A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eliezer Zeytouneh

Torah Lecture

Daily Advice: You Ain’t No Judge!

Lectured by Rabbi Eliezer Zeytouneh

Published
July 23, 2025
Duration
4:04
Lecture code
RZE-DA-14

The Limits of Personal Judgment

  • Rabbi Eliezer Zeytouneh says people judge constantly, including from how someone sits, looks, dresses, speaks, prays, behaves, and raises children.
  • He cites the Chafetz Chaim’s point that judging people in this way is not our place. An individual is not a Beit Din, even if he is a great judge; a private verdict or label does not amount to a Beit Din’s judgment.
  • Rabbi Zeytouneh says Borei Olam is the ultimate judge, and a Beit Din can consider the facts. He refers to the mitzvah of B'tzedek Tishpot Amitecha (“Judge your fellow righteously”) and says a judgment requires putting the relevant facts and considerations into play. He also says that “when you're alone, you have an obligation,” while stressing that you are not a Beit Din.

Not Knowing the Whole Story

  • Seeing someone come to shul, hearing him talk, or observing his conduct does not reveal his whole story. Rabbi Zeytouneh repeats that a person does not know another person’s beginnings or all the “pit stops” in between.
  • This is especially difficult in close communities, including Brooklyn and Jersey, where people live near one another. Even with a short distance between neighbors—he mentions a 20-foot perimeter—a person may see what someone does without knowing the context.
  • Familiarity can give someone some knowledge of where another person started; perhaps, for example, the person does not know how to pray. But that still does not mean one knows the whole story.
  • Rabbi Zeytouneh raises the objection, “But, Rabbi, I saw the charlatan,” while returning to the point that seeing something does not necessarily give a person all the facts needed to judge.

Righteous Judgment and One’s Own Conduct

  • B'tzedek Tishpot Amitecha is the mitzvah at issue, but Rabbi Zeytouneh cautions against treating it as permission to pass judgment on people’s character or actions without knowing their circumstances.
  • He says a person should be simple and wholehearted—Tamim Tihyeh, Im Hashem Elokecha (“You shall be wholehearted with Hashem your God”)—and places ultimate judgment with Borei Olam.
  • This does not mean being blind: when it comes to defending yourself, you should defend yourself. Rabbi Zeytouneh distinguishes that from judging or branding another person.