Keeping Tefillin On Through Aleinu
- Rabbi Mansour says the ideal is to wear Tefillin throughout Shaharit, from the beginning of the Berachot until after Aleinu. He notes that many authorities regard this as a halachic preference, not merely a stringency of the righteous.
- Tefillin express the bond with Hashem physically, spiritually, and publicly.
- The Mekubalim teach that the sections of Tefilla correspond to progressively higher spiritual worlds. Keeping Tefillin on through Aleinu allows their sanctity to accompany the entire ascent; removing them earlier may disrupt the flow of the Misva and signal a “spiritual descent” before Tefilla is complete.
Removing Tefillin Early for Discomfort or Health
- A person may remove Tefillin before Aleinu, including after the Amidah or earlier, if wearing them causes discomfort or a medical concern, such as headaches, tight straps, nausea or stomach weakness, skin sensitivity, or pressure points.
- Rabbi Mansour says it is fully permissible to remove them early in these cases.
- Hacham Ovadia Yosef writes that the Misva of Tefillin should be performed with joy and dignity, not discomfort or pain; one should not endure physical suffering just to maintain the ideal duration.
Tefillin During Keri'at HaTorah
- Many people remove Tefillin before the Torah reading on Mondays and Thursdays, but Rabbi Mansour says this is not ideal unless the synagogue has a strong custom to do so.
- If possible, one should keep Tefillin on through Keri'at HaTorah, whose holiness matches that of Tefillin. One receiving an Aliyah should wear Tefillin while standing next to the Sefer Torah.
- If wearing them feels uncomfortable or awkward—especially where the community expects them to be removed—one may remove them just before the Aliyah. Ideally, one should step to the side or wait until the Sefer Torah is covered before removing them.

