear a Kippa all the time. They make
a point of wearing a Kippa when they enter the synagogue, but not throughout
the day when they go about their ordinary affairs. Is this acceptable, or are these individuals
failing to fulfill a Halachic obligation?
This question depends
on whether we regard head-covering as a strict Halachic requirement, or as a
Middat Hasidut – a recommended measure of piety.
The Maharam of
Rothenberg (Germany, c. 1215-1293), cited by the Orhot Haim and Kolbo,
maintained that Halacha does not forbid going about bareheaded, and the Sages
who ensured to have their heads covered did so as a Middat Hasidut. This is also the clear implication of the
Rambam, in the passage cited earlier, where he mentions that great Rabbis made
a point of covering their heads – indicating that this is a recommended measure
of piety, and not a binding Halachic obligation.
The Maharshal (Rav
Shlomo Luria, Poland, 1510-1573) drew proof to this view from a passage in the
Midrash which emphasizes how Hashem deals with us far more kindly than mortal
kings deal with their subjects.
Normally, the Midrash comments, when a king's messenger reads to the
masses a written royal decree, everyone is expected to stand, remove their
hats, and listen with fear and trepidation.
But when we read the Shema in fulfillment of G-d's decree, we are not
required to stand and remove our head coverings. The Midrash here clearly implies that there
would be nothing wrong with baring our heads – even for the recitation of
Shema. The Shebut Yaakov (Rav Yaakov
Reischer, 1661-1733) refutes this proof, noting that the Midrash later observes
that Hashem does not demand that we hunt wild animals to bring them as
sacrifices, but rather commands that we offer as sacrifices domesticated
animals, which do not need to be hunted.
Clearly, this does not mean that it would be acceptable to offer wild
animals as sacrifices. By the same
token, we cannot necessarily deduce from the Midrash that it is acceptable to
recite Shema with our heads uncovered.
Maran (Rav Yosef Caro,
author of the Shulhan Aruch), in Bet Yosef (91), brings the aforementioned
opinion of the Maharam of Rothenberg, that covering one's head is not strictly
required, indicating that he concurred with this view. Elsewhere in Bet Yosef (46), however, Maran
appears to imply otherwise. In
discussing the blessing recited each morning, "Oter Yisrael Be'tif'ara" ("He
who crowns Israel with splendor"), Maran explains that we are "crowned" in the
sense that we, unlike other nations, are required to cover our heads. Maran adds that even those who maintain that
this is not strictly required, agree that it is recommended as an act of
piety. Here Maran clearly sides with the
opinion that head-covering constitutes an outright Halachic obligation.
Regardless, the Hida
(Rav Haim Yosef David Azulai, 1724-1806) noted that in the Shulhan Aruch, Maran
takes the position that covering one's head is recommended but not strictly
required. In Siman 2, the Shulhan Aruch
writes that "it is forbidden" to walk about "Be'koma Zekufa" – completely
upright, appearing proud and overly confident.
In the same sentence, the Shulhan Aruch writes that "one should not walk
four Amot with his head bare." When it
comes to "Koma Zekufa," the Shulhan Aruch uses the word "Assur" ("It is
forbidden"), whereas regarding walking bareheaded, he writes simply that this
should not be done. It would thus appear
that although it is proper to wear a head-covering, this is not strictly
required.
However, the Taz (Rav
David Ha'levi Segal, 1586-1667) writes that even assuming that head-covering
was practiced in ancient times only as a Middat Hasidut, in modern times this
has become a strict Halachic obligation.
The Taz explains that since the Christians are accustomed to walk about
bareheaded, doing so violates the prohibition of "Hukot Ha'akum" – following gentile
practices. Hence, in the view of the
Taz, one is required to wear a Kippa nowadays in order to avoid transgressing
the Biblical prohibition of "Hukot Ha'akum."
Hacham Ovadia Yosef
disputes this claim. Based on the
comments of the Mahari Kolon (Rav Yosef Kolon, d. 1480), Hacham Ovadia writes
that one transgresses the prohibition of "Hukot Ha'akum" only if he does
something with the specific intention of imitating gentile practices and
resembling a non-Jew. If a person
decides to leave his head uncovered in the interest of comfort, this does not
violate the prohibition.
Nevertheless, in a
famous responsum in Yehaveh Da'at, Hacham Ovadia writes that nowadays, one is
required to wear a Kippa, for a different reason – because this has become the
"badge" or symbol of an observant Jewish man.
By wearing a Kippa, one identifies himself as a member of the population
of G-d-fearing Jews. Conversely, one who
chooses not to wear a Kippa presents himself as being non-observant, thereby
inviting suspicion, and for this reason, wearing a Kippa has today become an
obligation.
It seems, however,
that this applies only in Israel, where the decision of whether or not to cover
one's head is the clear marker of one's self-identification as religious or
secular. Here in the United States, however,
at least in some communities, this is not the case, and it is known that not
all observant Jews ensure to keep their heads covered at all times. Therefore, while it is certainly preferred
and advisable to wear a Kippa – and where a person fears antisemitism, he can
wear a cap instead of, or over, his Kippa – one who wishes to leave his head
uncovered has a basis on which to rely. (Indeed,
in the school where I work, I advise the members of the basketball team to
leave their Kippot off during games, because the Kippa would interfere with
their playing; since the Kippa is not required as a strict obligation, it may
certainly be removed for this purpose.)
Nevertheless, wearing
a Kippa when eating, praying, reciting Berachot and learning Torah is strictly
required. Of course, one must wear a
Kippa in the synagogue. In the presence
of a Rabbi, it is proper to wear a Kippa in the interest of Derech Eretz
(common courtesy). When a person wishes
to fulfill the requirement of a Beracha by listening to its recitation by
somebody else, he must wear a Kippa even though he remains silent, because he
is considered as actually reciting the Beracha by listening to his fellow.