Before one learns
Torah in the morning, he must first recite Birkot Ha'Torah. The Gemara cites different opinions as to
which particular subjects within the broad corpus of Torah may not be studied
before the recitation of Birkot Ha'Torah.
Rav Huna maintained that only the study of Tanach requires Birkot
Ha'Torah; in his view, one may study anything else before reciting Birkot
Ha'Torah in the morning. Rabbi Elazar
ruled that both Tanach and Midrash require Birkot Ha'Torah, because the Midrash
explains the verses of the Tanach. The
next opinion brought is that of Rabbi Yohanan, who held that even the study of
Mishna must be preceded by Birkot Ha'Torah.
However, Halacha follows the final view brought by the Gemara – that of
Raba, who asserted that even Gemara requires Birkot Ha'Torah. Accordingly, the Rambam and Shulhan Aruch
write that one must recite Birkot Ha'Torah before studying either Tanach or any
part of Torah She'be'al Peh (the oral law).
Although the Shulhan Aruch does not specify the study of Midrash, the
Rama (Rav Moshe Isserles of Cracow, 1520-1572) adds that Midrash also requires
the recitation of Birkot Ha'Torah. The
Peri Hadash (Rav Hizkiya Da Silva, 1659-1698) writes that the Shulhan Aruch
does not disagree with the Rama on this point, even though he did not
specifically mention Midrash.
The Aruch Ha'shulhan
(Rav Yehiel Michel Epstein of Nevardok, 1829-1908) notes the possibility of
restricting this requirement to areas related to Halacha. It is possible, he writes, that Birkot
Ha'Torah is required only before the study of texts that form the basis of
Halacha. The Sages infer Halachot from
the verses, and these inferences and their applications are discussed,
elucidated and debated in the Midrash, Mishna and Gemara – and it might be for
this reason that these texts are specified as the material requiring Birkot
Ha'Torah. If so, then one would be
permitted to study non-halachic portions of the Torah – such as the stories in
Midrashic texts, Aggadic portions of the Gemara, and Zohar – before reciting
Birkot Ha'Torah in the morning. The
Aruch Ha'shulhan remains uncertain about this matter.
By contrast, the Kaf
Ha'haim Sofer (Rav Yaakob Haim Sofer, Baghdad-Jerusalem, 1870-1939) writes that
the study of the Zohar requires Birkot Ha'Torah. He does not explain the reason for this
ruling, but we may presume that he equated the study of Zohar with the study of
Gemara, and, moreover, we occasionally determine practical Halacha based on teachings
in the Zohar.
The final Halacha is
that even the study of non-halachic texts such as the Midrash and Zohar requires
Birkot Ha'Torah.
The study of works of
Mussar also requires Birkot Ha'Torah, because these works are based upon Torah
sources. Texts such as Mesilat Yesharim
and Michtab Me'Eliyahu, which guide and instruct how to live a religious life,
are rooted entirely in Torah, and so they certainly qualify as parts of Torah
requiring the recitation of Birkot Ha'Torah.
This applies to works of Hassidic teachings, as well.
In principle,
biographies of Sadikim, or story books that tell about the lives of great
Sages, may be read before Birkot Ha'Torah, because reading these stories –
despite being very valuable – does not qualify as the study of Torah. In practice, however, books about great
Rabbis almost invariably contain Torah insights which they taught, and so they
require Birkot Ha'Torah.
One is not required to
recite Birkot Ha'Torah before studying general subjects, even those subjects
which have great value and are important to learn. For example, one must study math in order to
properly understand certain sections of the Gemara, such as those which deal
with geometry (e.g. Sukka, Erubin and Kil'ayim). There are texts which address the dimensions
and layout of the Bet Ha'mikdash which similarly cannot be understood without a
background in mathematics. Scientific
knowledge, too, is critically important for the understanding of certain
sections of the Talmud – such as the Gemara's discussion about the volume of
wine which a Nazir must drink to be liable for violating his vow, which touches
upon the subject of volume displacement.
This issue requires an understanding of how displacement works, and how
the density of wine becomes a factor. One
cannot understand the portions of the Talmud that deal with the Jewish calendar
without basic knowledge of astronomy. An
understanding of modern technology, too, is necessary for learning how Halacha
applies in our time, and indeed, Hacham Ovadia Yosef studied the mechanics of
boilers in order to determine the relevant Halachot. Nevertheless, the study of these subjects
does not require Birkot Ha'Torah, since they are not actual Torah, but rather
background information to help in the study of Torah. The Rambam writes that subjects such as
mathematics and science are the "chefs" and "maidservants" of Torah, meaning,
they are necessary for the understanding of Torah, but are not part of
Torah. Therefore, one is not required to
recite Birkot Ha'Torah before studying general subjects.
Summary: One may not
learn any Torah subject before reciting Birkot Ha'Torah in the morning. This includes Tanach, Midrash, Mishna,
Gemara, Halachic texts, Zohar, Mussar and Hassidut. Biographies of Sadikim, too, require Birkot
Ha'Torah since they usually incorporate Torah insights by the Sages whose lives
and legacy they present. Birkot Ha'Torah
is not required before the study of non-Torah subjects, even those which are
necessary to learn to properly understand Torah.